Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)The 5 Phases of Gentrification -- When can it be stopped? [View all]
and when is it too late?
Phase 1 Pioneering
New residents move in to abandoned or under-maintained buildings.
Banks will not lend so renovation is limited to the resources of the Pioneers.
No displacement of original residents, yet.
Phase 2 Potential is Seen
Real estate agents promote the areas potential. Vacancy rates drop.
Rents begin to rise. Banks begin to lend. Speculators buy distressed buildings.
Phase 3 Safety and Media Hype
Gentrifiers create historic preservation, business and neighborhood associations.
Rents increase dramatically and displacement of the original residents fuels tensions.
Police adopt broken windows tactics and selectively enforce loitering and similar laws.
Media attention promotes the new safety and changes in the neighborhood.
Phase 4 Peak
The first wave of Pioneers gets priced out.
Banks and investors create more high priced apartments and condos.
Buildings bought for speculation in Phase 2 get put back on the market.
Phase 5 Post Peak
Vacancy rates increase as rents push above the limit.
Speculators take the money they made in Phase 4 and look for new opportunities in neighboring communities.
Landlords are absentee, including large banks and institutional investors.
Property values stagnate or fall from their peaks.
New residents move in to abandoned or under-maintained buildings.
Banks will not lend so renovation is limited to the resources of the Pioneers.
No displacement of original residents, yet.
Phase 2 Potential is Seen
Real estate agents promote the areas potential. Vacancy rates drop.
Rents begin to rise. Banks begin to lend. Speculators buy distressed buildings.
Phase 3 Safety and Media Hype
Gentrifiers create historic preservation, business and neighborhood associations.
Rents increase dramatically and displacement of the original residents fuels tensions.
Police adopt broken windows tactics and selectively enforce loitering and similar laws.
Media attention promotes the new safety and changes in the neighborhood.
Phase 4 Peak
The first wave of Pioneers gets priced out.
Banks and investors create more high priced apartments and condos.
Buildings bought for speculation in Phase 2 get put back on the market.
Phase 5 Post Peak
Vacancy rates increase as rents push above the limit.
Speculators take the money they made in Phase 4 and look for new opportunities in neighboring communities.
Landlords are absentee, including large banks and institutional investors.
Property values stagnate or fall from their peaks.
adopted from the work of American urban theorist Philip Clay.
56 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
No, because voucher payments are set too low for rents in newly gentrified areas.
Gormy Cuss
Oct 2015
#22
another question would be whether we can stop the worst effects of gentrification
GreatGazoo
Oct 2015
#6
it can be delayed, but once the drug dealer goes, the chain of events begins
geek tragedy
Oct 2015
#9
and that's the thing, there's organic revitilization which is the more benign form
geek tragedy
Oct 2015
#27
No, that would be as feckless as ignoring the problems caused by gentrification.
Gormy Cuss
Oct 2015
#45
redlining certainly did play a role in depressing housing prices in black communities
geek tragedy
Oct 2015
#46
Killing it at step 1 would mean forcing banks to redline minority and poor neighborhoods.
geek tragedy
Oct 2015
#25
Okay, so all we need to do is pass a law banning poverty. Seems easy enough nt
geek tragedy
Oct 2015
#33
There is a difference between what various groups consider "undesireable to live"
GreatGazoo
Oct 2015
#41
as I said in another post in this thread, the key is promoting middle class ownership
geek tragedy
Oct 2015
#42
The speculators and developers arriving on the scene is the return of the predators, original street
Bluenorthwest
Oct 2015
#16