General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Why do people drive SUVs? [View all]krispos42
(49,445 posts)In order to get twice the mileage, you have to pick a compact car with very little room for more than 4 people and limited cargo capacity. You loose 4-wheel or all-wheel drive, the ability to haul large and bulky items like furniture or home-improvement supplies, the ability to haul up to 8 people (5 of them comfortably), options like rear-seat entertainment systems, and the ability to tow a trailer of any note.
At the dawn of the SUV craze, a minivan got about 18mpg, a sedan got about 22 mpg, and an SUV got about 16. Gas was $1.25 a gallon, so many people figured the extra $500 a year in gas was worth it for the extra convenience and capabilities.
My Dad has a 2006 Pathfinder. He's retired, so he drives about 30 miles a week. If he switched over to a sedan, he's save maybe a gallon of gas a week while losing tons of versatility. To him, it's worth paying a few extra dollar a week in gas to be able to haul building supplies to the house and home and yard waste to the dump, plus he can haul 7 people if needed.
It's not my choice; I would rather drive a compact wagon than either a sedan or an SUV. I had a Subaru Impreza sportwagon that worked quite nice... it got 28mph highway when cruising at 80mph.