General Discussion

winter is coming

(11,785 posts)

7. Whoosh.

Reply to muriel_volestrangler (Reply #5)

Tue Jun 3, 2014, 10:11 AM

Jun 2014

Your first link is about modern EU governments, not all present-day governments. Not sure what you think is so off-base about them being in the upper right quandrant.

Your second link shows that Barack Obama and Mitt Romney basically have identical positions.

And implying that the poll isn't skewed because almost all DUers end up in the same quadrant is a total logic fail.

This quiz only measures along two axes. If there are things that separate people that aren't accounted for in those questions, the poll is no more meaningful than a Cosmo quiz.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

38 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

authoritarian, libertarian, right, left-- what quadrant of the Political Compass are you in? [View all] carolinayellowdog Jun 2014 OP

I've taken that test a few times over the years. The_Commonist Jun 2014 #1

I've also done it a few times, always in the green tularetom Jun 2014 #2

What is called "libertarian" here could be better classified as respect for basic human rights. Tommy_Carcetti Jun 2014 #9

Yeah, I'm always near -7 & -7. "Libertarian" is a slur in DU... Eleanors38 Jun 2014 #19

Thanks to Ron Paul and his calf head son, Libertarian, with the big L, is taking a beating. Whisp Jun 2014 #20

I still like the terms "civil libertarian" and "economic progressive," Eleanors38 Jun 2014 #22

I agree with your overall point that the terms authoritarian and libertarian are overused on DU stevenleser Jun 2014 #3

Not sure why you believe this test gives an accurate or meaningful result. winter is coming Jun 2014 #4

"probably still skews that way" is an unjustified assumption of yours muriel_volestrangler Jun 2014 #5

Whoosh. winter is coming Jun 2014 #7

I never said there was anything 'off-base' about putting them upper-right muriel_volestrangler Jun 2014 #15

You're right. I should have dug a little deeper before commenting. winter is coming Jun 2014 #18

Do you really think Obama took this test or the pope Johonny Jun 2014 #36

developed by a leftist British social historian and political journalist carolinayellowdog Jun 2014 #6

This message was self-deleted by its author LeftishBrit Jun 2014 #11

I don't think so LeftishBrit Jun 2014 #12

I do wish they had defined the terms instead of merely using them. winter is coming Jun 2014 #14

I was a political compass quiz virgin... DreamGypsy Jun 2014 #8

Good point about "strongly" term. Eleanors38 Jun 2014 #21

In the UK, 'libertarian' used to mean civil libertarian, and economic libertarianism was called LeftishBrit Jun 2014 #10

It's the same in the US. What we have here is an intersection of ignorance and duplicity. Romulox Jun 2014 #31

Economic -7.5; Social -6.82 LeftishBrit Jun 2014 #13

The simple problem my friend is this Savannahmann Jun 2014 #16

all good points, thanks, perhaps "authoritarian" implies more consistency than is appropriate carolinayellowdog Jun 2014 #28

A little to the left & a touch more "libertarian" than Gandhi... Eleanors38 Jun 2014 #17

That's a fascinating ngram. woo me with science Jun 2014 #23

thanks, inspired by your previous posts about "authoritarian" as a term carolinayellowdog Jun 2014 #24

Ah yes, the Nolan chart, again. ucrdem Jun 2014 #25

Kicked and recommended. Uncle Joe Jun 2014 #26

Lefty me damnedifIknow Jun 2014 #27

Hrm. have I changed? I moved further left? Xyzse Jun 2014 #29

Same place as always MicaelS Jun 2014 #30

Left Libertarian hack89 Jun 2014 #32

So many DUers tend toward that top right quadrant. Can't we just ban the word "authoritarian"? nt Romulox Jun 2014 #33

Economic Left/Right: -9.50 Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -8.97 frylock Jun 2014 #34

Everytime I take it, I end up somewhere between -9.50 and -10.00 on both axes. NuclearDem Jun 2014 #35

About what I expected opiate69 Jun 2014 #37

Libertarian in the U.S. is RIGHT-WING kfreed Aug 2014 #38