General Discussion

Yorktown

(2,884 posts)

109. (a) I was presenting a graph from 'Le Monde', not the whole INED databank

Reply to muriel_volestrangler (Reply #49)

Wed Dec 9, 2015, 01:45 AM

Dec 2015

(b) when presenting the graph, I was only focusing on Muslims as a % of the total population
NB the numbers increased recently as some of the Catholic drop-outs moved to Protestantism.
(c) possible
(d) I was thinking about French nationals. Didn't know so many immigrants were Orthodoxs.
(e) Not so sure 15% is wrong. Most sources say 6M Muslims/60M inhabitants=10% avg.
Given that the proportion is much lower in the 60+ age group, it has to be mechanically higher in the 18-50yo age group to end up with a 10% average.
(f) Your statement "It's not just Christianity that's 'dying' in France" is questionable.
The 43% Catholics are now mostly nominal, with only 4/43 attending church weekly
http://www.lefigaro.fr/actualite-france/2009/12/29/01016-20091229ARTFIG00292-les-francais-boudent-la-messe-.php
By contrast, the Muslim population is increasingly practicing.
http://www.la-croix.com/Religion/Actualite/Les-musulmans-pratiquent-plus-qu-il-y-a-vingt-ans-_NG_-2011-07-31-694668

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

112 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Rise of far-right in France after Paris Attacks [View all] flamingdem Dec 2015 OP

The Return To Facism Has Begun In Europe cantbeserious Dec 2015 #1

It's amazing how fast things can change nt flamingdem Dec 2015 #2

Oddly enough, not in Germany or Italy Yorktown Dec 2015 #4

What do you think will happen to Frau Merkel? Nt flamingdem Dec 2015 #6

She will calmly leave in 2017. Yorktown Dec 2015 #7

She'll be gone. 840high Dec 2015 #11

Everyone thinks she'll not run again DFW Dec 2015 #107

How interesting, the next few years may well have women as the most flamingdem Dec 2015 #108

Women have done at least as well as men leading European countries DFW Dec 2015 #111

Disagree re: Italy JustAnotherGen Dec 2015 #26

It can happen anywhere, but it's not currently in the minds of Italians Yorktown Dec 2015 #28

Agree to Disagree JustAnotherGen Dec 2015 #30

Never been south of Rome, so I wouldn't know Yorktown Dec 2015 #40

Sadly there is much racist/fascist in America newfie11 Dec 2015 #46

France has had problems with the Muslim populanton since they had many colonies in Africa. Jim Beard Dec 2015 #83

Yes, the fate of the harkis is de Gaulle's shame Yorktown Dec 2015 #84

Here it comes newfie11 Dec 2015 #45

the threat of being killed by islamic radicals is going to drive survival behaviors patsimp Dec 2015 #51

Far right? Far nonsense. Yorktown Dec 2015 #3

Yesturday I served at my poll station and counted ballots. mylye2222 Dec 2015 #5

In which part of France? Yorktown Dec 2015 #9

In St-Etienne, central-eastern France. mylye2222 Dec 2015 #35

Oh, surprised. Yorktown Dec 2015 #38

Me too. mylye2222 Dec 2015 #39

I went once around St Etienne Yorktown Dec 2015 #41

Why do you think they are having so much success in your area? smirkymonkey Dec 2015 #60

less immigration than high uneployement. mylye2222 Dec 2015 #64

I've actually been to St Etienne. hifiguy Dec 2015 #65

Wow. mylye2222 Dec 2015 #90

AFAIK Focal is still there. hifiguy Dec 2015 #100

Truth is that the far right is only rising because people have hidden racist attitudes politicman Dec 2015 #8

Your comment is far, far disconnected from reality Yorktown Dec 2015 #10

Islam is not a race, no. Scootaloo Dec 2015 #14

Please see my answer #18 Yorktown Dec 2015 #19

I'm simply explaining racialized the nature of the bigotry to you Scootaloo Dec 2015 #20

Agreed, and I knew. But do not discard the legitimate ideological worry. Yorktown Dec 2015 #22

That's not really a legitimate worry Scootaloo Dec 2015 #23

No, it's very legitimate worry, as numbers can demonstrate Yorktown Dec 2015 #27

Again; A minority within a minority wants something that they can't agree on Scootaloo Dec 2015 #29

I have personally zero worry on the subject Yorktown Dec 2015 #37

That's 15% *of those who are religious* muriel_volestrangler Dec 2015 #42

Interesting link, but the numbers you posted must be wrong Yorktown Dec 2015 #48

(a) they're from your own source muriel_volestrangler Dec 2015 #49

(a) I was presenting a graph from 'Le Monde', not the whole INED databank Yorktown Dec 2015 #109

No, we can be very confident that 15% is wrong - it's only among the religious muriel_volestrangler Dec 2015 #110

