Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)If an armed man breaks into my home and I attack him, can he shoot me and claim self defense? [View all]
Similarly, if I am walking down the street in my own neighborhood, committing no crime, and an armed man chases and confronts me... if I try to fight back, can he shoot me and claim self defense?
There's no dispute that Trayvon Martin was committing no crime.
There's no dispute that Zimmerman chased him - he admitted doing so in the 911 call.
If you commit a crime, you have no right to act in "self defense." If you are armed and you chase an innocent, unarmed minor down the street, I say you also have no right to claim "self defense."
30 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
If an armed man breaks into my home and I attack him, can he shoot me and claim self defense? [View all]
Nine
May 2012
OP
You can't generally physically attack a person for "confronting" you. That's the problem. nt
Romulox
May 2012
#1
Did it rise to the level of a "reasonable apprehension" of physical harm? Then yes.
Romulox
May 2012
#8
"to chase and confront someone in public" is this not stalking? If he had been wearing a police
jwirr
May 2012
#19
To a layman perhaps. In the eyes of the law it has a very limited and specific meaning.
hack89
May 2012
#25
Then this SYG law puts all of us in danger. All we need is an enemy. Fortunately for me Governor
jwirr
May 2012
#26
That was part of the argument on the PA castle doctrine change. Short answer: Yes.
HopeHoops
May 2012
#4
Not analogous. Breaking and entering is a crime; following and confronting isn't a crime.
JVS
May 2012
#7
I don't think you get a right to self defense while committing a crime.
4th law of robotics
May 2012
#12
If a strange man chases me down the street at night, I'm going to fear for my safety.
Nine
May 2012
#13
Yes, if gz had just been walking behind him but first he followed him in his car and then got out of
jwirr
May 2012
#21
It's not a problem with SYG, it's a problem with a lazy/corrupt/incompetent...
PavePusher
May 2012
#22
I may be wrong but before SYG laws I think all self defense claims had to be looked into. I remember
jwirr
May 2012
#23
If Trayvon had broken into Zimmerman's house, I'd have to defend him...
Comrade_McKenzie
May 2012
#30