Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

BainsBane

(53,180 posts)
Mon Aug 25, 2014, 08:23 PM Aug 2014

On Marx and Leftism [View all]


25 votes, 2 passes | Time left: Unlimited
I consider myself a leftist, have read Marx, and support many of his core principals
12 (48%)
I consider myself a leftist, have read Marx, but do not support his core principals
1 (4%)
I consider myself a leftist and have never read Marx
2 (8%)
I consider myself a centrist and have read Marx
1 (4%)
I consider myself a centrist and have not read Marx
1 (4%)
Marx is irrelevant to my concetpion of leftist politics
5 (20%)
I consider myself a leftist, have read Marx, and support some of his ideas/analysis
3 (12%)
Show usernames
Disclaimer: This is an Internet poll
107 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
On Marx and Leftism [View all] BainsBane Aug 2014 OP
I concur with his analysis of capitalism leftstreet Aug 2014 #1
That capitalism is exploitative by nature BainsBane Aug 2014 #4
Right. That came from his analysis leftstreet Aug 2014 #6
It is an ideology that frames how one understands society BainsBane Aug 2014 #9
Right leftstreet Aug 2014 #11
OK, I think we can more or less agree on that. Now what? Adrahil Aug 2014 #106
I've read The Communist Manifesto a few times and do support some of his principles. TexasTowelie Aug 2014 #2
You don't think one conveys that? BainsBane Aug 2014 #3
Check my ETA. TexasTowelie Aug 2014 #7
I see BainsBane Aug 2014 #8
When Marx and his followers call for the 'elimination of private property,' it is VanGoghRocks Aug 2014 #51
Private property is itself a creation of capitalism BainsBane Aug 2014 #56
Private property was around way before capitalism started muriel_volestrangler Aug 2014 #61
That is not true BainsBane Aug 2014 #65
As an example, the Roman Republic had ownership of land muriel_volestrangler Aug 2014 #70
That could well be BainsBane Aug 2014 #84
Why are you 'certain' of that? muriel_volestrangler Aug 2014 #87
Do you know of documentation of land sales BainsBane Aug 2014 #100
yes: muriel_volestrangler Aug 2014 #102
ummm... the concept of a free holding yeoman or franklin pre-exists the Early-Modern period.... Adrahil Aug 2014 #98
holding land is not owning land. There is a key distinction, as I already made clear. BainsBane Aug 2014 #101
Medieval free-holders DID own their land. Adrahil Aug 2014 #107
Thank you for making that distinguishment between private and personal property. TexasTowelie Aug 2014 #57
Wow, this is a big topic to get into here and maybe not well-suited to this forum. Here's what I can VanGoghRocks Aug 2014 #64
Thanks for the explanation. TexasTowelie Aug 2014 #86
I don't think "From each according to his ability, to each according to his need" is a nomorenomore08 Aug 2014 #5
What is your issue with it, if you're willing to share? Shankapotomus Aug 2014 #12
I said it's NOT a fundamentally bad idea. nomorenomore08 Aug 2014 #15
lol Sorry nt Shankapotomus Aug 2014 #18
That's okay. Didn't mean to snap at you. nomorenomore08 Aug 2014 #19
No worries Shankapotomus Aug 2014 #45
It's never worked when tried. 3rdwaydem Aug 2014 #13
Depends what you mean by "tried." Many would argue that most self-proclaimed Communist regimes nomorenomore08 Aug 2014 #16
because its not realistic. There's no legitimate provision for individual CAG Aug 2014 #20
Very well put CAG! 3rdwaydem Aug 2014 #23
/ignore [n/t] Maedhros Aug 2014 #68
while I agree with what you are saying, I wonder why I don't consider myself a centrist Tuesday Afternoon Aug 2014 #25
It's not either/or. In fact, there is arguably almost no country that is purely capitalist *or* nomorenomore08 Aug 2014 #44
capitalism is based on greed and explitation of labor BainsBane Aug 2014 #46
On those points I am in complete agreement with you. TexasTowelie Aug 2014 #60
If anything leads to "utter corruption and perversion" TBF Aug 2014 #52
Nonsense. The only proscription is against owning OTHER PEOPLE'S means of production eridani Aug 2014 #58
Thats just silly CAG Aug 2014 #59
What's silly about it? eridani Aug 2014 #63
and what are all of those "business partners" supposed to do for money CAG Aug 2014 #80
We've never had publicly owned banks before either eridani Aug 2014 #83
Look! Republican talking points on DU! Maedhros Aug 2014 #67
oh, for god's sake, democrats can't be capitalists now???? CAG Aug 2014 #76
