Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

longship

(40,416 posts)
10. "Vested in Paliament"
Sun Jun 26, 2016, 07:42 AM
Jun 2016

So Parliament can make any damned law they want with no checks in the law, which would be a fair definition of a constitution.

The UK has no constitution because there is no legal check on Parliament. Parliament can rewrite it on the fly, at their whim.

In other words, no law above Parliament. In other words, no law by which Parliament needs to abide.

In other words, no fucking constitution! A separation of powers is essential to any constitutional government where such constitution rises above any legislative pronouncements. In order to implement such a thing, an independent judiciary to adjudicate disagreements is a necessary element. The UK has none of these elements. Which means that the UK has no fucking constitution.

QED

My best to you.


Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Given some of the vicious anti-Scots xenophobia Denzil_DC Jun 2016 #1
Message auto-removed Name removed Jun 2016 #6
Scotland elected 1 (out of 50) Conservative MP in 2015. If Scotland ever leaves, Conservatives will pampango Jun 2016 #2
The broader political problem in Scotland for the rest of the UK isn't that they don't elect Tories Spider Jerusalem Jun 2016 #3
Not necessarily. This is a myth. Denzil_DC Jun 2016 #4
"Hello, Prime Minister Farage ..." How about, "Hello, President Trump"? A 'dynamic duo' pampango Jun 2016 #5
Who knows? Denzil_DC Jun 2016 #7
After the performance some of these... auntpurl Jun 2016 #32
Holy shit..."Hello, Prime Minister Farage...?" Surya Gayatri Jun 2016 #38
This message was self-deleted by its author rjsquirrel Jun 2016 #12
"The white working class was persuaded to act from fear rather than in solidarity." That is scary to pampango Jun 2016 #14
Riveting and disquieting...this is what an unbridled gutter press Surya Gayatri Jun 2016 #39
"subject to amendment on the fly whenever Parliament damn well pleases" longship Jun 2016 #8
No, the UK has a constitution (largely unwritten, but it still has one). Spider Jerusalem Jun 2016 #9
"Vested in Paliament" longship Jun 2016 #10
Nope! Spider Jerusalem Jun 2016 #11
Love your posts, Spider. But I have no choice but to disagree (respectfully). longship Jun 2016 #15
You're still wrong Spider Jerusalem Jun 2016 #16
I know about the Magna Carta and Common Law. longship Jun 2016 #20
"Common law" is not "enacted", it is the body of law derived from judicial decisions and precedent Spider Jerusalem Jun 2016 #21
King John "enacted" Magna Carta in the same sense Denzil_DC Jun 2016 #22
Indeed, he had no choice! longship Jun 2016 #26
Just wrong. There is law above parliament. Denzil_DC Jun 2016 #13
I will look that up. longship Jun 2016 #17
Magna Carta, the Petition of Right, Human Rights Act, Bill of Rights 1688, etc Spider Jerusalem Jun 2016 #18
Legal scholars will say we do, Denzil_DC Jun 2016 #19
But if parliament can override it all, what good is it? longship Jun 2016 #23
We're going round in circles here. Denzil_DC Jun 2016 #28
Wow! Thank you for this. longship Jun 2016 #31
Some people who voted on Thursday Denzil_DC Jun 2016 #24
It looks to be a very messy affair. That is for sure. longship Jun 2016 #29
Well, they can't override the UK Supreme Court, as things stand. Denzil_DC Jun 2016 #33
Well, again, I have to thank you and Spider. longship Jun 2016 #35
I don't think it's in any way describable as ignorance, Denzil_DC Jun 2016 #36
I try to always honor my DU friendships. longship Jun 2016 #37
Who and how many are the justices on the Supreme Court, and how are they appointed, Denzil? Surya Gayatri Jun 2016 #40
As far as a Scottish (or NI) 'veto' goes, others say it's not a veto, just withholding consent muriel_volestrangler Jun 2016 #25
In practise it may be the same thing Spider Jerusalem Jun 2016 #27
correct it will take about two years before UK is fully cut off from "Union", if UK ever starts Sunlei Jun 2016 #30
And, the Regrexit petition phenomenon is gaining pace: Surya Gayatri Jun 2016 #34
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Brexit, Article 50, and a...»Reply #10