Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

AZ Progressive

(3,411 posts)
69. You can't talk about America's hatred of the poor without talking about its protestant work ethic
Wed Nov 12, 2014, 01:33 PM
Nov 2014
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/05/opinion/sunday/are-americans-still-puritan.html?_r=0

"Not all of the legacy of Puritanism suggests moral uprightness. Studies since the ’70s have also found that Americans who score high on a Protestant Ethic Scale (emphasizing self-reliance and self-discipline) or similar metric show marked prejudice against racial minorities and the poor; hostility toward social welfare efforts; and, among obese women, self-denigration.

"Why the persistence of Puritanism in American life? “New England exercised a disproportionate influence on American ideals,” the historian John Coffey says, “thanks to a powerful intellectual tradition disseminated through its universities, its dynamic print culture and the writings of its famous clergy.” He also notes the power of Evangelicalism as a carrier of Puritan values and America’s resistance, compared with other largely Protestant nations, to secularization."




Max Weber argued a century ago that America's success was due to its protestantism, that the protestant work ethic (first brought by the Puritans) is why America became great. In particular, this work ethic first started with Calvinism and predestination, that everyone was already chosen by God whether they will have salvation or damnation, and one would be able to see if they were chosen for salvation by their levels of prosperity. Thus everyone had an incentive to prove that they have salvation by working hard and being prosperous. If someone is poor and in need, they were damned and that was God's will. In short, it's part of America's culture to reward prosperity and denigrate the poor. It wasn't always like this, as the Democratic Party has fought this through history, but it seems like it has roots in America, and primarily when the Republicans and other assholes of this country get power and promote their worldviews.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Americans hate poor people. [View all] Yavin4 Nov 2014 OP
I have personal experience with that. Kingofalldems Nov 2014 #1
Our brand of capitalism is a brilliant system Ron Green Nov 2014 #2
^^^THIS^^^ Tom Ripley Nov 2014 #58
Well said. (no text) Quantess Nov 2014 #71
A sad truth. n/t 99Forever Nov 2014 #3
Yep BlindTiresias Nov 2014 #4
And since so many are poor, they actually hate themselves? Maybe. Rex Nov 2014 #5
They hate the poor because they are afraid of becoming poor. n/t FSogol Nov 2014 #6
No, They're afraid of being correctly identified as poor. Yavin4 Nov 2014 #8
Crazy Lurker Deluxe Nov 2014 #18
OWING more that you OWN puts your net worth at 0 or in negative territory Yavin4 Nov 2014 #44
That does not make you poor Lurker Deluxe Nov 2014 #50
Individuals, corporations, and govrerment are not the same. Yavin4 Nov 2014 #51
Okay ... Lurker Deluxe Nov 2014 #57
Rebuttal Yavin4 Nov 2014 #59
Again Lurker Deluxe Nov 2014 #62
The couple in your example have a $250 K a year revenue stream. They have ASSETS to offset their Yavin4 Nov 2014 #66
You are correct. Remember when Hillary (whom I am not supporting at this time) was talking about jwirr Nov 2014 #28
So sayeth Master Yoda Ampersand Unicode Nov 2014 #31
Yep. The ugly side of the American Dream. TDale313 Nov 2014 #7
Message auto-removed Name removed Nov 2014 #20
The religious aspect plays a large role in that hate. I have felt it first hand. I had an ace in the jwirr Nov 2014 #33
Americans? leftofcool Nov 2014 #9
In general poor and low income people feel this-you are probably an exception Stargazer99 Nov 2014 #10
if you ever become poor you will eventually understand Stargazer99 Nov 2014 #11
So True. Basic LA Nov 2014 #12
That's why the income inequality argument falls on deaf ears Yavin4 Nov 2014 #13
Deaf Ears. Basic LA Nov 2014 #17
That's a large part of the reason. Also people don't really understand how unequal our income pampango Nov 2014 #52
They don't care. Basic LA Nov 2014 #54
When it is based on religious beliefs they go so far as to see the poor and "weak" as someone who jwirr Nov 2014 #34
And many white, rural poor hate nonwhite poor Ampersand Unicode Nov 2014 #36
Because we fear the poor, and poverty, recognizing powerlessness when we see it. Orsino Nov 2014 #14
Worse. Americans think they're going to be rich Niko Nov 2014 #15
By the way - wasn't the plumber running for office somewhere? Did he win? jwirr Nov 2014 #35
He ran for Congress but lost... PoliticAverse Nov 2014 #45
Thank God for one favor. We do not have to put up with him. jwirr Nov 2014 #53
Exactly. lumberjack_jeff Nov 2014 #16
Frugal doesn't make an economy The2ndWheel Nov 2014 #19
Yep.I go into peoples houses (computer tech). I'll pull up in a very nice neighborhood, go inside .. BlueJazz Nov 2014 #42
You can blame that on Calvinism Spider Jerusalem Nov 2014 #21
Yep. There's a whole strain of Chritianity based on those notions. GoCubsGo Nov 2014 #43
It's pre-destination... devils chaplain Nov 2014 #49
Message auto-removed Name removed Nov 2014 #22
And thus most Americans hate themselves daredtowork Nov 2014 #23
Also let me say this is a dam good reason to support unions. Rex Nov 2014 #24
And with Industrial Unions they would control the jobs that make them. jtuck004 Nov 2014 #26
And a lot more people would be poor. A living wage is one of the goals of union. Without that goal jwirr Nov 2014 #37
We are TAUGHT to hate, and loathe, "poor people". Partly by using "poor people" jtuck004 Nov 2014 #25
Good point. jwirr Nov 2014 #38
And most are one or two generations from family LuckyLib Nov 2014 #27
Americans respect rich people. Octafish Nov 2014 #29
Which rich people, though? Ampersand Unicode Nov 2014 #39
Great Post Long Drive Nov 2014 #68
Many Americans live on the financial edge and put on a good show to others they are OK. This, RKP5637 Nov 2014 #30
i know struggling people who hate the poor , THEY are not like THEM JI7 Nov 2014 #32
Thank you for this op. I suspect that this attitude is part of the reason we lost this election. It jwirr Nov 2014 #40
Love Thy nieghbor...... Burf-_- Nov 2014 #41
Altogether too many Americans are not only shallow, but vindictive on top of it world wide wally Nov 2014 #46
Americans all think they are going to be rich. They don't get the kairos12 Nov 2014 #47
We HAVE to challenge this, I think if the choice was between majority power or no anti-poor attitude ck4829 Nov 2014 #48
Then there are those that even while they hate the poor... Kalidurga Nov 2014 #55
thus the need for the FDR PARTY in politics grasswire Nov 2014 #56
You get a damn skippy from me on this. MrScorpio Nov 2014 #60
I've seen more scorn thrown at the poor right on DU TorchTheWitch Nov 2014 #61
People are so terrified by them they convince themselves it's their fault. nolabear Nov 2014 #63
I crossed this country numerous times while nilesobek Nov 2014 #64
+1000 N/T UglyGreed Nov 2014 #65
When they should be directing their anger at cheap labor conservatives! B Calm Nov 2014 #67
You can't talk about America's hatred of the poor without talking about its protestant work ethic AZ Progressive Nov 2014 #69
Great post. And the poor have been taught to hate themselves ProfessorPlum Nov 2014 #70
I think you're oversimplifying it... MadDAsHell Nov 2014 #72
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Americans hate poor peopl...»Reply #69