General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Amanda Knox will again go before an Italian court [View all]pnwmom
(110,259 posts)after a full trial that considered the facts of the case. And then retried two years later in a subsequent trial after an appeal by the prosecution -- hence the double jeopardy.
Going before the Court of Cassation now to see if that verdict will be confirmed changes nothing.
Kind of blows your whole point out of the water.
By the way, even the State Department viewed the case as closed after the 2011 verdict that found for innocence. Any new trials after that point would constitute double jeopardy in the US system. That it isn't in Italian law is just a matter of labels, not reality.
http://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/europe/amanda-knox-ruling-could-prompt-new-extradition-battle-1.2148547
Amanda Knox was en route to Seattle from Rome - a free woman whose conviction for murder had just been overturned - when David Thorne, the US ambassador to Italy, sent a cable to the State Department declaring that the case was officially over.
Thornes relief seemed palpable. Knoxs arrest, trial and imprisonment for the brutal slaying of her British housemate, Meredith Kercher, had dominated headlines all over the world, and was closely followed by American officials in Rome, diplomatic cables would later reveal. Post considers this case closed, he wrote in October 2011.
It turned out to be premature, but the depth of the ambassadors miscalculation will only fully be known next week, when a highly-anticipated ruling in the ongoing case by Italys highest court could open the door to a whole new legal battle over Knoxs potential extradition from the US, a decision that would have significant diplomatic and political consequences from Rome to Washington DC.