The Conservatives Who Gutted the Voting Rights Act Are Now Challenging ‘One Person, One Vote’ [View all]

[octoberlib]

Ari Berman on May 28, 2015 - 3:06 PM ET





Ed Blum, who brought the case that led to the gutting of the Voting Rights Act in 2013, is now going after the historic principle of "one person, one vote." The Supreme Court decided on Tuesday to hear Evenwel v. Abbott, Blum's latest case, which challenges the drawing of State Senate districts in Texas. The obscure case could have major ramifications for political representation.

Blum first began attacking the Voting Rights Act after losing a Houston Congressional race to a black Democrat in 1992 and founded the Project on Fair Representation in 2005 to challenge the constitutionality of the VRA. The Evenwel case doesn't deal directly with the VRA, but on how districts should be calculated. Since the Supreme Court's 1964 Reynolds v. Sims decision, districts have been drawn based on the total population of an area. Blum instead wants lines to be drawn based only on eligible voters—excluding children, inmates, non-citizens, etc from counting toward representation.

If that happened, legislative districts would become older, whiter, more rural, and more conservative rather than younger, more diverse, more urban, and more liberal. "It would be a power shift almost perfectly calibrated to benefit the Republican party," explains University of Texas law professor Joey Fishkin. "The losers would be urban areas with lots of children and lots of racially diverse immigrants. The winners would be older, whiter, more suburban, and rural areas. It would be a power shift on a scale American redistricting law has not seen since the 1960s. While not nearly as dramatic as the original reapportionment revolution, it would require every map in every state to be redrawn, with the same general pattern of winners and losers."

Demographically, the gap between Republicans and Democrats is wider than it has ever been. "House Republicans are still 87 percent white male, compared to 43 percent of House Democrats - the widest gap we've ever seen," explains Dave Wasserman, House editor of The Cook Political Report. "In terms of composition of districts, the median GOP district is 76% white, while the median Dem district is 49% white—again, the widest gap we've ever seen. Overall, the median House district is 68% white, compared to 63% for the nation as a whole."


http://www.thenation.com/blog/208625/conservatives-who-gutted-voting-rights-act-are-now-challenging-one-person-one-vote