Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

In reply to the discussion: Prometheus sucked... [View all]

muriel_volestrangler

(105,948 posts)
28. Here's a review by an archaeologist
Tue Jun 12, 2012, 05:35 AM
Jun 2012

who has a bone or two to pick with the spaceship budget:

Fassbender cycles around the spaceship, throwing basketballs into hoops and watching documentaries. You get a feel for the size of the spaceship, and his lonely existence within it. For a crew of less than ten people, the financiers and engineers behind the expedition have sensibly decided that creating a space-ship the size of a cathedral would be a good idea. Presumably neglecting to install an off switch for a robot was just one of those costs they had to cut to make the whole thing possible. To pass the time he likes watching old films and learning languages. We like him. That’s even before all the humans wake up and prove to be barking mad or arseholes. Or barking mad arseholes.
...
The first duty of the captain is, naturally, to decorate the Christmas tree. Because it’s Christmas apparently. Charlize Theron reminds him that there is a mission briefing. He informs her that he has yet to have breakfast. He’s been asleep for two years, and decides to decorate a Christmas tree (while smoking a cigar in a closed environment) before he has breakfast. We realise that the crew selection procedure was yet another casualty of the cuts required to ensure that they had a sodding big spaceship (SBS from here on in).

At the breakfast table a rather nice biologist (played by Raef Spall, son of Timothy) introduces himself to a grumpy geologist, who is very rude. Later on, he confirms he’s the geologist, by shouting “I’m a geologist, I fucking love rocks!” as if that was the most pressing point that needed explaining. But we’re getting ahead of ourselves. The current point that needs explaining is the implication that these two crew members have managed to make it this far without actually meeting each other, and are plainly incompatible. It seems that at least one part of the crew selection procedure took the form of a raffle at an arsehole convention.

The crew is gathered. Two of the chaps at the front are betting that it’s a terraforming expedition. Apparently they don’t know why they’re here either. You’d think they’d shown a little curiosity when, for instance, they were packing and saying goodbye to their loved ones. Or climbing on board the SBS. Or going into suspended animation. But no.

http://digitaldigging.net/prometheus-an-archaeological-perspective/


Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Prometheus sucked... [View all] Demonaut Jun 2012 OP
So it's your average movie. HuckleB Jun 2012 #1
Sorry to hear that. Frank Cannon Jun 2012 #2
Miscast how? dogknob Jun 2012 #4
I'm going to guess that Snow White was miscast. MissB Jun 2012 #5
And you'd be right. Frank Cannon Jun 2012 #10
Kristen Stewart Frank Cannon Jun 2012 #8
she is absolutely awful Skittles Jun 2012 #12
Maybe she'll be like Nicole Kidman. Frank Cannon Jun 2012 #17
We'll have to put up with here as long as the twilight gush continues... Javaman Jun 2012 #35
Movie was very good except for Kristen Stewart Nancy Waterman Jun 2012 #47
They should have cast Amy Adams from the movie "Enchanted," she blew me away with her acting Uncle Joe Jun 2012 #48
I agree. sh80 Jul 2012 #49
I agree. And I haven't even seen it yet. Speck Tater Jun 2012 #16
To defend Ms. Stewart Xyzse Jun 2012 #45
What was the miscast? lookingfortruth Jun 2012 #27
I liked it..even though Thor's attempt at a Scottish brogue was laughable... truebrit71 Jun 2012 #44
I am not into dark sci-fi but felt it did a good job taking on some big philosophical questions Quixote1818 Jun 2012 #3
Also... Sprach Zarathustra WillyT Jun 2012 #6
I thought this guy had some interesting points Quixote1818 Jun 2012 #7
agreed ibegurpard Jun 2012 #18
This guy is great... trumad Jun 2012 #29
I found this review to be pretty decent and insightful SaB2012 Jun 2012 #9
It is. Thanks for the link! n/t Bolo Boffin Jun 2012 #11
I actually thought a lot of the dumb things people did is exactly what a corporate crew would do Quixote1818 Jun 2012 #15
too long a review............succinctly...it sucked Demonaut Jun 2012 #19
Yeah, I read that review earlier today and found it mostly spot-on. nt Poll_Blind Jun 2012 #21
Can't go wrong with Rotten Tomatoes critic & audience reviews. Here: FarLeftFist Jun 2012 #23
I didn't really like it either EarlG Jun 2012 #13
Hey,he gave us fire. Swede Jun 2012 #14
Is PROMETHEUS SUCKED the sequel the Atlas Shrugged? cthulu2016 Jun 2012 #20
LOL. But don't you mean 'Anthem?' RZM Jun 2012 #22
Prometheus and Atlas were brothers muriel_volestrangler Jun 2012 #26
They're moons of Saturn, too. sofa king Jun 2012 #33
I didn't like it. calimary Jun 2012 #24
It was a great comedy thelordofhell Jun 2012 #25
Here's a review by an archaeologist muriel_volestrangler Jun 2012 #28
That review is long, hilarious, and absolutely spot-on! ljm2002 Jun 2012 #32
I haven't seen it, but it does sound ripe for the Mystery Science Theater 3000 treatment (nt) muriel_volestrangler Jun 2012 #38
Having just read it, and as someone that enjoyed the film I have to agree... truebrit71 Jun 2012 #39
Jesus, I need to start watching movies with that guy Blue_Tires Jun 2012 #42
I thought it was great. And I'm not an action movie lover, as a rule. Honeycombe8 Jun 2012 #30
It lacked suspense, but... JHB Jun 2012 #31
you're right, it did lack suspense. Javaman Jun 2012 #36
Here's an interesting blog on the movie. it's worth reading... Javaman Jun 2012 #34
That was a great read! Thanks. nt Quixote1818 Jun 2012 #43
I disagree...thought it was definitely a B+ truebrit71 Jun 2012 #37
I'm saving my money for that Abe Lincoln Vampire Hunter Flick. Ganja Ninja Jun 2012 #40
Thanks for saving me 10 bucks Blue_Tires Jun 2012 #41
I watched Alien (1979) in hd over the weekend. I really love the real models, old-school special fx Romulox Jun 2012 #46
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Prometheus sucked...»Reply #28