Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Our Beautiful Black Athletes Supporting #ICantBreathe.. Racists are Going to Run Out of Teams [View all]Dr. Xavier
(278 posts)124. For years I hated the Lambs but then this happened...

Once you look at that photo look at this URL: http://www.sfexaminer.com/sanfrancisco/two-sfpd-officers-still-under-investigation-in-police-shooting-awarded-medals-of-valor/Content?oid=2913666
Two SFPD officers still under investigation in police shooting award... http://www.sfexaminer.com/sanfrancisco/two-sfpd-officers-still-unde...
News » Crime & Courts
|
December 08, 2014
Two SFPD officers still under investigation in police shooting awarded Medals of Valor
@Jonahowenlamb
By Jonah Owen Lamb
COURTESY PHOTO Freddy Martinez was left paralyzed from the waist down after being shot by an officer for brandishing
what looked like a gun. The alleged weapon was a toy gun. The two officers involved in the incident were recently awarded a Silver Medal of Valor by the Police Department despite two investigations into the incident that are still open.
Two SFPD officers still under investigation in police shooting award...
In the early-morning hours of April 7, 2013, there was a fracas between two groups of men on Valencia Street a block away from the Mission Police Station.
The first officers on the scene -- Ryan Daugherty and officer-in-training Valerie Durkin -- encountered a man waving what looked like a pistol in front of the Good Vibrations sex shop. When Freddy Martinez refused to put down the weapon and waved it in the direction of the officers, Daugherty fired his weapon, wounding Martinez and a bystander, police reported.
Some 19 months after the incident, the Police Department on Nov. 12 honored both officers with Silver Medals of Valor for their actions in the incident.
However, the honors came while two investigations into the incident remain open.
The move, some say, puts a cloud over the medal recipients and creates the image in the public eye that the investigations following an officer-involved shooting don't really matter.
"It's especially appalling when the investigations have not been completed," said Xavier Baeza, Martinez's attorney, who argues that the police version of events diverges with that of some witnesses. Martinez, who was left paralyzed from the waist down, is suing The City in federal court for alleged civil-rights violations.
The investigations into the shooting remain open with several agencies.
As part of an ongoing series looking into police-involved shootings, The San Francisco Examiner analyzed all such recorded incidents since 2000 to gain an understanding of when and why police use lethal force.
Separate investigations by the District Attorney's Office and the Police Department's Internal Affairs Unit are ongoing.
The internal affairs probe, which acts as the administrative investigation for the Police Department, needs to be complete for police to rule on whether the shooting was in policy. That action is pending.
The District Attorney's Office investigation looks into whether there was criminal wrongdoing, which could lead to charges. It, too, remains open.
A third body that looks into such matters, the Office of Citizen Complaints, which was asked before a vote about the medals about any open matters pertaining to the case, said no investigation or complaint related to the 2013 incident is open now or was at the time of the awards approval.
While a Police Department spokesman said the administrative process is all but complete pending the district attorney's letter, which could take years due to a backlog for such documents, a final administrative ruling on the incident has yet to be made.
2 of 5 12/9/14 6:46 PM
Two SFPD officers still under investigation in police shooting award... http://www.sfexaminer.com/sanfrancisco/two-sfpd-officers-still-unde...
Meanwhile, the District Attorney's Office said completion of its investigation rests on more than formalities. And internal affairs' own Aug. 13 report to the Police Commission lists the Martinez shooting as an open case.
The Police Department's official explanation does not sit well with Baeza.
Honoring the two police officers while investigations are open could impact his client's lawsuit against The City, Baeza said. A trial is scheduled for March.
"I think it's pathetic -- that it's an attempt to honor two officers whose actions were not up to the standards of an objective, reasonable police officer," Baeza said.
The Police Commission makes final approvals for the department's highest honors, and it is supposed to be informed when a nominee is under investigation, Commissioner Petra DeJesus said.
When the commission voted to approve the honors in August, DeJesus and her colleagues were told by then-President Thomas Mazzucco and Inspector John Monroe, the commission's clerk, that no investigations were open.
But those statements were false, as the commission knew the status of the investigations when it voted. Commissioners had a report by internal affairs from Aug. 13 on all open cases, including the Martinez incident.
DeJesus said a policy for such matters should be adopted so everyone can make "informed decisions."
Mazzucco has argued in the past that officers should not have to wait for honors on the DA, whose investigations can take years even when the department has completed its inquiry.
The commission does not have a rule baring approving medals for officers involved in incidents still under investigation, but DeJesus said at the August meeting that the commission should discuss creating such a rule.
"We have a commitment to ensure our process is comprehensive and thorough," current Police Commission President Suzy Loftus said. "We are always open to improvements and will review the standing procedures," she added in a statement, which did not speak to whether the commission plans on looking into changing the status quo.
