Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

JDPriestly

(57,936 posts)
17. The list of Palestinian attacks on civilians is very long.
Mon Aug 4, 2014, 07:36 PM
Aug 2014

Israel is in the tradition of Abraham as are Muslims and Christians.

Abraham, if you remember, was asked to sacrifice his child to God. God interrupted Abraham's ritual sacrifice and substituted an animal in the place of the child.

Eric Auerbach wrote a book called Mimesis which is an excellent book of literary criticism. In writing about the story of Abraham, Auerbach explains that its significance is in the fact that , first, God speaks to a human being and second, that God rejects human sacrifice. That was a milestone in our civilization in valuing human life above all else.

I differ with the speaker in the video on one point. I think that when this story is fully told, we will realize that, and I point this out again, when faced with deaths of Israelis due to suicide bombers and other bombs within Israel, Israel built a wall to keep bombers out. When rockets were sent to kill and injure Israelis, Israel built a missile shield at incredible expense. The wall and the missile shield were defense tactics. They were not weapons to be used in offense.

But Palestinians still wanted to attack Israelis, so they built tunnels in order to circumvent the peaceful defenses of Israel. The deaths we see are horrible. They should not happen. But neither should Palestinians be placing bombs in Israel or shooting rockets into Israel or building tunnels into Israel.

Israel is trying to defend its people. Is Palestine? I think that the Palestinians risk the lives of the Palestinian people with their rockets and bombs and tunnels. Why are they attacking Israel?

The land was acquired by Israel when Palestine attacked Israel and lost. Israel could easily give the land back if Palestinians gave Israel peace.

Israel's weakness is its adherence to the Abrahamic value of protecting the lives of its people. The Muslims and Christians in Palestine share that same Abrahamic tradition.

As I see it, Israel has tried to defend itself without taking Palestinian lives, but the Palestinians have found a new way to attack Israel and to defy each defense system.

Sorry, but the Palestinians need to value the lives of their people more than their homeland. When they do, they will have their homeland back. There will be room enough for all.

The killings are tragic and very horrible. But they do not tell the whole story in my opinion.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

An Auschwitz Survivor speaks about Palestine [View all] Douglas Carpenter Aug 2014 OP
Well, I agree with this man. upaloopa Aug 2014 #1
Sadly, a lot of us agree with him Warpy Aug 2014 #2
K&R nt alsame Aug 2014 #3
A voice of reason stating the obvious. K&R Tierra_y_Libertad Aug 2014 #4
K&R closeupready Aug 2014 #5
A sad K&R Garthem Aug 2014 #6
Thank You !! abakan Aug 2014 #7
Well at least no one can easily criticize an Auschwitz survivor..... DeSwiss Aug 2014 #8
Even those who DO see this - most will dismiss it out of hand. Plucketeer Aug 2014 #10
If your Congressdunce watches FOX...... DeSwiss Aug 2014 #21
so far no one has, but it wouldn't surprise me one bit Douglas Carpenter Aug 2014 #18
I think the tide is starting to turn. n/t DeSwiss Aug 2014 #22
K&R valerief Aug 2014 #9
Very well said tom_kelly Aug 2014 #11
He's exactly right! santamargarita Aug 2014 #12
There is often a big difference PatSeg Aug 2014 #13
indeed Douglas Carpenter Aug 2014 #20
K&R McCamy Taylor Aug 2014 #14
I'm so touched libodem Aug 2014 #15
I hope any one who allows his frustration with Bibi cross into anti-semitism sees this Jack Rabbit Aug 2014 #16
The list of Palestinian attacks on civilians is very long. JDPriestly Aug 2014 #17
Israeli attacks on Civilians so outnumber Palestinian attacks the numbers are so lopsided Douglas Carpenter Aug 2014 #19
And yet, there is no answer but to negotiate peace. JDPriestly Aug 2014 #24
Here is a very sensible conversation representing both side of the argument Douglas Carpenter Aug 2014 #25
Well. They have to negotiate. There is no other choice. JDPriestly Aug 2014 #26
But why would anyone want to raise their children in Israel. It is a place of hate. underthematrix Aug 2014 #28
Dr. Hajo Meyer is sadly exactly correct on what Israel has become: The Second Stone Aug 2014 #23
A few salient points absent from that: Spider Jerusalem Aug 2014 #32
I agree. Uncle Joe Aug 2014 #27
K&R woo me with science Aug 2014 #29
Deeply moving and so on point. snagglepuss Aug 2014 #30
knr Douglas Carpenter Aug 2014 #31
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»An Auschwitz Survivor spe...»Reply #17