Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

auntpurl

(4,311 posts)
17. It is much more helpful to base gun ownership on past actions than mental illness diagnosis.
Sun Jun 12, 2016, 06:23 PM
Jun 2016

If someone has committed a violent act, whether that be assault or domestic violence or even road rage that results in an accident, they are far more likely to commit violence with a gun than someone with, for example, a schizophrenia diagnosis.

I never said you said "all". But you made the direct connection in your first post.

Aggressive and angry do not always (or even often) go with unstable. This is the fundamental misunderstanding. They are "crazy" in the colloquial sense, because what kind of person goes into a public establishment and murders dozens of people? But they are not unstable in the clinical sense (unless they are, as I said below. Antisocial personality disorder can lead to violence. But most violent acts are NOT committed by people with a diagnosable mental health condition.).

Terrorists are normally sane and understand fully what they are doing. NutmegYankee Jun 2016 #1
Yes. auntpurl Jun 2016 #3
Good read DustyJoe Jun 2016 #2
Well, that is clearly not true. auntpurl Jun 2016 #4
Why would you want to own something made to kill unless you want to kill? scscholar Jun 2016 #27
wonderful post. thank you. cali Jun 2016 #5
Thanks for reading. auntpurl Jun 2016 #6
When someone commits such an atrocity Aerows Jun 2016 #19
"Unstable is a mental illness": Not in the sense of diagnosis and treatment. auntpurl Jun 2016 #20
I get what you are saying - the vast majority Aerows Jun 2016 #21
I'm so sorry. auntpurl Jun 2016 #22
Just when I think things have gotten better Aerows Jun 2016 #23
I was thinking today auntpurl Jun 2016 #24
... auntpurl Jun 2016 #7
we must talk about mental illness KT2000 Jun 2016 #8
"Words are important and we all have a need to separate ourselves from such an act." auntpurl Jun 2016 #9
as memory serves me - KT2000 Jun 2016 #15
It is much more helpful to base gun ownership on past actions than mental illness diagnosis. auntpurl Jun 2016 #17
reading comprehension KT2000 Jun 2016 #18
I think there is a valid conversation as to whether it is "sane" to think a magic being in the sky Warren DeMontague Jun 2016 #10
This is why language is important. auntpurl Jun 2016 #12
I think the real reflexive denial here is to make the connection to Islamic Fundamentalism Warren DeMontague Jun 2016 #14
I believe IS needs to be wiped out. auntpurl Jun 2016 #16
It's also an easy out. progressoid Jun 2016 #11
Yes. auntpurl Jun 2016 #13
One of the greatest atrocities that St. Ronnie committed Stonepounder Jun 2016 #25
How about a person being brainwashed, I liken his actions to a violent cult-like behavior oregonjen Jun 2016 #26
I'm a hunter with a history of Depression. Odin2005 Jun 2016 #28
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Can I just say something ...»Reply #17