Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Fantastic Anarchist

(7,309 posts)
49. You'll find this interesting:
Sat Mar 18, 2017, 05:18 PM
Mar 2017

The anarchist, Prince Peter Kropotkin, in 1903 studied the animal kingdom inter- and intra-species (including humans) cooperation vs competition, essentially building on Darwin. He came up with Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution (available for free online).

His conclusion was that societies that cooperated tended to survive over societies that competed.

Wiki:

Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution is a 1902 essay collection by Russian anarchist philosopher Peter Kropotkin. The essays, initially published in the English periodical The Nineteenth Century between 1890 and 1896, explore the role of mutually-beneficial cooperation and reciprocity (or "mutual aid&quot in the animal kingdom and human societies both past and present. It is an argument against the competition-centred theories of so-called social Darwinism, as well as the romantic depictions of cooperation presented by writers such as Jean-Jacques Rousseau, who argued it was motivated by universal love rather than self-interest. Mutual Aid is considered a fundamental text in anarchist communism, presenting a scientific basis for communism alternative to the historical materialism of the Marxists. Many biologists also consider it an important catalyst in the scientific study of cooperation.

Daniel P. Todes, in his account of Russian naturalism in the 19th century, concludes that Kropotkin’s work "cannot be dismissed as the idiosyncratic product of an anarchist dabbling in biology" and that his views "were but one expression of a broad current in Russian evolutionary thought that pre-dated, indeed encouraged, his work on the subject and was by no means confined to leftist thinkers."[1]

Kropotkin pointed out the distinction between the direct struggle among individuals for limited resources (generally called competition) and the more metaphorical struggle between organisms and the environment (tending to be cooperative). He therefore did not deny the competitive form of struggle, but argued that the cooperative counterpart has been underemphasized: "There is an immense amount of warfare and extermination going on amidst various species; there is, at the same time, as much, or perhaps even more, of mutual support, mutual aid, and mutual defense...Sociability is as much a law of nature as mutual struggle."[2]

As a description of biology, Kropotkin's work has been confirmed by recent research. Stephen Jay Gould admired Kropotkin's observations, noting that cooperation, if it increases individual survival, is not ruled out by natural selection, and is in fact encouraged.[3] Modern biology confirms Kropotkin's observations in two ways. When different species appear to aid each other, it is a case of mutualism. When individuals within a species aid each other, it is a case of altruism in animals, including kin selection and reciprocal altruism. Douglas H. Boucher places Kropotkin's book as a precursor to the development of mutualism as a theory.[4]


It's a fascinating read, and should be shared as much as possible.

The society is nothing without the individual, however, the individual is nothing without society.

It's this sort of interconnectedness between the individual and society that makes up the whole. You cannot damage one part without damaging the other.

This is what the reactionaries do not get. They can't think outside of their immediate body or tribe. Reactionary thinking is incapable of thinking of the whole except as a tool for fascism. It doesn't matter if you are a Buckley uber-capitalist or a Leninist Bolshevik. Both reactionary foundations limit the perception of the whole to the individuals (make no mistake, the Leninists see the same individualist few who would be masters of the economy, just as the Buckley capitalists, who would use society for their fascist ends). In both, you have the managerial class that would govern on behalf of the masses (mixing political authority with economic authority). One is a dictatorship of the proletariat, the other, a dictatorship of the capitalists. Words mean nothing here, because guess who owned and dictated? The same people! Just refer to Right-Wing Authoritarianism for more information. The term is not a political term here as it explains the American Libertarians just as much as it explains the Communist Party Apparatchiks - subservience to authority.

