General Discussion

HuckleB

(35,773 posts)

328. So, no criticism or praise of the work of dead artists is allowed!

Wed Jan 20, 2016, 01:15 PM

Jan 2016

It's funny that it's too hard for some people to handle more than one topic at once, and, interestingly, because they can't do so, they refer to those who can as "juvenile" or "not adult," when the truth is the exact opposite. It's also funny that some people can't simply ignore such criticism, and do their thing. They must be offended, and keep staring and responding to that which they don't like. Anyone who hangs with middle schoolers at all does see a pattern.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

453 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Glenn Frey�s death is sad, but the Eagles were a horrific band [View all] HuckleB Jan 2016 OP

.... Cal Carpenter Jan 2016 #1

Blasphemy! KamaAina Jan 2016 #2

There is one act that is worse, so we should clarify that. HuckleB Jan 2016 #7

I would take that list with a grain of salt. KamaAina Jan 2016 #57

I admit that I liked some of those bands, at first, but all of them faded with time. HuckleB Jan 2016 #61

No. 9 is in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. KamaAina Jan 2016 #64

And...? HuckleB Jan 2016 #66

Thereby proving my point that that list is mostly bogus. KamaAina Jan 2016 #81

OK, then. HuckleB Jan 2016 #84

Dude, ABBA is in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame! jmowreader Jan 2016 #245

So is number 11... GReedDiamond Jan 2016 #254

And Warren Zevon is not. OilemFirchen Jan 2016 #262

Chili peppers are going stronger than ever demwing Jan 2016 #451

This list is insanity. Ed Suspicious Jan 2016 #301

That's probably the point rockfordfile Jan 2016 #432

So the Sex Pistols edhopper Jan 2016 #68

Yup. HuckleB Jan 2016 #73

LOL, jealous I assume. Or one of the "smarter than you" DUers. OLIVE GARDEN!!! LOL. nt Logical Jan 2016 #223

The Pistols sucked.. whathehell Jan 2016 #305

They didn't push shit edhopper Jan 2016 #310

Tell it to HukleB...He's the one pushing that meme. whathehell Jan 2016 #390

The change didn't suck at all. HuckleB Jan 2016 #326

This message was self-deleted by its author HuckleB Jan 2016 #327

Believe it or not, I have actually seen Beatles-haters scurrying around the Lounge. KamaAina Jan 2016 #318

I believe it edhopper Jan 2016 #320

Blasphemy! whathehell Jan 2016 #386

I use to room with a musician who was a Beatles hater Quixote1818 Jan 2016 #406

Maybe people who have gone tone deaf from eating too many GMO's Zorra Jan 2016 #421

Oh, I can do that. Act_of_Reparation Jan 2016 #363

Ringo only wrote two Beatles songs ballabosh Jan 2016 #415

My contention is that "hyperbole" can be found in any English dictionary. Act_of_Reparation Jan 2016 #417

Wait... OilemFirchen Jan 2016 #212

That list is complete fail. Number 1 worst band of all time is Nickleback! nt LostOne4Ever Jan 2016 #271

Boring. HuckleB Jan 2016 #274

And No. 2 is Creed. KamaAina Jan 2016 #319

Well interesting that most of those bands are great and liberal. rockfordfile Jan 2016 #431

Nah, just bullshit.. whathehell Jan 2016 #314

The responses of the easily offended... HuckleB Jan 2016 #343

"Easily offended"? whathehell Jan 2016 #384

LOL! HuckleB Jan 2016 #408

I didn't want to mention it either, but now that you brought it up, The Velveteen Ocelot Jan 2016 #3

I'm impressed with how many of us there are, really. HuckleB Jan 2016 #174

I could "stand" them, at least before some of Hortensis Jan 2016 #309

Is that you, Dude? Tommy_Carcetti Jan 2016 #4

They're the Muzak version of The Flying Burrito Brothers and Gram Parsons. HuckleB Jan 2016 #13

I will say when Gene Simmons croaks, the author can go ahead and label KISS... Tommy_Carcetti Jan 2016 #25

