Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

CincyDem

(7,354 posts)
9. And in an alternate universe...
Mon May 30, 2016, 09:53 AM
May 2016


...4-year old child sneaks into gorilla enclosure. Trained specialists, some with decades of experience virtually living with these animals daily, view the situation and determine that the only solution is the put Harambe down rather than being sedated.

Local hair dresser with no primate behavioral expertise jumps into the conversation and yells "wait wait, I think he's protecting the child".

Suddenly, the trained specialists look at each other and say..."hey, she's right. I never thought of that. Let's back off and hit him with a sedative dart. That should be good.". Then they turn to said hair stylist and say "Gosh, we're glad you're here...we would have killed Harambe without you".

So they plug him with the sedative and his immediate reaction is to start thrashing around, pounding the child on a rock like Judge Judy with her gavel on a bad day...all captured on video by a dozen other experts (aka zoo visitors) in the gallery. Eventually, after 4-5 minutes of thrashing around, the sedative takes effect and Harambe falls to his knees in the stream and finally keels over - trapping what's left of the child under him in the water.

Zoo director goes on TV to defend the team's action saying "we sought outside input that was, in hindsight, less than informed and we're deeply distraught over the child's death at the hands of one of our animals."


So...what's the right approach ? In either situation, the real world or the alternative universe - was Harambe going to live to see sunset (because my bet is that he wasn't going to be long for the world after whooping the kid on the rocks in the alternate universe).

In this unfortunate situation, the best thinking made the decision. It wasn't a perfect decision, just the best. Others, often without the benefit of facts or an ability to understand the facts might offer a different interpretation that feeds other agendas but, in the end, in a binary decision of "save the kid vs. save Harambe"...they made the right choice. Unfortunately, not the perfect choice.




Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

An irresponsible parent created the problem. Criticizing the first responders is silly IMO. Trust Buster May 2016 #1
Yeah, but shooting the mom wasn't really an option. Bucky May 2016 #5
It was the absolute worst decision to have to make. nolabear May 2016 #2
+1 cali May 2016 #15
Did they not have tranqs on hand? (edited response) Bucky May 2016 #3
Sorry, I'll leave it up to the zoo folks. cali May 2016 #4
Still pushing the "murder" lie? SickOfTheOnePct May 2016 #6
Zoos are a disgrace 2naSalit May 2016 #7
As bad as zoos are, EL34x4 May 2016 #21
Calling it murder makes me have no respect for your opinion. pintobean May 2016 #8
And in an alternate universe... CincyDem May 2016 #9
Wish I could rec this post n/t SickOfTheOnePct May 2016 #13
Great post cali May 2016 #16
You're absolutely right. nolabear May 2016 #19
+1 GeorgeGist May 2016 #22
Great post. momto3 May 2016 #24
I rather believe the people who have day-to-day-experience with gorillas, not a random witness. DetlefK May 2016 #10
I saw the video.. sendero May 2016 #11
I saw it, too, and agree with you. The gorilla did not seem to be attacking the Nay May 2016 #12
Gorilla murder story? edbermac May 2016 #14
Perhaps it would help to child-proof the cages? (nt) stone space May 2016 #17
Agreed. And this point was included in the zoo director's first comments. CincyDem May 2016 #18
it doesn't take malicious intent for a very large animal to accidentally kill a human magical thyme May 2016 #20
I'm absolutely certain those witnesses were all wild animal and animal behavioral experts. underahedgerow May 2016 #23
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Update on the Gorilla mur...»Reply #9