I must thank you, you made me attempt a synthesis of the existing data Yorktown Dec 2015 #112

you just cant accept reality because its uncomfortable for you to admit. politicman Dec 2015 #15

You are wrong on so many counts I can't count Yorktown Dec 2015 #18

It is you that is wrong because you dont want to admit whats makes you uncomfortable politicman Dec 2015 #21

LOL. OK, you discard studies? Then just try to reason: Yorktown Dec 2015 #24

My response politicman Dec 2015 #33

We're getting nearer to middle ground Yorktown Dec 2015 #47

response politicman Dec 2015 #53

You are all over the place Yorktown Dec 2015 #54

It's you that can't understand what racism is politicman Dec 2015 #56

I quite understand what racism is , thank you. Yorktown Dec 2015 #67

...... politicman Dec 2015 #69

..-..- Yorktown Dec 2015 #70

////////////////// politicman Dec 2015 #71

@#$%^& Yorktown Dec 2015 #72

%$^&***&^%$$##$ politicman Dec 2015 #74

777***777 Yorktown Dec 2015 #75

!#%^*&^&$#$@#% politicman Dec 2015 #79

[{<+>}] Yorktown Dec 2015 #80

$^^$^$ politicman Dec 2015 #81

<*<*<++>*>*> Yorktown Dec 2015 #82

$#@#%&^& politicman Dec 2015 #85

You really place religion before evidence Yorktown Dec 2015 #86

^%(% politicman Dec 2015 #91

Mmmhhh, interesting Yorktown Dec 2015 #95

*%%*% politicman Dec 2015 #98

My MacBook has some cool icons, but they don't translate at the DU server Yorktown Dec 2015 #99

Have you a link for "the #1 reason for support to the Front National is unemployment"? muriel_volestrangler Dec 2015 #44

Easy Yorktown Dec 2015 #55

That's a failure of logic muriel_volestrangler Dec 2015 #57

We both have a point Yorktown Dec 2015 #68

When there's 3 economic issues listed, then you'd expect them to add up to more than just one muriel_volestrangler Dec 2015 #92

The reasons add up because "it's about the economy, stupid" (not you, the old Clinton quote) Yorktown Dec 2015 #94

The point is that with people allowed to pick 2, and 1 'immigration' vs. 3 'economic' muriel_volestrangler Dec 2015 #96

Oh, sorry, I misread you Yorktown Dec 2015 #97

"Marion Mar�chal-Le Pen: the new wonder-girl of France's far-right" ucrdem Dec 2015 #12

French Ann Coulter flamingdem Dec 2015 #16

The Le Pens. mylye2222 Dec 2015 #36

The left needs to take the public's fear seriously Democat Dec 2015 #13

Oh come on. politicman Dec 2015 #17

Organized international terrorism is different from school shootings Democat Dec 2015 #31

thats a cop out politicman Dec 2015 #34

"When voters are scared, they will look for a strong leader to protect them." Trump supporters pampango Dec 2015 #43

We agree Democat Dec 2015 #50

The European left have nobody to blame but themselves LittleBlue Dec 2015 #25

Yes, they needed to do something after the attacks flamingdem Dec 2015 #62

Your first sentence is the most accurate assessment I have seen yet here DFW Dec 2015 #73

Could you elaborate? Just interested in getting an opinion from someone who actually lives smirkymonkey Dec 2015 #78

Sure DFW Dec 2015 #88

Thank you very much! smirkymonkey Dec 2015 #93

No one would like more to hear Germany's long-term plans than the Germans themselves DFW Dec 2015 #101

Sorry to hear that. Sounds like a recipe for a lot of social unrest and unfortunately smirkymonkey Dec 2015 #102

You have it pegged DFW Dec 2015 #103

thanks for an excellent answer, as always! :) nt steve2470 Dec 2015 #104

A three hour layover can be used for many things DFW Dec 2015 #105

I read the complaints from English-speaking Europeans LittleBlue Dec 2015 #87

Frankly, I can't figure the EP out. DFW Dec 2015 #89

Just as I feared malaise Dec 2015 #32

War always works for the oligarchs, doesn't it? PatrickforO Dec 2015 #52

Logic goes out the window when people see blood nt flamingdem Dec 2015 #63

Looks like ISIS got what it wanted. Act_of_Reparation Dec 2015 #58

Same thing will happen here if Democrats don't play this the right way davidn3600 Dec 2015 #59

I agree, we are merely fortunate that Trump plays this role now flamingdem Dec 2015 #61

As long as we don't play it the right wing way: "You have everything to fear including fear itself." pampango Dec 2015 #66

Hollande is willing to go to war with ISIS Dawson Leery Dec 2015 #76

Yes, but with these elections it appears that flamingdem Dec 2015 #77

Rachel doing a bit on Jean Marie Le Pen the father flamingdem Dec 2015 #106