True. HuckleB Jan 2016 #32

Unreal. Ed Suspicious Jan 2016 #302

I liked KISS. Saw them in concert twice. Waldorf Jan 2016 #54

Me too, DirtyHippyBastard Jan 2016 #159

Last time I saw them in concert was during one of thier so called last tours, pretty much everybody Waldorf Jan 2016 #178

Sorry, poor word choice, DirtyHippyBastard Jan 2016 #203

You're correct, IMO -- I hate KISS... GReedDiamond Jan 2016 #256

KISS were the muzak equivalent of the New York Dolls and the MC5. Erose999 Jan 2016 #353

Yes, KISS far exceeds any of the band listed as the worst. MoonchildCA Jan 2016 #382

Burritos Roy Ellefson Jan 2016 #106

Cheers! HuckleB Jan 2016 #127

Shit, you beat me to it. Act_of_Reparation Jan 2016 #63

I didn't realize that Jeffrey Lebowski was the writer of the article! Initech Jan 2016 #104

THANK you. whathehell Jan 2016 #392

Probably too soon. sufrommich Jan 2016 #5

The Eagles were the music you put on in the background while you did something else. jeff47 Jan 2016 #6

People listened to The Dave Matthews Band? OilemFirchen Jan 2016 #264

Hotel California edhopper Jan 2016 #8

Never mind the bollocks Facility Inspector Jan 2016 #11

Hey, hey, they're the Punk-ees Miles Archer Jan 2016 #307

The Sex Pistols sucked, but at least they did something. HuckleB Jan 2016 #16

Yeah the Sex Pistols did The Stooges with more snot. Bluenorthwest Jan 2016 #147

To be fair... HuckleB Jan 2016 #149

For punk I'll take the Clash and the Buzzcocks over the Pistols any day sweetloukillbot Jan 2016 #236

Indeed. -eom- HuckleB Jan 2016 #333

lol Go Vols Jan 2016 #439

+ a Brazilian opiate69 Jan 2016 #56

This. nt B2G Jan 2016 #120

Mom rock. Codeine Jan 2016 #160

God, thankfully not my mom laundry_queen Jan 2016 #269

Jesus, man, can you change the channel? DefenseLawyer Jan 2016 #9

Just this once krawhitham Jan 2016 #450

Perhaps there's less to the story... PJMcK Jan 2016 #10

I have fond memories of my K-Tel years as a kid. Starry Messenger Jan 2016 #12

They weren't Gen-Xers. They're boomers. HuckleB Jan 2016 #18

i wonder if the lifestyle in earlier years contributed to it JI7 Jan 2016 #77

I'm kind of baffled by boomers who seem surprised that people their age are dying. LeftyMom Jan 2016 #194

Not surprised PasadenaTrudy Jan 2016 #204

This message was self-deleted by its author LiberalArkie Jan 2016 #230

I had the same reaction. Codeine Jan 2016 #239

I was hoping the Keith Richards Singularity Field was also covering Bowie. Starry Messenger Jan 2016 #257

You'll figure it out when you get to their age.. whathehell Jan 2016 #306

Lol. Exactly. cwydro Jan 2016 #337

You got it. whathehell Jan 2016 #387

All music doesn't have to be serious exboyfil Jan 2016 #14

There you go. skypilot Jan 2016 #53

+1000 Binkie The Clown Jan 2016 #293

You are right on point exboyfil Jan 2016 #295

I agree with The Dude when it comes to The Eagles. temporary311 Jan 2016 #15

I'm getting acid flashback's to Laura Branigan's death on DU. ScreamingMeemie Jan 2016 #17

i never understood the hype either saturnsring Jan 2016 #19

Joe Fucken Walsh always seemed out of place with the Eagles. maveric Jan 2016 #20

He's great. HuckleB Jan 2016 #24

Yeah, I like Joe Walsh too. Warren DeMontague Jan 2016 #181

Ironic because of the OP but I met Joe Walsh at a Red Hot Chili Peppers Concert chowder66 Jan 2016 #193

James Gang kicks ass DirtyHippyBastard Jan 2016 #288

Neil Young's "ditch" reference from the liner notes to the "Decade" album Miles Archer Jan 2016 #308

