Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)Don't ask why Janay Palmer married him. Ask why anyone would blame a victim. [View all]
. . .
This broadcasting of victims most vulnerable moments as sites for public commentary is not new. Indeed, victims of abuse have always been forced to recount their traumas to audiences more intent on policing their victimhood than finding justice. With YouTube and TMZ and all the rest, victim blaming extends far past simply being shunned by your immediate community it means having your most horrific memories go viral without your consent. It means having millions of people virtually dissect your wounds, not to heal them but to decide if your injuries were bad enough for everyone to feel bad for you.
. . .
But that deluded fetishization is every bit as untrue as it is exploitative. In reproducing victims trauma over and over, we only expose them to more harm. Throughout this six-week public ordeal, Janay Palmers pain has been minimalized, her judgment called into question. Why did she marry him after he beat her? reverberates around the web and in our minds, an accusation masquerading as a concern. When victims reveal their experiences (or have their experiences revealed by someone else), viewers reach for pre-packaged answers, rather than listen to victims themselves.
It is easier to believe that a woman provoked catastrophic violence from a supposedly otherwise peaceful man than it is to come to terms with the fact that a well-liked public figure is abusive. It is easier to conceive Palmer as an accomplice in her own beating than it is to realize that almost half of black women killed by their partners were killed as they tried to leave.
. . .
If we viewed victims as more than a link to be tweeted, more than statistics to be reported to a broken criminal justice system, we would have to grapple with their complex humanity. We would have to offer meaningful solutions to violence, holistic responses to trauma, and accountability for abusers whom we may love. We would have to do more than just watch.
This broadcasting of victims most vulnerable moments as sites for public commentary is not new. Indeed, victims of abuse have always been forced to recount their traumas to audiences more intent on policing their victimhood than finding justice. With YouTube and TMZ and all the rest, victim blaming extends far past simply being shunned by your immediate community it means having your most horrific memories go viral without your consent. It means having millions of people virtually dissect your wounds, not to heal them but to decide if your injuries were bad enough for everyone to feel bad for you.
. . .
But that deluded fetishization is every bit as untrue as it is exploitative. In reproducing victims trauma over and over, we only expose them to more harm. Throughout this six-week public ordeal, Janay Palmers pain has been minimalized, her judgment called into question. Why did she marry him after he beat her? reverberates around the web and in our minds, an accusation masquerading as a concern. When victims reveal their experiences (or have their experiences revealed by someone else), viewers reach for pre-packaged answers, rather than listen to victims themselves.
It is easier to believe that a woman provoked catastrophic violence from a supposedly otherwise peaceful man than it is to come to terms with the fact that a well-liked public figure is abusive. It is easier to conceive Palmer as an accomplice in her own beating than it is to realize that almost half of black women killed by their partners were killed as they tried to leave.
. . .
If we viewed victims as more than a link to be tweeted, more than statistics to be reported to a broken criminal justice system, we would have to grapple with their complex humanity. We would have to offer meaningful solutions to violence, holistic responses to trauma, and accountability for abusers whom we may love. We would have to do more than just watch.
THE REST of this gut-wrenching, passionately-written, spot-on piece:
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/sep/08/ray-rice-domestic-violence-video-janay-palmer-victim-blaming
55 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Don't ask why Janay Palmer married him. Ask why anyone would blame a victim. [View all]
Triana
Sep 2014
OP
Not being an NFL fan- I missed this story. Sooo fucked up on so many levels and brought to you by
bettyellen
Sep 2014
#38
First off, what does her relative physical appearance have to do with anything.
DrewFlorida
Sep 2014
#39
Your comment that she is beautiful is incredibly sexist, are you suggesting if she was...
DrewFlorida
Sep 2014
#43
The man is empowered by the owners and the fans of pro sports. I refuse to support them.
NYC_SKP
Sep 2014
#2
People often like to judge what they clearly do not understand. And when a woman is involved...
Triana
Sep 2014
#5
Re: "It's not "blame" to wonder why a woman who has been so horribly hurt would marry such a man"
951-Riverside
Sep 2014
#8
HI LeftyMom. I want to interject my feelings on this because I AM a black woman who's survived
Ecumenist
Sep 2014
#32
Hi Justice, I agree with your assessment of the the fact that not everyone is as
Ecumenist
Sep 2014
#40
Yep, TexasMommaWithA Hat, I cannot get my head around this. I didn't have much of a choice when I
Ecumenist
Sep 2014
#48
I had a problem with my self worth for a little while when I was a young teen but a STRONG mom,
Ecumenist
Sep 2014
#54
Questioning why she doesn't leave makes it more difficult for the victim to leave.
KitSileya
Sep 2014
#14
It was so creepy how he prompted her to apologize for her "role in the incident"
SunSeeker
Sep 2014
#25