Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)Please Stop Saying You Want to Go to Cuba Before It’s Ruined [View all]
Heres a terse explanation of why: a doctor, a lawyer, or another similar profession that is considered to be high-earning everywhere else in the world will make about twenty to thirty dollars per month in Cuba. Yet shampoo at the store still costs three dollars. This is because everything is supposed to be rationed out to you, but the reality is that theyre always out of most things, and your designated ration is always meager. And if you live off the land? Well, if youre a farmer and youve raised a cow, and youre starving, and your family is also starving, and you decide to kill that cow and eat it? Youll be put in jail for life. Because its not your cow, its everyones cow. Thats good ol Communism in practice.
Now, knowing this, picture me at any dinner party or Hollywood event or drugstore or press interview or pretty much any situation where someone who considers themselves cultured finds out Im Cuban. I prepare myself for the seemingly unavoidable Ooh, Cuuuuubaas if the country itself were somehow a sexy woman or delicious foodfollowed by the inevitable, I have to go there before its ruined! I try to be polite, because I am aware that, oftentimes, people who think they are very thoughtful are the least thoughtful. So I ask, What do you mean by ruined? and they always say, You know, its so cool looking! Its stuck in time! They have all the old cars and stuff Everythings gonna change soon!
So depending on the situation (and how dumb I would like to make that person feel), I will say some version of this: What exactly do you think will ruin Cuba? Running water? Available food? Freedom of speech? Uncontrolled media and Internet? Access to proper healthcare? You want to go to Cuba before the buildings get repaired? Before people can actually live off their wages? Or before the oppressive Communist regime is someday overthrown? Make sure you hurry and go observe these human beings in the time bubble that was created especially for you so that you could post a #nofilter photo of it on Instagram.
Look, part of me gets it. I appreciate good art direction just as much as anyone else, and I see that Cuba looks like a beautifully destroyed photo op. But its not your photo op. The old cars are not kitschy; they are not a choice. Its all they have. The old buildings are not preserved; their balconies are falling and killing people all the time. The very, very young girls prostituting themselves are not doing it because they cant get enough of old Canadian men, but because it pays more than being a doctor does. Hospitals for regular Cuban citizens are not what Michael Moore showed you in Sicko. (That was a Communist hospital for members of the Party and for tourists, and I, for one, think Moore fell for their North Korealike propaganda show pretty hard.) There are no janitors in the hospitals because it pays more money to steal janitorial supplies and sell them on the street than it does to actually have a job there. Therefore, the halls and rooms are covered in blood, urine, and feces, and you need to bring your own sheets, blankets, pillows, towels, and mattresses when you are admitted. Doctors have to reuse needles on patients. My moms aunt had a stroke and the doctors course of treatment was to put her feet up and let the blood rush back to her head. That was it. And this is in Havana, the big city. I cant be sure, but Id imagine things there are a lot better than they are in more remote parts of the country.
http://floodmagazine.com/34721/please-stop-saying-you-want-to-go-to-cuba-before-its-ruined/
Now, knowing this, picture me at any dinner party or Hollywood event or drugstore or press interview or pretty much any situation where someone who considers themselves cultured finds out Im Cuban. I prepare myself for the seemingly unavoidable Ooh, Cuuuuubaas if the country itself were somehow a sexy woman or delicious foodfollowed by the inevitable, I have to go there before its ruined! I try to be polite, because I am aware that, oftentimes, people who think they are very thoughtful are the least thoughtful. So I ask, What do you mean by ruined? and they always say, You know, its so cool looking! Its stuck in time! They have all the old cars and stuff Everythings gonna change soon!
So depending on the situation (and how dumb I would like to make that person feel), I will say some version of this: What exactly do you think will ruin Cuba? Running water? Available food? Freedom of speech? Uncontrolled media and Internet? Access to proper healthcare? You want to go to Cuba before the buildings get repaired? Before people can actually live off their wages? Or before the oppressive Communist regime is someday overthrown? Make sure you hurry and go observe these human beings in the time bubble that was created especially for you so that you could post a #nofilter photo of it on Instagram.
Look, part of me gets it. I appreciate good art direction just as much as anyone else, and I see that Cuba looks like a beautifully destroyed photo op. But its not your photo op. The old cars are not kitschy; they are not a choice. Its all they have. The old buildings are not preserved; their balconies are falling and killing people all the time. The very, very young girls prostituting themselves are not doing it because they cant get enough of old Canadian men, but because it pays more than being a doctor does. Hospitals for regular Cuban citizens are not what Michael Moore showed you in Sicko. (That was a Communist hospital for members of the Party and for tourists, and I, for one, think Moore fell for their North Korealike propaganda show pretty hard.) There are no janitors in the hospitals because it pays more money to steal janitorial supplies and sell them on the street than it does to actually have a job there. Therefore, the halls and rooms are covered in blood, urine, and feces, and you need to bring your own sheets, blankets, pillows, towels, and mattresses when you are admitted. Doctors have to reuse needles on patients. My moms aunt had a stroke and the doctors course of treatment was to put her feet up and let the blood rush back to her head. That was it. And this is in Havana, the big city. I cant be sure, but Id imagine things there are a lot better than they are in more remote parts of the country.
http://floodmagazine.com/34721/please-stop-saying-you-want-to-go-to-cuba-before-its-ruined/
Great article by an actual Cuban. "See it before it's ruined" has become such a cliché.
