General Discussion

A HERETIC I AM

(24,876 posts)

14. Take him a white flag and say....

Thu Mar 30, 2017, 07:01 PM

Mar 2017

"Here. The one you have up is better represented by this one."

Either that or school him on how incredibly wrong it is to fly the Battle Flag of the Army of Northern Virginia which in NO way whatsoever was adopted as an official flag of the confederacy.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

109 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

I live in rural upstate NY and my neighbor just hung a Confederate flag on their trailer front porch [View all] adigal Mar 2017 OP

Is this a new neighbor, or someone who has also been there for 14 years? RedWedge Mar 2017 #1

This neighbor has been here for as long as we have owned the house adigal Mar 2017 #33

So is this move a surprise? RedWedge Mar 2017 #44

I don't know them...it's a rural area, but this is a 2 lane state "highway," adigal Mar 2017 #46

Message auto-removed Name removed Mar 2017 #64

A number of years ago a similar situation across the street beachbum bob Mar 2017 #2

Put out your American flag. Maybe that will shame him. nt Ilsa Mar 2017 #3

Anyone flying the Confederate flag is beyond shame. guillaumeb Mar 2017 #4

Agree. McCamy Taylor Mar 2017 #27

LOL! Great idea...where do I get a Russian flag? Nt adigal Mar 2017 #34

Amazon Marthe48 Mar 2017 #48

I think you should hang a Russian flag and an American flag. See what happens. 😎 pangaia Mar 2017 #77

It should. My experience is that white wingers who fly that flag, have no shame. Hoyt Mar 2017 #29

True, but I think it is important to show him up to Ilsa Mar 2017 #59

What is their affinity towards Southern Paternalism and Sedition, or is this a Yankee Confed poser? TheBlackAdder Mar 2017 #5

I honestly don't know nt adigal Mar 2017 #35

sad Skittles Mar 2017 #6

Yes. narnian60 Mar 2017 #104

Put up a Union flag! shenmue Mar 2017 #7

Or a United Nations flag... n/t EarthFirst Mar 2017 #9

or a Pride flag crazycatlady Mar 2017 #47

Yes shenmue Mar 2017 #53

That would be the best response! LisaM Mar 2017 #101

Links to where you can buy Union battle flags LisaM Mar 2017 #102

I am living in the South and wondering what will happen when I put a OldHippieChick Mar 2017 #8

Cops will pull you over and find ways to issue you tickets, and bullies will follow you and tblue37 Mar 2017 #17

I guess I'm about to find out how brave I am. OldHippieChick Mar 2017 #20

Be careful, please. Don't take unnecessary chances alone nt adigal Mar 2017 #36

What nonsense. cwydro Mar 2017 #81

A Darwin fish can get your car keyed down here. beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #23

Nope. cwydro Mar 2017 #82

So your experience is the only valid one? beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #97

Nope. cwydro Mar 2017 #98

So you only read about it on DU? How odd. beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #100

You will probably get quite a few honks and gestures peacebuzzard Mar 2017 #67

I fucking hate Confederate flags. TransitJohn Mar 2017 #10

I hate seeming them brer cat Mar 2017 #13

I think I have seen one big one flying from a truck leftyladyfrommo Mar 2017 #18

Yep. I see that occasionally. brer cat Mar 2017 #24

These were kids. The flag was huge. leftyladyfrommo Mar 2017 #25

I find them useful as asshole indicators, especially outside the south Warpy Mar 2017 #28

I'm originally from Wyoming as well. No place is safe from OldHippieChick Mar 2017 #32

I agree, it's a way to be in the KKK mentality without the white hood nt adigal Mar 2017 #38

One local has a truck with two huge rebel flags that he drives around the city all weekend. beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #103

Neighbor here in red FL did that mcar Mar 2017 #11

I too live in rural upstate NY. NewRedDawn Mar 2017 #12

Damn. Great history there, New Red. Hats off. callous taoboy Mar 2017 #61

Jeff Davis was indicted for treason Yupster Mar 2017 #73

No trial. NewRedDawn Mar 2017 #85

He had a high powered team of northern lawyers defending him Yupster Mar 2017 #92

Take him a white flag and say.... A HERETIC I AM Mar 2017 #14

Love it!!!!! Better than my KKK sign idea! Nt adigal Mar 2017 #39

Look up some Civil War memorabilia sites, see if there are affordable... JHB Mar 2017 #15

I refer to it as the Dixie Swastika. beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #16

