General Discussion

Doreen

(11,686 posts)

44. I will make it simple to understand from what I see.

Sat Feb 18, 2017, 08:31 PM

Feb 2017

I have known mentally ill people of different mental illnesses most likely I have met all of those illnesses. I have seen a lot of them with the same issues that Trump does have but non of them are hateful like he is. It is possible to have a mental illness and be a bad and evil person at the same time. His hate does not come from mental illness but his behavior does. Yes, he is narcissistic but his concern for himself also goes into him just being a bad person.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

84 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Stop saying Donald Trump is mentally ill when what you mean is that he's a bad person [View all] loyalsister Feb 2017 OP

He is mentally ill MFM008 Feb 2017 #1

+1,000!!! AgadorSparticus Feb 2017 #3

Mental illness is not pornography loyalsister Feb 2017 #9

after 2 years of psychology MFM008 Feb 2017 #10

2 yrs? loyalsister Feb 2017 #19

I can diagnose Donald from right here. kwassa Feb 2017 #20

You can diagnosis to your hearts delight loyalsister Feb 2017 #24

I think it is both valid and reasonable. kwassa Feb 2017 #28

People are desperate to get rid of 45 loyalsister Feb 2017 #33

This mental illness claim is completely legitimate. kwassa Feb 2017 #38

Cautionary statement for DSM IV - TR rug Feb 2017 #73

I think you're going overboard with your criticism. Eyeball_Kid Feb 2017 #58

You may not realize it... lame54 Feb 2017 #82

And Bill Frist was sure he could diagnose Terri Schiavo mythology Feb 2017 #40

and you can take all the tea in China. kwassa Feb 2017 #41

I have a good friend who is a PHD clinical psychologist and professor. Hassin Bin Sober Feb 2017 #42

I have a good friend who is a PHD clinical psychologist and professor. LenaBaby61 Feb 2017 #46

Yeah 2 years worth of Psychology MFM008 Feb 2017 #23

That's what I was MFM008 Feb 2017 #61

I don't understand how speaking of one person in particular tars everyone with the same brush. Demit Feb 2017 #12

It's bigotry in action loyalsister Feb 2017 #29

That's not an exact analogy. Demit Feb 2017 #37

People are saying mentally ill, dementia, loyalsister Feb 2017 #63

Thats a pretty broad brush MFM008 Feb 2017 #67

This seems to be on going issue here bdamomma Feb 2017 #49

He is mentally ill AND a bad person. LenaBaby61 Feb 2017 #45

He is both, clearly Alice11111 Feb 2017 #52

This yuiyoshida Feb 2017 #64

. Egnever Feb 2017 #71

I agree..he's not mentally ill but I wouldn't rule out a personality disorder. TrekLuver Feb 2017 #2

Personality disorders ARE mental illnesses NoGoodNamesLeft Feb 2017 #16

Ok I like this...yes he has a mental illness with a character defect and this shit show is the end TrekLuver Feb 2017 #30

I also think he is in the early stages of dementia. nt tblue37 Feb 2017 #26

Sorry, but you can be both mentally ill and an evil person JenniferJuniper Feb 2017 #4

yeah, well... he's mentally ill AND a bad person. Squinch Feb 2017 #5

Can we say "emotionally disturbed"? n/t ginnyinWI Feb 2017 #6

Mentally ill. Without question. Comatose Sphagetti Feb 2017 #7

and I agree. MFM008 Feb 2017 #68

Donald Trump Isnt Mentally Ill. Hes Just Unpleasant, Psychiatrist Says Kilgore Feb 2017 #8

If it's wrong to diagnose someone as mentally ill from afar, then it's just as wrong to Demit Feb 2017 #11

Not mentally ill is the default and does not need to be proven loyalsister Feb 2017 #22

That's what I'm saying. Dr Frances is saying Trump doesn't meet his criteria for Demit Feb 2017 #31

The Dr. is saying it is not legitimate to make the claim loyalsister Feb 2017 #34

The Dr said "I wrote the criteria that define this disorder, and Mr. Trump doesn't meet them." Demit Feb 2017 #39

Exactly loyalsister Feb 2017 #17

And he's full of shit up to his eyebrows NoGoodNamesLeft Feb 2017 #21

I think he DOES suffer from distress. He is clearly distressed when he tweets. Amaryllis Feb 2017 #43

He sees things that are clearly not there lame54 Feb 2017 #83

Trump is an evil person who also happens to be mentally ill NoGoodNamesLeft Feb 2017 #13

My question bdamomma Feb 2017 #55

Trump is a billh58 Feb 2017 #14

I think he's a dreadful, bad person probably with a personality disorder. NT Ilsa Feb 2017 #15

I just said the same thing to myself bdamomma Feb 2017 #57

Asshole, Dipshit, and Fuckwad are not in the DSM 5!!! NightWatcher Feb 2017 #18

they sure should be MFM008 Feb 2017 #69

But Antisocial Personality Disorder is. pat_k Feb 2017 #74

The Author of This New York Times Op-Ed Agrees. mahatmakanejeeves Feb 2017 #25

He's a bad person who also has severe mental problems CanonRay Feb 2017 #27

I truly believe he is mentally ill and he is also a bad person nt doc03 Feb 2017 #32

It is possible to be both, ya know. nt Laffy Kat Feb 2017 #35

No cure for stupid Worktodo Feb 2017 #36

I will make it simple to understand from what I see. Doreen Feb 2017 #44

He could be both. Warren DeMontague Feb 2017 #47

He NUTS and drunk at the same time. Case closed! Stellar Feb 2017 #48

He is mentally unstable and unpredictable lynintenn Feb 2017 #50

I think he is both - he has a dark soul and is mentally ill Pachamama Feb 2017 #51

I believe he is mentally ill and a bad person. NCTraveler Feb 2017 #53

I think it is irrelevant. HopeAgain Feb 2017 #54

Trump is an asshole, evil, etc, AND MENTALLY ILL kennetha Feb 2017 #56

He is raving mad liberal N proud Feb 2017 #59

Oh, good. oldcynic Feb 2017 #60

Stop telling me what to say. trof Feb 2017 #62

You're not the boss of me now... yuiyoshida Feb 2017 #65

The two states of being are not mutually exclusive. He is both evil & perhaps sliding into dementia Hekate Feb 2017 #66

I suppose there's a possibility that he's acting... qdouble Feb 2017 #70

Psychopaths are not generally a nice bunch pat_k Feb 2017 #72

I don't know if he's bad pressbox69 Feb 2017 #75

Cheers to that loyalsister! C Moon Feb 2017 #76

There is nothing "normal" or "average" about his behavior. VOX Feb 2017 #77

Maybe he's just a huge ASSHOLE Soxfan58 Feb 2017 #78

People suspected Reagan had dementia while he was in office... Sancho Feb 2017 #79

Trump is both: mentally ill and bad. Vinca Feb 2017 #80

Fuck that - He's Crazy! lame54 Feb 2017 #81

Jerk, goof, oddball, pain in the ass-- JohnnyLib2 Feb 2017 #84