Didn't he insist that Jimmy Page buy his Gibson Ligyron Jan 2016 #358

How Jimmy Page got his Les Paul: Miles Archer Jan 2016 #398

The Eagles were more o a Country-Country Rock INdemo Jan 2016 #21

Someone has obviously never heard Nickelback... beevul Jan 2016 #22

Lol. +1 emulatorloo Jan 2016 #40

I was about to say. backscatter712 Jan 2016 #422

I'm glad you are here to tell us that. cpwm17 Jan 2016 #23

Of course, no one told you to dislike anyone. HuckleB Jan 2016 #28

sure about that bucko? edhopper Jan 2016 #35

That's just a fact. It's not telling anyone to do anything. HuckleB Jan 2016 #39

Please post you favorite band edhopper Jan 2016 #45

Oh, goodness. HuckleB Jan 2016 #49

like laughing at people edhopper Jan 2016 #52

If you can't handle people criticizing public figures. HuckleB Jan 2016 #55

Oh is that what this is? edhopper Jan 2016 #59

Do you know how to trash a thread? HuckleB Jan 2016 #62

If you don't want to see people criticise a thread edhopper Jan 2016 #65

LOL! HuckleB Jan 2016 #70

still waiting on your favorite band? edhopper Jan 2016 #91

Keep waiting. HuckleB Jan 2016 #95

thought so edhopper Jan 2016 #96

You can start bashing bands on a daily basis with your own threads. HuckleB Jan 2016 #100

normal troll response edhopper Jan 2016 #101

You seem to want to bash some bands, so go for it. HuckleB Jan 2016 #103

you seem to want to get joy edhopper Jan 2016 #109

No one is getting joy over the death of a man. HuckleB Jan 2016 #111

you are getting joy at laughing edhopper Jan 2016 #119

I'm having fun because you've chosen to attack. HuckleB Jan 2016 #124

Great edhopper Jan 2016 #136

Awesome! HuckleB Jan 2016 #143

+1 TexasMommaWithAHat Jan 2016 #197

No, you are muriel_volestrangler Jan 2016 #195

That's cute. HuckleB Jan 2016 #277

No, it's your behaviour in the rest of the thread that's showing your character muriel_volestrangler Jan 2016 #299

You seem to think that you know the motivations of others automatically. HuckleB Jan 2016 #339

Silly Boomer here who likes the Eagles' music. And.. SammyWinstonJack Jan 2016 #209

guilty edhopper Jan 2016 #210

So you're not arguing with him. You're just telling him why he's wrong. ieoeja Jan 2016 #108

Perhaps. HuckleB Jan 2016 #112

That just tells you about the writer pintobean Jan 2016 #315

I used to cower behind implication too. LanternWaste Jan 2016 #137

Oh, goodness. HuckleB Jan 2016 #144

sure, edhopper Jan 2016 #30

I will agree with this Bonx Jan 2016 #26

If that makes you feel better... HuckleB Jan 2016 #29

I feel fine Bonx Jan 2016 #34

And yet... HuckleB Jan 2016 #37

One more. Still fine. Bonx Jan 2016 #43

I feel sorry for you. cwydro Jan 2016 #338

I'm quite happy. HuckleB Jan 2016 #340

I am sure you are in ecstacy edhopper Jan 2016 #346

You seem to think you know what I think. HuckleB Jan 2016 #348

I am just going by your actions edhopper Jan 2016 #349

No, you're not. HuckleB Jan 2016 #351

You seem to have a need to answer edhopper Jan 2016 #354

It's my thread. HuckleB Jan 2016 #364

confession? edhopper Jan 2016 #373

Yes, confession. HuckleB Jan 2016 #375

sorry if it was beyond you understanding edhopper Jan 2016 #376

I understand that your upset. HuckleB Jan 2016 #409

A wee bit ironic you fail to apply that sentiment to yourself LanternWaste Jan 2016 #378

you know what edhopper Jan 2016 #381

LOL! HuckleB Jan 2016 #410

Trashing this thread made my day. nt TeamPooka Jan 2016 #27

Just cutting the stem doesn't work Mendocino Jan 2016 #50

get outta my cab. KG Jan 2016 #31

Horrific goes a bit far Buzz cook Jan 2016 #33

When you know they were copying Gram Parsons and the Flying Burrito Brothers... HuckleB Jan 2016 #36

well... Roy Ellefson Jan 2016 #113

Listen to the recordings. The difference is astounding. HuckleB Jan 2016 #114

Stealing from others is what got Rock and Roll started Buzz cook Jan 2016 #438

Yes, we are aware of that. HuckleB Jan 2016 #440

LOL....... Logical Jan 2016 #38

So criticism is not allowed? HuckleB Jan 2016 #42

It is like saying a popular movie is the worst movie ever. Stupid. nt Logical Jan 2016 #67