Easy rebuttal to that. TrollBuster9090 Mar 2017 #19

Oh, and before we go all apeshit on the South...REMEMBER BUFORD. TrollBuster9090 Mar 2017 #21

General Pemberton, the general who surrendered Vicksburg to Grant Yupster Mar 2017 #74

Thank you. nt raccoon Mar 2017 #83

Wasn't kentucky NewRedDawn Mar 2017 #90

Kentucky had representation in both Yupster Mar 2017 #93

If not one of the three below, it's not a CSA Flag. The jerk's probably flying the Army of Tennessee TheBlackAdder Mar 2017 #22

Today, all those flags are a symbol of hatred. Hoyt Mar 2017 #30

Yep. That and sedition. I just like to point out that those who fly it often don't know the nuances. TheBlackAdder Mar 2017 #31

Racism is now the official position of our government. Eliot Rosewater Mar 2017 #26

Don't go looking for trouble vlyons Mar 2017 #37

I NEVER said I would go into their yard adigal Mar 2017 #40

The Confederate Constitution didn't allow the President Yupster Mar 2017 #75

They cant even pull the bullshit excuse drray23 Mar 2017 #41

This is why Russia targeted white America with their underthematrix Mar 2017 #42

Russia knew tRump supporters were bdamomma Mar 2017 #66

Not sure about where you live mrs_p Mar 2017 #43

Can you imagine?? These people may have ancestors who were adigal Mar 2017 #45

We live just outside of a suburb of Rochester, a mostly rural/agriculture village community... EarthFirst Mar 2017 #49

Somebody should let him know he shouldn't display the U.S. flag touching the ground.n/t indie9197 Mar 2017 #62

I live in the south and they say terrible things about New Yorkers down here. yardwork Mar 2017 #50

but isn't rural upstate NY the "real" New York pstokely Mar 2017 #71

what part of the South? pstokely Mar 2017 #72

So is upstate SC. nt raccoon Mar 2017 #84

3 words: William Tecumseh Sherman. muntrv Mar 2017 #51

I know MFM008 Mar 2017 #80

WTS' record after the Civil War is far more checkered. Ask any Native KingCharlemagne Mar 2017 #94

I've made the very same point in the past, only to be completely ignored. Seems this is a blind... Marengo Mar 2017 #106

I used to be an unabashed admirer. One of my Commie friends educated me. - nt KingCharlemagne Mar 2017 #108

3 words: Native American genocide. VOX Mar 2017 #109

They are everywhere here in Southwest PA. Freedomofspeech Mar 2017 #52

One good thing is now people know what lives there luvMIdog Mar 2017 #54

I'm from Upstate NY - I have lived in large cities since I have graduated from college but smirkymonkey Mar 2017 #55

I live in a small town NewRedDawn Mar 2017 #63

I grew up about 30 miles north of Utica! smirkymonkey Mar 2017 #65

Salisbury NewRedDawn Mar 2017 #89

I'm from north of Glens Falls, NY nt adigal Mar 2017 #68

That's a beautiful area! smirkymonkey Mar 2017 #70

You are lucky!!! Not many liberals here, except transplants. nt adigal Mar 2017 #95

This flag is displayed for one reason and one reason only mountain grammy Mar 2017 #56

You could put up a sign in your yard about unity Equinox Moon Mar 2017 #57

I, too, live in H2O Man Mar 2017 #58

They are just trying to hold on to the wet dream as they see 45 and his Russian band nearing the end nikibatts Mar 2017 #60

Put up a sign that says "one of my neighbors is a racist" Renew Deal Mar 2017 #69

Why would you want to start a fight with your neighbor Yupster Mar 2017 #76

I live in a town of about 15 000... pangaia Mar 2017 #78

Growing up in the south and currently living here...here's my perspective, FWIW. Docreed2003 Mar 2017 #79

Well said. It isn't 'southern bashing' to state the obvious. beam me up scottie Mar 2017 #105

Anyone so shameless would have no problem terrorizing you HAB911 Mar 2017 #86

I saw them just outside of Gettysburg last summer. OnionPatch Mar 2017 #87

I go to Gettysburg yearly NewRedDawn Mar 2017 #91

Blue state repugs often forget which side their state was on Mc Mike Mar 2017 #88

A lot of this flag flying is a way of saying MicaelS Mar 2017 #96

Been in the souyh all my life, nowadays only racists fly that flag. The yellow Gadsden Hoyt Mar 2017 #107

I live in a very blue area, but yesterday I pulled into a parking lot and saw a pickup Vinca Mar 2017 #99