General Discussion

Hoyt

(54,770 posts)

59. Are you denying SOME people join the military for guns, bombs, glory, and all that BS.

Fri Dec 16, 2016, 07:17 PM

Dec 2016

We can argue all night on how many do that. I think it is a lot. The guys who joined up right after high school where I came from were looking for the WWII type glory, were into guns and the gung ho junk, were quick to believe some peasant in a rice paddy was going to take over the USA, and similar BS.

Do you think the majority of the military who supported george war bush, and apparently support Trump, are there for some other reason?

One can serve their country in a lot of ways besides joining an organization where you will be taught to lay down a barrage that will likely kill a bunch of innocent people, push buttons that launch bombs and will kill a bunch of innocent people, or peel potatoes to feed those that do. I'm sorry, this is not WWI or WWII. It's hard to call any of the wars we've been in since then as wars of necessity.

You never have answered why you joined up.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

73 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Are we going to reinstate the draft? [View all] elehhhhna Dec 2016 OP

Yes, and it will include women this time greymattermom Dec 2016 #1

Better not unless they quickly pass the ERA. nt DURHAM D Dec 2016 #3

Supreme Court 14th amendment rulings have surpassed the ERA long ago. former9thward Dec 2016 #7

while the 14th Amendment at times has been interpreted to benefit women, it offers them no assurance LanternWaste Dec 2016 #18

Yup. n t Laffy Kat Dec 2016 #26

Enough political capital to reinstate a draft will also mean enough to include women without having Warren DeMontague Dec 2016 #61

You mean create a new one? "THE" ERA is long dead. Thor_MN Dec 2016 #69

Some argue otherwise. DURHAM D Dec 2016 #72

I agree, there should be equal rights for everyone, but it is your point that is off point. Thor_MN Dec 2016 #73

Mostly the same people who join now will sign up-- Those who Hoyt Dec 2016 #2

Spoken like a man who has fuck-all experience in the military. linuxman Dec 2016 #8

Way to shit on the armed forces. I know many who serve honorably and who are not xenophobes NightWatcher Dec 2016 #9

Thanks Jersey Devil Dec 2016 #15

Don't know about your son-in-law, but some of the vilest insults I've heard about Muslims Hoyt Dec 2016 #44

No. Military supported george war bush, polls show they support Trump, and Hoyt Dec 2016 #19

A surprisingly large amount enlist to get money for school. Calculating Dec 2016 #23

We need to change that. Killing for school ought not to be their only option. Hoyt Dec 2016 #28

That is a sad truth etherealtruth Dec 2016 #66

This message was self-deleted by its author Jake Stern Dec 2016 #31

The post you responded to is not in conflict with yours. Lil Missy Dec 2016 #33

I responded to a post calling troops racists and xenophobes NightWatcher Dec 2016 #56

My but you do go to great lengths to read SO MUCH more into comments Lil Missy Dec 2016 #68

You think THAT'S insulting? resistance2016 Dec 2016 #64

As a lifelong Democratic sarisataka Dec 2016 #67

Wow Calculating Dec 2016 #12

I can't begin to express my disgust at your besmirching my family and friends SQUEE Dec 2016 #16

The bar to enlist is not tough, don't kid yourself. I know several kids who Hoyt Dec 2016 #25

Flag on the play sarisataka Dec 2016 #34

Drugs and juvenile delinquency type stuff. I know darn well it happens. Hoyt Dec 2016 #37

take their problem kids and put them in military school. SQUEE Dec 2016 #43

Drug charges are the hardest convictions sarisataka Dec 2016 #49

Do you not get the Judge is giving the kid a choice -- go to trial and get convicted or join Hoyt Dec 2016 #57

And again SQUEE Dec 2016 #36

I took the test, my cat could have passed it too. Hoyt Dec 2016 #38

8 years ago is not recent. SQUEE Dec 2016 #41

Oh, the kid being told to join the military is like 5 years ago. Hoyt Dec 2016 #47

nice strawman. SQUEE Dec 2016 #50

So did you join up, or would you have, after bush invaded and killed thousands Hoyt Dec 2016 #53

I joined the Army under Poppy Bush SQUEE Dec 2016 #70

Daddy bush really wasn't that bad, but he shouldn't have killed quite so many Innocent Iraqis. Hoyt Dec 2016 #71

What a pathetic post, applying your usual broad brush attack against those in the military Lurks Often Dec 2016 #24

Another gunner promoting the MIC, not surprising. Hoyt Dec 2016 #39

Please reconsider this statement. HassleCat Dec 2016 #29

That's your prerogative. Are you in the category I described? If not, don't fret. Hoyt Dec 2016 #40

Yes, I am in the category. HassleCat Dec 2016 #46

That's obvious. My question was were you brought Hoyt Dec 2016 #48

Your initial post made a pretty sweeping generalization. HassleCat Dec 2016 #58

Are you denying SOME people join the military for guns, bombs, glory, and all that BS. Hoyt Dec 2016 #59

I was in from 1972 to 1978. HassleCat Dec 2016 #60

That's a commendable explanation. Navy was my preference too, well after the Coast Guard said I Hoyt Dec 2016 #63

Your autocorrect is seriously dorked. KamaAina Dec 2016 #52

The apparatus remains in place gratuitous Dec 2016 #4

The future is hopeless. deaniac21 Dec 2016 #5

Indeed Calculating Dec 2016 #11

Unlikely. Current warfare doesn't really involve the MineralMan Dec 2016 #6

Not so sure our military has outgrown the need for large numbers of warm bodies. Girard442 Dec 2016 #10

That's a good point, but the sheer number of people MineralMan Dec 2016 #20

I remember an interview years ago with a General or someone like that meadowlark5 Dec 2016 #32

IOW, the military doesn't want or need cannon fodder. DinahMoeHum Dec 2016 #45

my son turned 18 last Saturday 0rganism Dec 2016 #13

Your son is not going to be drafted Lurks Often Dec 2016 #27

and Donald Trump will definitely never be president, right? 0rganism Dec 2016 #30

Anybody who posted that Trump had a chance was ignored, mocked and alerted on. Lurks Often Dec 2016 #51

I think there are a lot of young, male fools out there who think Warpy Dec 2016 #14

Really? You think all who enlist are "fools" out for "glory"? (nt) Jersey Devil Dec 2016 #17

Hardly. I do think many of the ones looking for a fight under Twittler are Warpy Dec 2016 #21

Not this nonsense again Lurks Often Dec 2016 #22

I was in the army during 1964 thru 1967 zippythepinhead Dec 2016 #35

FYI zippythepinhead Dec 2016 #42

The US may have to. We are being cyber attacked by Russia, which is making moves on Europe... Hekate Dec 2016 #54

Maybe all of those sarisataka Dec 2016 #55

No. Warren DeMontague Dec 2016 #62

I hope so dumbcat Dec 2016 #65