And...? HuckleB Jan 2016 #78

Based on that stupid logic the best band in the world might never have been heard! LOL. Brilliant! n Logical Jan 2016 #222

Logical fallacies only relate to objective facts Major Nikon Jan 2016 #359

Utilization of argumentum ad populum is utilization of argumentum ad populum. HuckleB Jan 2016 #362

I don't think one has to pretend that anyone's taste in music is anything but subjective Major Nikon Jan 2016 #377

to be fair hfojvt Jan 2016 #51

LOL, do more reading, Ozzy asked them remove their name from the list in 1999. nt Logical Jan 2016 #72

all I said was about the so called Hall of Fame hfojvt Jan 2016 #105

Who shouldn't be in the HOF? HuckleB Jan 2016 #116

I actually found my post from 2014 on FB hfojvt Jan 2016 #196

Oh, goodness. I had a feeling it would be something like this. HuckleB Jan 2016 #367

well, if you look at other halls of fame hfojvt Jan 2016 #399

Actually, that's not true. HuckleB Jan 2016 #444

ozzy said the fans should decide, based on the eagles sales and concert tickets they had fans. nt Logical Jan 2016 #221

I am sure your whining will hurt the HOF. nt Logical Jan 2016 #225

Being successful is not cool on DU redstateblues Jan 2016 #205

actually I don't think it is THAT sad hfojvt Jan 2016 #41

is 67 old to you? Texasgal Jan 2016 #248

Isn't 67 now the "official" retirement age? DBoon Jan 2016 #266

30 is old to me hfojvt Jan 2016 #325

How did you come with up Texasgal Jan 2016 #416

I enjoyed the Eagles bigwillq Jan 2016 #44

It's another one of them music snobbery posts... ScreamingMeemie Jan 2016 #148

I love Laura Branigan. bigwillq Jan 2016 #157

Me too! xmas74 Jan 2016 #229

I loved the Eagles! I could listen to them all day asjr Jan 2016 #360

No joy over a man dying but yes, happy to be the first and only REC so far. :) Juicy_Bellows Jan 2016 #46

It's up to four. I didn't think it would get that many. HuckleB Jan 2016 #102

That was a good article. I agree. Atman Jan 2016 #47

Seven Bridges Road is a solid jam.... vi5 Jan 2016 #48

I thought it was corporate music. It was pushed on us like everything else in this country. Gregorian Jan 2016 #58

Not much different today. Atman Jan 2016 #82

There is so much great local music in most cities in this era. HuckleB Jan 2016 #93

There is so much out there now it's just incredible. Gregorian Jan 2016 #182

Umm....no Doctor_J Jan 2016 #60

The OP's hate is sad, but this is a horrific thread. Bonx Jan 2016 #71

Since when did sales mean quality? HuckleB Jan 2016 #74

Take look at the rest of the top 20 and see which ones are "horrific" Doctor_J Jan 2016 #79