140 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Everything beautiful and authentic will be destroyed if market values comes in.
Ken Burch
Jun 2016
#1
If the values switch from collective solidarity to nothing but individual self-interest
Ken Burch
Jun 2016
#5
You should read more. There is a whole economic spectrum between capitalism and communism.
DetlefK
Jun 2016
#66
"Poland and Hungary will be nothing but right-wing and anti-democratic for the rest of eternity"
AntiBank
Jun 2016
#91
If Cuba goes full-on capitalist, no humane social values can be preserved there.
Ken Burch
Jun 2016
#6
Prostitution, starvation and hospitals covered in human waste are humane social values?
Nuclear Unicorn
Jun 2016
#75
"And a market values Cuba would never be a place where ... anarchism would be allowed to spread."
mahatmakanejeeves
Jun 2016
#87
That was in response to Nuclear Unicorn, whose avatar is the anarchist symbol.
Ken Burch
Jun 2016
#102
The root cause of all of it was the massive austerity imposed on those countries
Ken Burch
Jun 2016
#109
So your saying an influx of money into the country in the form of resorts, golf courses, restaurant,
frankieallen
Jun 2016
#103
Those things exist here, and they do nothing to stop people having to sleep rough.
Ken Burch
Jun 2016
#104
so they will hire only rich people to construct the buildings, clean rooms, server food, cook,
frankieallen
Jun 2016
#108
You should say "those whom the system prevents from working" not "those who do not work"
Ken Burch
Jun 2016
#110
fine, you have a flip phone. You are in solidarity with your Cuban bros and sisters
frankieallen
Jun 2016
#134
Well. consider that you are also expressing your opinion of how you think they should progress
newthinking
Jun 2016
#15
You're right: advocating for them to make their own decisions, is, in a way..
Dreamer Tatum
Jun 2016
#18
"supporting democracy does mean wanting them to make their own decisions"
Dreamer Tatum
Jun 2016
#36
Sit glumly and wait for my moral betters to pass judgment on me on the internet.
Dreamer Tatum
Jun 2016
#32
blaming the political situation in Poland and Hungary on capitalism or on the market
uhnope
Jun 2016
#62
There is a GORGEOUS McDonald's right next to the Spanish Steps in Rome--to the right as you go up.
MADem
Jun 2016
#9
2nd picture, bottom left, is that 5 (at least) different kinds of salad to choose from?
Electric Monk
Jun 2016
#21
It's not warped to believe a capitalist restoration in Cuba can't be anything but a tragedy.
Ken Burch
Jun 2016
#42
the US is far better off than Cuba. they risk their lives to come here. you don't see that happening
JI7
Jun 2016
#52
how come you can't point to specific examples ? you are too hung up on trying to prove how liberal
JI7
Jun 2016
#58
It should be up to them how they want to live. They don't exist for fulfill the fantasies of
lunamagica
Jun 2016
#126
Yep. In five words you have provided a comprehensive, erudite, and devastating rebuttal
Nye Bevan
Jun 2016
#17
This is really the first you've heard about the poverty and dysfunction in Cuba?
Recursion
Jun 2016
#30
Cuba has problems. The reintroduction of massive corporations can't solve them.
Ken Burch
Jun 2016
#39
What about the millions forcibly driven from their homes so useless megadams could be built?
Ken Burch
Jun 2016
#47
That should be "the problem SOME socialists have". There is no unified "line" on that.
Ken Burch
Jun 2016
#139
This is the first time I have heard a bottle of shampoo is 15% a doctor's monthly income
Ash_F
Jun 2016
#67
Don't know much about it, outside of what people who have been there have written.
Ash_F
Jun 2016
#71
I posted down thread about my recent visit. Personal toiletries are in short supply and expensive.
Coventina
Jun 2016
#138
Thank you, great post. My daughter and son-in-law visited and they loved the place.
akbacchus_BC
Jun 2016
#38
I disagree that Cuba will lose its values to America's engagement. They been there and know
akbacchus_BC
Jun 2016
#49
Of course there's always someone somewhere telling us what to say and not say.
LanternWaste
Jun 2016
#69
I know, those uppity ethnic groups saying "please don't say this" and "please don't say that",
Nye Bevan
Jun 2016
#83
Let's keep in mind that Cuba is so 'authentic' in largely because of the embargo
RandySF
Jun 2016
#76
Yes. Although we were given lots of free time to go and do whatever we wished.
Coventina
Jun 2016
#129
ITT: Cuban emigre wankers and tankies argue while everyone else shakes their head
forjusticethunders
Jun 2016
#93