I suspect Elizabeth Warren would agree with my statements, does that make CAG Aug 2014 #82
Star Trek is set in a socialist\communist milieu. (Ever see any money changing hands VanGoghRocks Aug 2014 #69
I was unaware Star Trek was non-fiction and described a real-world, er, CAG Aug 2014 #77
Come on, CAG, where's your imagination? Star Trek is the 'history of the VanGoghRocks Aug 2014 #79
Live long and prosper.... but don't prosper too much, you might be CAG Aug 2014 #81
Oddly enough, I was reading some commentary on the Lubbock Avalanche-Journal TexasTowelie Aug 2014 #88
Because so many Russians are clamoring for the return of the Czar. Viva VanGoghRocks Aug 2014 #66
It is particularly dangerous to progressivism Puzzledtraveller Aug 2014 #91
As an idea it's fine. It's implementing it where things fall to pieces. NT Adrahil Aug 2014 #99
Like I said, nothing has to be an absolute. I just think it's a decent general principle. n/t nomorenomore08 Aug 2014 #104
Well, I certainly agree with that. :) NT Adrahil Aug 2014 #105
I'm familiar with Marxism mostly through intermediaries Shankapotomus Aug 2014 #10
My overall stance is probably quite similar to yours. nomorenomore08 Aug 2014 #17
I think all of us have some beliefs that are far left. I would also say that I am "moderate left." 3rdwaydem Aug 2014 #24
I'm not sure what kind of support you wanted, but....... socialist_n_TN Aug 2014 #14
That's the support I wanted! BainsBane Aug 2014 #35
Hear, hear. I also voted for option #1, fwiw VanGoghRocks Aug 2014 #71
Me too........ socialist_n_TN Aug 2014 #85
LOL. KG Aug 2014 #21
I think reading Marx and subsequent political economists lovemydog Aug 2014 #22
Great suggestions! BainsBane Aug 2014 #26
I had no idea this was such a literate bunch Warpy Aug 2014 #27
The responses are by nature self-selective BainsBane Aug 2014 #28
More precisely than that. Chan790 Aug 2014 #47
Well, they didn't call it the Red Scare for nothing YoungDemCA Aug 2014 #50
They were still pussyfooting around it in AP history in the mid 60s Warpy Aug 2014 #62
I put Marx in the same category as utopian fiction sarisataka Aug 2014 #29
Then you miss his major importance BainsBane Aug 2014 #30
Admittedly I have mostly read his communism writing sarisataka Aug 2014 #31
Foucault is of course enormously important BainsBane Aug 2014 #43
I respectfully disagree. lovemydog Aug 2014 #33
Good points sarisataka Aug 2014 #38
Thank you saristataka. lovemydog Aug 2014 #39
Thanks to you as well lovemydog sarisataka Aug 2014 #42
Excellent point about capitalism as based on Utopian fiction BainsBane Aug 2014 #48
Sigh. Is there anything specific in Marx' and Engels' corpus with which you VanGoghRocks Aug 2014 #72
Several items sarisataka Aug 2014 #89
So much here to take issue with, one hardly knows where to start. You're right that VanGoghRocks Aug 2014 #94
Very astute sarisataka Aug 2014 #103
I think I am more ZombieHorde Aug 2014 #32
What's post left? lovemydog Aug 2014 #34
Hakim Bey is probably the most famous post-left advocate. ZombieHorde Aug 2014 #36
Thank you ZH! lovemydog Aug 2014 #37
+1, post-leftism ftw. joshcryer Aug 2014 #41
I disagree with Marx on implementation, but the core ideas are sound. joshcryer Aug 2014 #40
Anyone who holds that capitalism was either naturally or historically inevitable should study more YoungDemCA Aug 2014 #49
Well, Marx himself viewed capitalism as largely inevitable and *beneficial*, although VanGoghRocks Aug 2014 #73
Haven't read any Marx yet shenmue Aug 2014 #53
My ambition is to read Das Kapital in German before I die. I'm going to have VanGoghRocks Aug 2014 #75
His analysis of capitalism is spot on. BaggersRDumb Aug 2014 #54
I never agree with BainsBane Codeine Aug 2014 #55
1. Cool avatar. Benton D Struckcheon Aug 2014 #74
In his 1903 tract 'What is to be Done?," Lenin argues that the VanGoghRocks Aug 2014 #78
Yes, but it's also pretty clear that Marx probably would have agreed with him. Benton D Struckcheon Aug 2014 #90
In fact Marx did write about his views on the Paris Commune - TBF Aug 2014 #93
Thanks for posting that. Benton D Struckcheon Aug 2014 #96
I have been "accused" of being a Marxist Matrosov Aug 2014 #92
Marxism is excellent at identifying serious problems. Unfortunately, it sucks at realistic solutions Tommy_Carcetti Aug 2014 #95
No option really matches my opinion.... Adrahil Aug 2014 #97
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»On Marx and Leftism