Damn. There are a few, aren't there! HuckleB Jan 2016 #83

Lots of them. Thanks for the list. Atman Jan 2016 #89

McDonald's sells the most "hamburgers." Atman Jan 2016 #85

The rock and roll, man! HuckleB Jan 2016 #88

My first thought after hearing of Frey's death: FSogol Jan 2016 #69

Nice. HuckleB Jan 2016 #75

I'll confess, that was my first thought as well..... Coventina Jan 2016 #311

Right. Kelvin Mace Jan 2016 #76

They did a nice job on back-up vocals for Randy Newman. n/t bvf Jan 2016 #80

Indeed. -eom- HuckleB Jan 2016 #86

Whatever, dude .... Whiskeytide Jan 2016 #87

To each his own, I guess. Warpy Jan 2016 #90

Brave and good job. 7wo7rees Jan 2016 #92

I'm happy that more than a few seem to like it. HuckleB Jan 2016 #98

Your thread has over 4,000 views and only 12 likes. Quixote1818 Jan 2016 #265

The best line in the article: Atman Jan 2016 #94

Perfection, indeed. HuckleB Jan 2016 #97

Meh, music is obviously subjective. Arugula Latte Jan 2016 #99

No one said it was wrong to listen to anything. HuckleB Jan 2016 #110

you should read your own OP edhopper Jan 2016 #115

It doesn't say that at all. HuckleB Jan 2016 #122

that is one steaming pile of bullshit you just laid edhopper Jan 2016 #126

LOL! HuckleB Jan 2016 #141

Huck will never tell you. mac56 Jan 2016 #243

better to laugh edhopper Jan 2016 #246

He's sooooo edgy mac56 Jan 2016 #247

sooo edgy edhopper Jan 2016 #252

Oh, the irony. HuckleB Jan 2016 #341

unrec spanone Jan 2016 #107

Have to agree with The Dude as well. pa28 Jan 2016 #117

I'm betting most of the defenders don't like them either. HuckleB Jan 2016 #132

So, are you saying they were... NYC Liberal Jan 2016 #118

I loved the Eagles! itcfish Jan 2016 #121

I hate music snobs. B2G Jan 2016 #123

Cool. HuckleB Jan 2016 #125

IYHO of course. nt B2G Jan 2016 #128

It's fun to push button while maintaining the pretense of innocence. LanternWaste Jan 2016 #162

LOL! This is hilarious! HuckleB Jan 2016 #169

Hehe. SammyWinstonJack Jan 2016 #213

In your opinion. kentuck Jan 2016 #129

You forgot to add ", MAN!" HuckleB Jan 2016 #150

Right! kentuck Jan 2016 #219

No doubt they don't compare to all of your works but outside of Mozart, the Beatles, Botany Jan 2016 #130

I go to art movies w/ subtitles, but find this OP mean-spirited and tacky. SMC22307 Jan 2016 #241

I agree that the O.P. was just being an ass for no good reason. Botany Jan 2016 #312

JB's "Jamaica Say You Will"... aaaaah, so soothing. SMC22307 Jan 2016 #419

Seventies music as a whole sucked tularetom Jan 2016 #131

Except for Springsteen. edhopper Jan 2016 #133

Well, yeah, there is that tularetom Jan 2016 #151

I used to think that, too. HuckleB Jan 2016 #140

Fela Kuti...oh yeah BeyondGeography Jan 2016 #153

Even if I agreed with all those I still say the overwhelming majority of pop music released during tularetom Jan 2016 #176

Return to Forever, Chick Corea, Mahavishnu, Jan Hammer JunkYardDogg Jan 2016 #177

1970-75 was the second half of the greatest decade in the history of popular music BeyondGeography Jan 2016 #164

Maybe you should try filling that void. Here's some suggestions: onenote Jan 2016 #198

Gotta disagree. Bowie, Costello, Big Star, the Ramones, the Clash, Gang of Four, Motorhead, Erose999 Jan 2016 #355

Yeah, I personally prefer the 80's Reter Jan 2016 #423

The Clash and The Talking Heads rescued me from The Eagles BeyondGeography Jan 2016 #134

Lots of great music from that era, though it wasn't at the top of the charts then. HuckleB Jan 2016 #146

No doubt, we all entertain a wide variety of opinions- LanternWaste Jan 2016 #135

As someone once said "You're no Steely Dan" (not you HuckleB, the Eagles)..But I will admit.. BlueJazz Jan 2016 #138

Then there's the DJ who played HC over and over again at a beach in San Diego... HuckleB Jan 2016 #145

