General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Democrat's Apathy For Unions Is Suicide [View all]ND-Dem
(4,571 posts)Last edited Wed Apr 1, 2015, 08:31 PM - Edit history (1)
When a young person with lousy life chances thinks of his future as a kind of lottery, that is the appropriate terrain for hope. Tell the young to read Think and Grow Rich, and to buy a scratch ticket while theyre at it. Why not?
But with politics its different: We form groups, we strategize, we donate, we plan how to best advance our collective interests. This is not the lottery. When we elect public servants, the deal ought to be a little more of a sure thing.
Recall, in this connection, one of the most annoying invocations of hope ever to cross a politicians lips, John Edwards vice presidential acceptance speech at the 2004 Democratic Convention. His tag line, which he repeated many times: Hope is on the way. Not help, mind you; hope. Edwards had lots of good, practical ideas, but this phrase rubbed me the wrong way. What it seemed to suggest was not that the candidate was actually going to do something for the suffering, hard-working people he described, but that, by the strength of his presence, he was going to give people a chance that someone might do something for them. We give him the vice presidency, he gives us a Powerball ticket.
Hope also sets an extremely low standard for judging Democratic politicians. Hope is, by their definition, something they bring with them, or a place they come from, or a poster they are (literally!) the illustration for; ensuring that this fanciful substance flows our way doesnt require them actually to, you know, enact anything were hoping for. On the contrary, they can do things (like Clintons deregulations or Obamas spying program) that actually harm their constituents, and then tell us, as Barack Obama tweeted after the 2012 election, The definition of hope is you still believe, even when its hard.
This is the opposite of accountability. It means, just keep waiting, and just keep voting. If you think good thoughts long enough, maybe someday youll get that million bucks, or that single-payer healthcare system.
And thats probably why this stuff springs so goddamned eternal. After 30 years of these pseudo Democrats...its easy enough to understand why elected officials love the concept. Hope means, forget about how you got taken last time. Think positively. Maybe this next Democrat is the one who will finally act the way you think Democrats ought to act. And when he doesnt, hope means you need to stick with him anyway, because . . . well, because hes the one who carries hope in his back pocket and all.
http://www.salon.com/2014/03/23/the_hope_diet_would_the_tea_party_fall_for_this/