This is not the first time officers were awarded medals under such circumstances, or the first time the commission seemingly failed to check on such matters.
In 2013, Officer Mary Godfrey was given a Silver Medal of Valor for a 2012 incident. At the time, Mazzucco said Godfrey had been vetted by the OCC and Police Department and had no issue with moving forward with approving her honor.
3 of 5 12/9/14 6:46 PM
Two SFPD officers still under investigation in police shooting award... http://www.sfexaminer.com/sanfrancisco/two-sfpd-officers-still-unde...
Former Commissioner Angela Chan was the only commissioner who voted against the approval.
In 2000, the commission held off on awarding medals for two officers involved in a 1998 shooting incident that ended in the death of ad executive John Smart.
While the District Attorney's Office and internal affairs investigations were complete, the OCC's was not. After discovering the oversight, the medals, which had already been approved, were put on hold by Dennis Herrera, who was commission president at the time and is now the city attorney.
Herrera's office did not return a request for comment.
After the issue arose, then-Police Chief Fred Lau told The Examiner that the department's medal committee would start checking with all the relevant agencies before putting forward nominees.
More Crime & Courts »
TaTgasg:s: , , , , ,,,
JONAH OWEN LAMB
Crime & Courts
police shooting
San Francisco police
San Francisco Police Commission
officer involved shooting
medal of valor
San Francisco Office of Citizen Complaints
San Francisco
District Attorneys Office
SF EXAMINER DECISION MAKER
READ MORE
16.8K
They are a valid response to police brutality The violence takes away from the message There should be no protest, cops are just doing their jobs They help bring attention to the issue of race in America
VOTE!
Powered by 1World Online
jlamb@sfexaminer.com
How do you feel about the protests erupting over the two cases of black men killed by police?
4 of 5 12/9/14 6:46 PM
Two SFPD officers still under investigation in police shooting award... http://www.sfexaminer.com/sanfrancisco/two-sfpd-officers-still-unde...
Let me know what you think? I'll let you know how you can help.
Dr. X
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
137 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Our Beautiful Black Athletes Supporting #ICantBreathe.. Racists are Going to Run Out of Teams [View all]
Cha
Dec 2014
OP
Neither am I, silverweb.. but, I support these Black Athletes standing up for #ICantBreathe!
Cha
Dec 2014
#5
Vital point.. "More importantly, these athletes are heroes to a lot of young people, who emulate
Cha
Dec 2014
#15
I'm so proud of these guys.. I can imagine how their Mamas must feel.. bursting! We're feeling it
Cha
Dec 2014
#8
If you don't see the beauty in these athletes supporting #ICantBreathe.. I'm sorry.
Cha
Dec 2014
#20
Their Mamas must be bursting with pride at their beautiful sons standing up for Justice, she..Hawaii
Cha
Dec 2014
#25
A Big Thank you to you, Steve! Really good role models for our younger generation watching all this
Cha
Dec 2014
#35
Of course you don't.. being an idiot asshole it must be really hard to see anything worthwhile.
Cha
Dec 2014
#38
Oh, we definitely had a poor bumbling racist on this thread.. wanting to flame out.. obviously
Cha
Dec 2014
#40
Yes, if only I was a professional basketball player, I would join in solidarity
Vattel
Dec 2014
#102
It was terrific to see he added his presence to the statement. Good for all of them. n/t
Judi Lynn
Dec 2014
#49
Hi Judi Lynn.. wanted you to see this too.. in case you didn't know.. quite sweet..
Cha
Dec 2014
#51
Yes, that would be interesting.. i just looked him up. Here's a musician and his wife standing up..
Cha
Dec 2014
#50
I'm listening to the music vid now.. it's quite good.. it's got "Ferguson" in it.. written before
Cha
Dec 2014
#58
Isn't it a beautiful song, logosoco?! I wish everyone could hear it.. yeah, that is too bad about
Cha
Dec 2014
#67
Mahalo Spazito.. you're exactly right.. it's a movement with Protesters all across the country who
Cha
Dec 2014
#85
Watching coverage of all the protests night after night has been very encouraging...
Spazito
Dec 2014
#101
Thank you for that.. I don't have a tv.. hope it's on American TV, too.. probably not quite like
Cha
Dec 2014
#103
Mahalo so much for this, Spazito! I'm in and out right now but looking forward to reading!
Cha
Dec 2014
#106
It's heartwarming, mcar.. after all the injustice to see People standing up against it!
Cha
Dec 2014
#94
Such whiners.. and yes they probably are racists.. we had a couple of vicious ones on here last
Cha
Dec 2014
#104
Muchas Gracias. she~ The Laker Team came out with #ICantBreathe Tees before their Game!
Cha
Dec 2014
#117
Fantastic...Donttorturedontshoot , what is that riot gear for, aint no riot here
NoJusticeNoPeace
Dec 2014
#130