Gotta agree. peacefreak Jan 2016 #139

no,you do. wendylaroux Jan 2016 #142

OMG, this is IT, EXACTLY! ghostsinthemachine Jan 2016 #152

Great line! (The ranch dressing one.) HuckleB Jan 2016 #154

DMB is hardly The Eagles ghostsinthemachine Jan 2016 #161

Oh, no! HuckleB Jan 2016 #165

Journey! Bwhahaha! Atman Jan 2016 #163

Exactly. -eom- HuckleB Jan 2016 #166

what kind of dating rating would I get with Rainbow Skittles Jan 2016 #251

One thing you can be sure of klook Jan 2016 #155

Those folks all use ear speakers now, so I'm not worried. HuckleB Jan 2016 #156

Ha, good point klook Jan 2016 #179

Well, that was interesting. HuckleB Jan 2016 #158

It really wasn't Bonx Jan 2016 #167

It must have been, since you keep paying attention to it. HuckleB Jan 2016 #170

I've watched many things worse than this thread Bonx Jan 2016 #175

So you're interested, then. HuckleB Jan 2016 #368

Mildly 'interested' to see how a stupid OP like yours ultimately pans out Bonx Jan 2016 #437

Actions speak louder... HuckleB Jan 2016 #441

Only legends write timeless music. Rex Jan 2016 #168

"Legends." HuckleB Jan 2016 #171

Take it up with their record sales and awards. Rex Jan 2016 #250

That's not helping your case. HuckleB Jan 2016 #370

One man's opinion. And I should add that TheManInTheMac Jan 2016 #172

And that would be your opinion, MAN! HuckleB Jan 2016 #173

So you build your opinions off of movies you like? Gotcha. TheManInTheMac Jan 2016 #217

Cute. HuckleB Jan 2016 #361

Boooooooooooooo! joeybee12 Jan 2016 #180

Awwww but I LOVE The Eagles music, Boo. Keeps me chilled out. nc4bo Jan 2016 #183

How about waiting until the body's cold to venture opinions like that? Paladin Jan 2016 #184

Guy dies--- perfect time to crap on his life's work. Classy. Warren DeMontague Jan 2016 #185

To be fair... Atman Jan 2016 #186

I just don't have time to worry about all the music I can't stand. Warren DeMontague Jan 2016 #188

Apparently, you do. Atman Jan 2016 #189

Oh, I'm sure there's some overlap. Warren DeMontague Jan 2016 #192

You win. Atman Jan 2016 #199

I so agree, you nailed it nt steve2470 Jan 2016 #208

This certainly doesn't hit me the way Bowies passing did drm604 Jan 2016 #187

Bowie was mainly theatre. redstateblues Jan 2016 #207

I take great issue with Neil Young having been influenced by the Eagles. cui bono Jan 2016 #190

musically inventive Steely Dan???? KT2000 Jan 2016 #191

Thank you. (n/t) SMC22307 Jan 2016 #235

That's sarcasm. Yikes! HuckleB Jan 2016 #365

Don't say that in front of my dad. Odin2005 Jan 2016 #200

Eagle influenced Neil Young, WHAT THE HELL! randys1 Jan 2016 #201

Yeah, that is 100% unadulterated horseshit. Miles Archer Jan 2016 #237

Glad to see there is another real fan here. I am a musician but a fan first, always randys1 Jan 2016 #242

I know! That reviewer doesn't know wtf he's talking about! scarletwoman Jan 2016 #244

I'm only 51, and as such, a pretty young kid when the Eagles began bullwinkle428 Jan 2016 #255

There are exceptions to every rule lumberjack_jeff Jan 2016 #202

This message was self-deleted by its author steve2470 Jan 2016 #206

Another example of how weird reviewers are. truedelphi Jan 2016 #211

YIPPIE! i am not alone. glen better w/out teh eagles. BLEGH. pansypoo53219 Jan 2016 #214

What hits people is marked50 Jan 2016 #215

Liked first couple of albums, particularly first. Then, they changed the lineup and went corporate. Hoyt Jan 2016 #216

What a fucking stupid post. I suppose when Jimmy Carter passes away, you'll come on here madinmaryland Jan 2016 #218

You're comparing Jimmy Carter to Frey? HuckleB Jan 2016 #366

Yeah, yeah, yeah HassleCat Jan 2016 #220

I liked them.. I never cared for Punk or Disco. B Calm Jan 2016 #224

Nothing like dancing on the grave liberal N proud Jan 2016 #226

Yeah, that's my thought... MerryBlooms Jan 2016 #231

I'm pretty lukewarm on the Eagles myself cemaphonic Jan 2016 #227

Hating on the Eagles is easy now sweetloukillbot Jan 2016 #234

YEP. Rex Jan 2016 #300

Well at least we can all agree the NFL Eagles SUCK as a football team. That's what should madinmaryland Jan 2016 #228

