General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: This message was self-deleted by its author [View all]nsd
(2,486 posts)Others have politely and gingerly suggested more or less the same thing ("please post an image"
, but I'm going to be impolite and blunt.
This post sounds made up.
The red flags:
1. Why is fuel measured in kilometers?
2. Americans don't measure distance in kilometers anyway.
3. Syria and Turkey have a long border. Where is this hypothetical plane taking off?
4. Mosul is in Iraq. I consider myself relatively well informed for an American, but I couldn't locate Mosul any better than that. There is no way American 9th graders could tell you where Mosul is. In fact, I suspect most of them would guess that Mosul is the name of a breakfast food, high in fiber but not tasty, that people in "Europe" eat.
5. I have never heard of cities called Rajah and Sinjar. I'll bet you dollars to donuts that, assuming these cities even exist, only a small fraction of 1% of American teenagers have heard of them.
If I am wrong, I apologize. But this just sounds like bullshit.
ETA: The problem is akin to the traveling salesman problem, which is a famously difficult and deep math problem. If 9th graders are really being asked questions like this, I have to say that I am very, very impressed with the state of American math education.