Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Give Obama Credit: Drones Are Better Than Boots [View all]freshwest
(53,661 posts)42. That is a thought provoking piece there. I am thinking about your excerpt:
'...forfeit their right to be protected by sovereignty, as they cannot first violate sovereignty and then ask to be protected by it...'
I agreed, then guessed the next argument to be made is that, in assisting allies to maintain their society, civil or not, is the worth of supporting them. They are often not respected or trusted by Americans online. In fact, we could argue endlessly 'whose' ally they really are.
I feel some objections are that we are trespassing on the sovereignty of the nation who requested or allowed the USA to fly drones over their territory. Because by our own standards, those governments are not legitimate, while some would gloss over the merit or legitimacy of ISIS - ISIL. as they appear to be acting as the avengers of Saddam Hussein, who many say should have been left in place, massacres and all, to spare us going into Iraq in the first place.
There is a sloppiness in the assertion that neither us nor the drones are not welcome in other countries.
At times DUers applaud the use of drones, even lethal ones, if it is used for causes they support. Such as Sea Shepherd using them to find Japanese whalers, drones to kill elephant poachers, or this morning OP of using them to watch farms for animal abuse.
One of the most prolific live streaming reporters named Tim in NYC following Occupy made a video of a drone he made to fly about and record events. Surviellance by one side okay but not by the other.
I think for some, it's more the feeling of nothing between one and the sun, moon and stars; living in a state of nature of a sort countless humans have throughout our history, and prehistorically, is being taken away from us. That we are unwillingly becoming part of a technocratic global grid that cannot be trusted and dp not respect us.
But many people in the world are eager to build this grid. Those who are not, are called terrorists by some for not modernizing in culture amd accepting change to go along. And I think that is what is driving some of the extremists, their fight against science and universality in culture, and we are conflicted.
Not all change is positive, nor is all tradition. Just ruminating here as I woke up in too much pain to sleep. This thread is a good opening to thinking about why drones exist.
I agreed, then guessed the next argument to be made is that, in assisting allies to maintain their society, civil or not, is the worth of supporting them. They are often not respected or trusted by Americans online. In fact, we could argue endlessly 'whose' ally they really are.
I feel some objections are that we are trespassing on the sovereignty of the nation who requested or allowed the USA to fly drones over their territory. Because by our own standards, those governments are not legitimate, while some would gloss over the merit or legitimacy of ISIS - ISIL. as they appear to be acting as the avengers of Saddam Hussein, who many say should have been left in place, massacres and all, to spare us going into Iraq in the first place.
There is a sloppiness in the assertion that neither us nor the drones are not welcome in other countries.
At times DUers applaud the use of drones, even lethal ones, if it is used for causes they support. Such as Sea Shepherd using them to find Japanese whalers, drones to kill elephant poachers, or this morning OP of using them to watch farms for animal abuse.
One of the most prolific live streaming reporters named Tim in NYC following Occupy made a video of a drone he made to fly about and record events. Surviellance by one side okay but not by the other.
I think for some, it's more the feeling of nothing between one and the sun, moon and stars; living in a state of nature of a sort countless humans have throughout our history, and prehistorically, is being taken away from us. That we are unwillingly becoming part of a technocratic global grid that cannot be trusted and dp not respect us.
But many people in the world are eager to build this grid. Those who are not, are called terrorists by some for not modernizing in culture amd accepting change to go along. And I think that is what is driving some of the extremists, their fight against science and universality in culture, and we are conflicted.
Not all change is positive, nor is all tradition. Just ruminating here as I woke up in too much pain to sleep. This thread is a good opening to thinking about why drones exist.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
114 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Better why? So we can covertly kill at will, minimizing blowback and costs at home?
TheKentuckian
Jun 2014
#19
Like coffee without caffeine. You can drink it all day and not get the shits.
Gravitycollapse
Jun 2014
#41
And what about the violence, oppression, dislocation, and murder carried ouy by ISIS?
cheapdate
Jun 2014
#72
What about the violence, oppression, dislocation, disenfranchisement, and murder of the puppet
TheKentuckian
Jun 2014
#78
drones just give the illusion of clean hands. WE are the merchants of their misdeeds
bigtree
Jun 2014
#24
Yes, by attempting a lame and disgustingly invalid "lesser of two evils" argument,
woo me with science
Jun 2014
#44
With all this predictability, you should change your name to Miss Cleo.
Michigander_Life
Jun 2014
#51
Wow. "In the mean time, those of us who aren't blinded by racism...."
woo me with science
Jun 2014
#52
Do you deny that PBO has been attacked by racists since his presidency began?
Michigander_Life
Jun 2014
#54
Collective psychological punishment of entire villages and regions (http://www.livingunderdrones.org
woo me with science
Jun 2014
#70
As Slavoj Zizek puts it, this is like coffee without the caffeine, soda without the sugar...
Gravitycollapse
Jun 2014
#40
How does a surveillance camera read the text messages on your phone as you peruse through a store?
Michigander_Life
Jun 2014
#61
Surely there is an immeasurable amount of intelligence proceeding drone strikes
Michigander_Life
Jun 2014
#66
They remember, they just want everyone else to forget so they can spin the fairy tales of goodness
TheKentuckian
Jun 2014
#76
If a country is going to insist on waging war, then it damend well SHOULD cost that country!
markpkessinger
Jun 2014
#112