General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Anti-Semitism's increasingly thin and hard-to-see line [View all]Bonobo
(29,257 posts)OK, here's some info for you:
Oh, sorry. This contains actual info. You may not want to sully yourself.
http://www.haaretz.com/opinion/defining-zionism-the-belief-that-israel-belongs-to-the-entire-jewish-people.premium-1.525064
The right likes to use it as a type of whipped cream to improve the taste of dubious dishes, while the left treats it with fear, as if it were a mine liable to explode in its hands − which is why it always feels the need to neutralize it with some strange adjective, as in sane Zionism or humane Zionism. In the dispute between the national camp and the peace camp, Zionism is used as an offensive weapon that is batted from one side to the other.
Abroad, critics of Israel use Zionism as a kind of poisonous potion to exacerbate every accusation against the state. Many critics believe that the solution to Israels future lies in the de-Zionization of its identity. Among Israels sworn enemies, Zionist is a demonic epithet, a term of denunciation that replaces the word Israeli or Jew. Hamas members speak of the captured Zionist soldier, and Hezbollah and Iran speak of the criminal Zionist entity, not about Israel.
So its about time that we try to define the word Zionist realistically. First of all, we must remember that from a historical perspective, the concept emerged only at the end of the 19th century. Its meaningless to try and describe Yehuda Halevi as a Zionist, or any other Jew who immigrated to the Holy Land in centuries past. In the same fashion, we cant use the terms socialism or socialist for periods before the middle of the 19th century, and describe Robespierre, for example, as the socialist of the French Revolution, which occurred at the end of the 18th century. These concepts only have significance from the time when they emerged in a specific historical context, and tossing them around freely as labels for anything we choose is a clearly anachronistic act.