Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Here's The Heartbreaking Reality For Thousands Of Kids Who Have Entered The US Illegally [View all]JustAnotherGen
(38,131 posts)68. Not the Haitians
http://gbgm-umc.org/response/articles/haiti.html
My friend Mryna's imediate family just got lucky. And they had to go to Italy first - this was back in the 80's.
We turned a boat full of Jewish refugees away.
We haven't always helped refugees.
And then thinking of the "narrative" of our media during the aftermath of Katrina - we couldn't even help our "supposed" internal "refugees".
We truly are talking about mass orphanages here. A radical expansion of our public schools. When it hits the average Republican's property taxes (our prop taxes go towards education in NJ) - they are going to flip. So what other services are we going to have cut?
It would be immoral to keep these kids permanently detained. They are going to need orphanages that can handle their needs and give them some kind of normalcy. And adoption is out of the question. I consider the foster to adoption "product" a part of the fertility industrial complex . . . Having seen three couples go through that and who have warned my husband and me to avoid it at all costs and adoption in general at all costs - the families that can afford it without state help are probably going to hesitate.
Those aren't abandoned, neglected and abused kids. Their parents loved them soooo much they put them on this path. They are going to want their children back the first chance they get.
My friend Mryna's imediate family just got lucky. And they had to go to Italy first - this was back in the 80's.
We turned a boat full of Jewish refugees away.
We haven't always helped refugees.
And then thinking of the "narrative" of our media during the aftermath of Katrina - we couldn't even help our "supposed" internal "refugees".
We truly are talking about mass orphanages here. A radical expansion of our public schools. When it hits the average Republican's property taxes (our prop taxes go towards education in NJ) - they are going to flip. So what other services are we going to have cut?
It would be immoral to keep these kids permanently detained. They are going to need orphanages that can handle their needs and give them some kind of normalcy. And adoption is out of the question. I consider the foster to adoption "product" a part of the fertility industrial complex . . . Having seen three couples go through that and who have warned my husband and me to avoid it at all costs and adoption in general at all costs - the families that can afford it without state help are probably going to hesitate.
Those aren't abandoned, neglected and abused kids. Their parents loved them soooo much they put them on this path. They are going to want their children back the first chance they get.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
69 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Here's The Heartbreaking Reality For Thousands Of Kids Who Have Entered The US Illegally [View all]
xchrom
Jun 2014
OP
We need to ship them home and do a better job stopping them at the border. nt
Demo_Chris
Jun 2014
#1
Since neither of your suggestions will ever be implemented, let alone in the next month, Plan B = ?
WinkyDink
Jun 2014
#9
It can be both a refugee crisis and an illegal immigrant crisis. In any case...
Demo_Chris
Jun 2014
#13
Even if you take away the drugs, it won't be poines and rainbows in Latin America
Art_from_Ark
Jun 2014
#69
You answered that you would favor dropping children in the desert or a crime riddled city.
morningfog
Jun 2014
#59
"Ship them anywhere"? These are kids -- You're certainly not Mr. Compassion, are you?
whathehell
Jun 2014
#51
"It is not our job to feed, shelter, clothe, educate, or heal the world's poor."
alp227
Jun 2014
#63
Yes. How can a Democrat be so cold-hearted and inhumane? We should figure
Louisiana1976
Jun 2014
#33
So now what? The U.S. needs to end Latin American poverty? How about the L.A. oligarchy acting?
WinkyDink
Jun 2014
#11
And your solution is what? Import the world's poor and all starve together? nt
Demo_Chris
Jun 2014
#16
Well, short of some never-going-to-happen complete overhaul of Latin America, what would you
WinkyDink
Jun 2014
#8
Why is the US taxpayer obligated to subsidize the dysfunction of other countries?
Throd
Jun 2014
#20
Looks like the right wing media strategy of pitting the 99% against each other has worked.
alp227
Jun 2014
#64
Wow! They're going to have a terrible effect on our country. Just like the Irish, Germans, Jews,
Tierra_y_Libertad
Jun 2014
#32