Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Bill Maher slams Berkeley protesters: Who said you only had to hear what didn’t upset you? [View all]alp227
(33,301 posts)114. He does while at the same time othering American Muslims.
But his rabid defense of post-9/11 liberalism is what Maher brandishes as an excuse when accused of Islamophobia. He is consistently trumpeting a false dichotomy between the western us and the Muslim them, making points based on his notions of Muslim countries and Muslim culture creating a false entity that could be opposed to western countries and culture, denying its religious singularity.
ALSO quotes maher:
Absolutely. Because theyre violent. Because they threaten us. And they are threatening. They bring that desert stuff to our world
We dont threaten each other, we sue each other. Thats the sign of civilized people. And they dont ... People who want to gloss over the difference between western culture and Islamic culture and forget about the fact that the Islamic culture is 600 years younger and that they are going through the equivalent of what the west went through with our middle ages, our dark ages when religion had way too much power
do so at their peril.
http://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/tvandradioblog/2014/oct/06/bill-maher-islam-ben-affleck
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
143 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Bill Maher slams Berkeley protesters: Who said you only had to hear what didn’t upset you? [View all]
babylonsister
Nov 2014
OP
He has actually read those holy books, which both have hurtful and cruel shit from coved to cover
snooper2
Nov 2014
#133
It is a commencement speech. The graduates just have to sit there and take it.
djean111
Nov 2014
#49
I thought the show tonight was great. I think he's wrong if he's blaming all,, or the majority,
Hoyt
Nov 2014
#5
You know if you watch the original exchange between Affleck and Maher he didn't say one thing
scarystuffyo
Nov 2014
#24
He was saying no liberal criticizes Islam. Liberal certainly do criticize Israel.
applegrove
Nov 2014
#95
But 60% of Egyptians do not kill people who leave Islam. Bill was all but equating poll responses
merrily
Nov 2014
#38
if his speaking fee came out of student fees, they certainly haave a right to have someone
hollysmom
Nov 2014
#9
Maybe someone who has some kind of academic achievement rather than a talkshow host.
JVS
Nov 2014
#46
And you know that UCBerkeley is a state university and thus part of the gov't, right? n/t
Sivafae
Nov 2014
#138
The pro lifers do far more than mere disagreement. They interfere with women's life choices.
alp227
Nov 2014
#99
Of course Bill is speaking in favor of equal rights for LGBT people and freedom of religion
Bluenorthwest
Nov 2014
#110
"why, I have to look at Muslims every day on the street--even at Nobel awards!" nt
MisterP
Nov 2014
#22
Berkeley's still got a chance to keep its reputation for "free speech," but not without a fight,
ancianita
Nov 2014
#23
This has nothing to do with free speech, nothing. Please see Replies 28 and 32.
merrily
Nov 2014
#33
I appreciate your points about students' views. Thanks. Does the protest represent
ancianita
Nov 2014
#40
My last commencement was high school; didn't attend my college ones. I read #41.
ancianita
Nov 2014
#45
I'd prefer a majority representation of the graduating class, although a case can be made for
ancianita
Nov 2014
#58
Berkley has a not so great reputation among Union loving performers, the last non CEO or political
Bluenorthwest
Nov 2014
#113
It's like inviting Gordon Gecko to speak at graduation - it's an insult to the graduates. nt
bananas
Nov 2014
#43
Exactly why Bill Maher welcomes him on the show. That, and Bill Maher makes money from his show
merrily
Nov 2014
#41
On his own dime. That doesn't mean anyone has to have him as commencement speaker.
merrily
Nov 2014
#42
IIRC, a student led group extended the initial invitation several months ago...
CincyDem
Nov 2014
#56
The students did pick him. A small number protested after his episode with Affleck
riderinthestorm
Nov 2014
#78
people that are purposely offensive, get offended when they offend. he needs to suck it up. nt
seabeyond
Nov 2014
#60
Protesting is a big part of civil rights, and people have the right to protest...
Violet_Crumble
Nov 2014
#75
You have no clue whatsoever how ironic and hypocritical that statement is, do you?
True Blue Door
Nov 2014
#88
I agree with Bill! Way too much political correctness with liberals. If you need to know whats the
B Calm
Nov 2014
#84
Please, please won't someone protect the young impressionable Berkeley students
Nye Bevan
Nov 2014
#86
It amazes me there is one key fact that eludes Maher and the debate in general
JonLP24
Nov 2014
#131
Maher has the right to speak, and the students have the equal right to protest his speech. n/t.
Ken Burch
Nov 2014
#122