Much editing due to making this post on my phone, apologies for any errors or incoherence.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I don't know...but it's so sad lisa58 Mar 2017 #1
Just Curious jaxind Mar 2017 #2
Yes, we were here on election day Mr. Ected Mar 2017 #9
I know how that feels. I had faith in my people to do the right thing, too. Silver Gaia Mar 2017 #15
We are the Un-United States of insatiable greed and unfortunately democratisphere Mar 2017 #3
You damage you thesis by referring to the "Russian and Putin communists." Putin and KingCharlemagne Mar 2017 #20
Many Russians and Putin act like former communists. democratisphere Mar 2017 #32
Sigh They do NOT act like former communists (or current communists). The KingCharlemagne Mar 2017 #33
Sure seems like Cold War 2.0 to me; Russians and Putin hacking everything democratisphere Mar 2017 #37
This Cold War v 2.0 to which you allude is happening between capitalist-imperialist KingCharlemagne Mar 2017 #38
And don't forget starving 10 million Ukrainians to death... malchickiwick Mar 2017 #63
Funny how we NEVER hear about how many Americans died of starvation KingCharlemagne Mar 2017 #66
I totally get what you're saying. Fantastic Anarchist Mar 2017 #53
Without commenting on your specific claims, I will simply note KingCharlemagne Mar 2017 #67
Oh, I agree that anarchism and communism are the same. Fantastic Anarchist Mar 2017 #69
This is how my family does it madokie Mar 2017 #4
the paul slimey ryans and the creepy greedy vicious monster trumps Cha Mar 2017 #5
You are always so kind and insightful, Cha Mr. Ected Mar 2017 #10
Thank you, Mr. Ected.. you luckies! Cha Mar 2017 #12
Education? Scarsdale Mar 2017 #6
Thank you for sharing your story. smirkymonkey Mar 2017 #7
We're staying in Delft, home of Vermeer and birthplace of my youngest son! Mr. Ected Mar 2017 #11
I must say I'm envious! I love to hear about other people's travels. smirkymonkey Mar 2017 #14
Not to rain on your parade, but the Dutch have much to answer for for their KingCharlemagne Mar 2017 #21
The Dutch East Indies dissolved in 1942 GulfCoast66 Mar 2017 #26
Yeah, I get your point (I think). Here's a thought experiment for you: how much KingCharlemagne Mar 2017 #30
I am from that other region you mention GulfCoast66 Mar 2017 #35
I'll leave you to your weekend with a quote from the great French writer Honore KingCharlemagne Mar 2017 #36
In my family's case... GulfCoast66 Mar 2017 #40
I know, me too, smirky. Cha Mar 2017 #13
As a US expat lies Mar 2017 #8
The US era of global leadership has certainly been hurt by GW and now Trump Martin Eden Mar 2017 #16
The thing is.... lies Mar 2017 #18
Without a doubt, Europe has lost confidence in the US as "leader" of the Free World Martin Eden Mar 2017 #42
Wellll lies Mar 2017 #44
I've been quite disappointed in the US in my later years. I had thought the US would be much RKP5637 Mar 2017 #29
Melting pot vs. homogeneous populations. moondust Mar 2017 #17
Well stated... As in I agree dembotoz Mar 2017 #34
Because they're not patriots and they have no moral conscience (nt) bekkilyn Mar 2017 #19
A) gerrymandering B) electoral college C) Citizens United spooky3 Mar 2017 #22
we can. barbtries Mar 2017 #23
IT'S THE MEDIA sharedvalues Mar 2017 #24
This - and all the internet social media permutations MrPurple Mar 2017 #55
I was just in Bolivia. a la izquierda Mar 2017 #25
Too many white Americans GulfCoast66 Mar 2017 #27
The Dutch avoided a far rightie recently but Id be interested to know if they think it will continue lunasun Mar 2017 #28
I think that once Trump, who is highly visible throughout the world, PatrickforO Mar 2017 #47
Generally...the European attitude is to lend a "helping hand". roamer65 Mar 2017 #31
Re that last question BSdetect Mar 2017 #39
Here's the response you get in America: CrispyQ Mar 2017 #41
They undermined it in the pledge of allegiance alwaysinflux Mar 2017 #43
as sad as this is to say, Europe is not safe from nut cases Hamlette Mar 2017 #45
Don't you perhaps mean The Netherlands just escaped? pangaia Mar 2017 #56
ah shit, what's the difference :) Hamlette Mar 2017 #61
All true.. pangaia Mar 2017 #62
...Why do the so-called patriots insist that America is an 'every man and woman for themselves' PatrickforO Mar 2017 #46
You should have asked the Dutch family how many political parties there are in Holland DFW Mar 2017 #48
You'll find this interesting: Fantastic Anarchist Mar 2017 #49
Thank you for the time and effort to post this. Mr. Ected Mar 2017 #64
Thank you. I'm glad to share. Fantastic Anarchist Mar 2017 #68
America's unique view of poverty as a moral failing goes back to the pilgrims. SunSeeker Mar 2017 #50
I have 2 cousins who live in Holland. They said they will never come back to America SummerSnow Mar 2017 #51
Why can't we look out for each other in the USA? Here's why: singed.dude Mar 2017 #52
Please tell them (next time) that more of us Ilsa Mar 2017 #54
I know what you mean. MrScorpio Mar 2017 #57
Love Holland and felt.. zentrum Mar 2017 #58
There's so much hatred that many actually *want* others to suffer and die. Kablooie Mar 2017 #59
yeah. i know danish people AND i have been there twice. they are HAPPY. pansypoo53219 Mar 2017 #60
Message auto-removed Name removed Mar 2017 #65
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»My family and I are in Ho...»Reply #49