Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Do We Disrespect Rural America? [View all]It's not about winning hearts and minds they can't be reasoned with, Hillary was right they're not redeemable so why try.
Were you a strategist for the Viet Nam war? If that is your approach, you've already lost and those on the margins will move away also.
But I tell you what, go ahead. See how well it works out for you. When tRump carries those areas in 2020 to win re-election when another royal blue blood screech is run, what will your reaction then be? Going to double down on 'punishing' them? Denying them emergency assistance & ambulance service? Is that what being liberal now means? What next? Close their hospitals and medical clinics? Hey! Here's an idea that'll really get them to come around, deny their elderly Medicare & Medicaid. Close the nursing homes and throw their grandmothers out on the street. They're not redeemable, so why bother?
Put any dog in a corner and start kicking them, and they're going to bite you. And you don't think that these people are any better than dogs? Quite progressive of you. These people may not have an Ivy League diploma on their wall but they would see their situation is worsening due to (D) actions. And do you think that they're go lick the boots that kick them?
So inclusive.
So diverse.
So tolerant of you.
With this type of approach and attitude, winning in 2020 has zero possibility. These people voted not because they're bigots but voted their jobs & futures. How many had been laid off for years and drove past the padlocked factory where they used to work while promised some pie-in-the-sky service job while Hillary was supporting TRRP that was going to ship more of their jobs overseas. Someone that looked like a pissed off ex-wife that only went to $100,000/plate events didn't appeal to them. Stop and think!, the cost of one plate was three times what these people made in a year. And she was somehow a better option that tRump?
Again, Bernie would have appealed and reached out to these people and would have won. And won big.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
119 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
i don't think they are dumb either that's why i think most voted for him over bigotry
JI7
Nov 2016
#3
that's true of city and surburban types also. they might have more formal education but not much
JI7
Nov 2016
#12
I think religion has a lot to do with it. The refusal to look at things critically.
smirkymonkey
Nov 2016
#54
I think mostly fundamentalist religions. Not the more liberal denominations
smirkymonkey
Nov 2016
#73
Sorry, didn't mean to clump them all in together! The south and midwest are filled
smirkymonkey
Nov 2016
#75
Iowa has always had a strong evangelical side to it so i'm not too surprised by that . Wisconsin had
JI7
Nov 2016
#16
Totally agree. They finally had a chance to strike back against POC, Muslims, LGTB, Latinos and
Fla Dem
Nov 2016
#117
However a formal education teaches one to think critically and that is what they lack.
smirkymonkey
Nov 2016
#55
They are not educated in the respect of cultural aspects. Sorry but I too have lived in
ebbie15644
Nov 2016
#107
Trump praised them for being uneducated and they cheered . Why the insult now?.
lunasun
Nov 2016
#50
in 2012 West Virginia Democratic Primary a Prison inmate got more than 40 percent of the vote
JI7
Nov 2016
#17
I think Rural America has been victims of a steady diet of right-wing propaganda
meow2u3
Nov 2016
#27
I've always wondered why this is only from the right. Maybe right wing stuff sells better. Many
RKP5637
Nov 2016
#58
And sadly so many people hear/watch it and think their BS is the absolute truth. n/t
RKP5637
Nov 2016
#114
if they immediately identified with being a deplorable then it seems most likely the townspeople
lunasun
Nov 2016
#43
Maybe you're right, maybe they shouldn't be allowed to leave until the demonstrate
ileus
Nov 2016
#95
Because if for no other reason the country can't be governed with political control of
TheKentuckian
Nov 2016
#90
Rural areas send the cities energy supplies, food, fiber, and construction materials
FarCenter
Nov 2016
#88