Dave Matthews thanks youfor this message nt tishaLA Jan 2016 #232

. HuckleB Jan 2016 #372

Why does music have to be "edgie" to be enjoyed? Personally, I decidedly prefer 1monster Jan 2016 #233

Music without edges is nothingness. Codeine Jan 2016 #238

Uh huh. Tell that to Mozart, Beethoven, Tchaikovsky, 1monster Jan 2016 #258

actually... dhill926 Jan 2016 #259

Edgy? Read the contemporary reviews. Manifestor_of_Light Jan 2016 #369

I'm not bashing Frey, but yes, the Eagles were terrible. Action_Patrol Jan 2016 #240

Yeah...because the Eagles were not a rock and roll band at all jmowreader Jan 2016 #249

They sucked as a country band, too. HuckleB Jan 2016 #280

True dat, but it doesn't change what they are jmowreader Jan 2016 #282

They didn't market themselves as country. HuckleB Jan 2016 #286

Wow. Gersh Kuntzman is an asshole. PatrickforO Jan 2016 #253

He worked for the NY Post for 10 years. Go figure. nt Zorra Jan 2016 #268

Agree. nt Quixote1818 Jan 2016 #298

A republican that dislikes the Eagles rockfordfile Jan 2016 #430

I hear that Kanye is planning a tribute album. Orrex Jan 2016 #260

Over 4,000 views and only 12 likes. All I can say is FAIL! nt Quixote1818 Jan 2016 #261

You can say whatever you want to say. HuckleB Jan 2016 #414

Most of them are also very strong Democrats, especially Don Henley Quixote1818 Jan 2016 #263

Musicians who are Democrats? Shocking! HuckleB Jan 2016 #412

Wow, real classy response and nice strawman you presented to devert from your lack of respect Quixote1818 Jan 2016 #446

The critic (eeew) is probably tone deaf, and can't tell a G note from a duck fart. Zorra Jan 2016 #267

Interesting, thanks for posting that. nt Quixote1818 Jan 2016 #294

So, on DU, you now have to be not only politically correct, but musically correct as well? DFW Jan 2016 #270

+1 nt steve2470 Jan 2016 #273

Lol. HuckleB Jan 2016 #278

I read most of them. Like we used to say in grade school: DFW Jan 2016 #283

Or if you don't have anything to say, don't say anything. HuckleB Jan 2016 #285

Yeah, I see a lot of OPs that fall under that rubrique DFW Jan 2016 #287

Thanks for the confirmation. HuckleB Jan 2016 #289

gern geschehen DFW Jan 2016 #291

There are stars in the southern sky... LostOne4Ever Jan 2016 #272

Thanks for proving the author's point. HuckleB Jan 2016 #276

I don't hate The Eagles, just not much of a fan. My favorite song of theirs is still James Dean CBGLuthier Jan 2016 #275

As usual, I side with the Dude on this... RufusTFirefly Jan 2016 #279

Next you'll be telling us that the BeeGees weren't the greatest band of all time! Binkie The Clown Jan 2016 #281

Everyone is entitled... deathrind Jan 2016 #284

One thing I forgot to say - Glenn, RIP PatrickforO Jan 2016 #290

I wasn't a "fan" of anyone except the Beatles and Moodies, but Bitter Creek, man, Zen Democrat Jan 2016 #292

This thread reminds me lovemydog Jan 2016 #296

The OP shows how classy they are...yet again. U4ikLefty Jan 2016 #297

And your need to attack individuals because you can't support your stances continues. HuckleB Jan 2016 #323

Amusing how very childishly pissy some people get, when others don't like what they like, djean111 Jan 2016 #303

Kind of like when someone says "You have good taste TexasBushwhacker Jan 2016 #425

Subjective opinions about subjective subjects: we all have them nt steve2470 Jan 2016 #304

why? why? do a thread like this? themaguffin Jan 2016 #313

Why not? HuckleB Jan 2016 #324

Well you can't please everybody book_worm Jan 2016 #316

Argumentum HuckleB Jan 2016 #329

Can we at least let Frey be put in the ground first Blue_Tires Jan 2016 #317

Why? HuckleB Jan 2016 #350

I guess I'm just one of those "speak no ill of the dead" -types Blue_Tires Jan 2016 #379

Firebombing Dresden RobinA Jan 2016 #321

Words can be used to describe very different things. HuckleB Jan 2016 #322

Nope The Eagle's music was/still is good rockfordfile Jan 2016 #429

So, no criticism or praise of the work of dead artists is allowed! HuckleB Jan 2016 #328

Meh. I liked "Take it Easy" yellowcanine Jan 2016 #330

You'll like this mural in Winslow Arizona edhopper Jan 2016 #331

Yeah, saw that. Actually I fantasized about the Flatbed Ford as much as the girl. yellowcanine Jan 2016 #335

Isn't there a thread here about edhopper Jan 2016 #336

The Eagles were a great band, you must have liked Punk Rock B Calm Jan 2016 #332

"Great." HuckleB Jan 2016 #334

Considering the size of their fan base & the level of their success, apparently some would disagree. WillowTree Jan 2016 #342

Why are you reposting this... HuckleB Jan 2016 #344

I see. WillowTree Jan 2016 #356

Well because some people just don't know what they're talking about rockfordfile Jan 2016 #428

Flying Burrito Brothers > Eagles. Edgier, less stodgy, more fun. Gram Parsons set the blueprint for Erose999 Jan 2016 #345

Exactly. -eom- HuckleB Jan 2016 #347

Parsons is dead, too. It's not too late for you to talk some shit about him, though. Paladin Jan 2016 #352

Why would I talk shit about Gram Parsons? HuckleB Jan 2016 #371

You lack the standing to offer such cricism, given the ugly nature of this thread. (nt) Paladin Jan 2016 #380

+1 sketchy Jan 2016 #411

Your responses continue to make no sense. HuckleB Jan 2016 #413

WITHOUT Gram Parsons... Miles Archer Jan 2016 #401

"the Eagles were, quite simply, the worst rock and roll band." JVS Jan 2016 #357

early stuff was okay edhopper Jan 2016 #383

can't agree with that lame54 Jan 2016 #374

Edgy smedgy -- Music needn't be "edgy" to be good. whathehell Jan 2016 #385

But then it's not edhopper Jan 2016 #388

Of course.. whathehell Jan 2016 #391

And of course edhopper Jan 2016 #394

Yes whathehell Jan 2016 #395

Too true edhopper Jan 2016 #396

Yes, I believe whathehell Jan 2016 #397

Totally agree steve2470 Jan 2016 #389

Thanks...You said it way better than I did. whathehell Jan 2016 #393

This is the best discussion of the thread down here Quixote1818 Jan 2016 #400

I appreciate that, Quixote.. whathehell Jan 2016 #424

Well in all fairness, it is to someone that only knows one kind of music. Rex Jan 2016 #435

Your post makes no sense. HuckleB Jan 2016 #445

. Rex Jan 2016 #448

I largely agree. hifiguy Jan 2016 #402

I... MrWendel Jan 2016 #403

Not really, the latter part, anyway. HuckleB Jan 2016 #407

The Eagles will never be forgotten rockfordfile Jan 2016 #427

Lyin' Eyes was a horrible song. As bad as anything Kenny Rogers ever did. cheapdate Jan 2016 #404

An apt comparison, indeed. HuckleB Jan 2016 #405

I hate snobbery. Adrahil Jan 2016 #418

I hate snobbery snobbery. HuckleB Jan 2016 #420

This thread appears to have brought out an over-emotional and melodramatic side of you. LanternWaste Jan 2016 #433

Zzzzzzzzzzzzzz. HuckleB Jan 2016 #443

That writer sounds like a idiot rockfordfile Jan 2016 #426

An idiot, you mean. HuckleB Jan 2016 #442

I think REO Speedwagon was the worst rock and roll band gollygee Jan 2016 #434

Post removed Post removed Jan 2016 #436

Guardian: You mourned David Bowie, but you mock Glenn Frey. Why? arenean Jan 2016 #447

Good to see the author of that trash piece put in their place so many times. Rex Jan 2016 #449

. HuckleB Jan 2016 #452

. HuckleB Jan 2016 #453