Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: It would be nice if the far left, for once, did some introspection. [View all]DanTex
(20,709 posts)381. Yes. The far left in this country is quite stupid.
And a good example of this is their continued denial of responsibility for 2000. The math clearly and uncontrovertibly shows that Nader cost Gore Florida: if even 1% of the Nader votes had gone to Gore, there's no recount and no SCOTUS. If Nader isn't on the ballot (not to mention if he doesn't go around telling his naive/ignorant followers that there's no difference between Bush and Gore), Gore wins comfortably.
In any event, collapsing the left into the Greens, Nader and Stein is a cheap shot.
No it's not. The Green Party is the political vehicle of the far left. It is through the Green Party that the far left actually accomplishes anything at all. What they accomplish is throwing elections to Republicans. And, by their own words, they do this on purpose. Nader and Stein both made it clear that they preferred the GOP candidate to the Dem.
No doubt Hedges is a purist, but Hedges is not hurting anything.
Yes, he and the rest of the far-left authors like him are definitely hurting the country. Because he has an audience. And he tells that audience that they should not vote for the Democratic Party. He couldn't be a more useful ally of the right-wing in this country if he tried: pretend to care about progressive causes, and then go around depressing Democratic turnout.
I saw one interview with him that was just mind-boggling. He pointed out (correctly) that the clock is running out on climate change, the earth is at risk. And then, when asked about the single most important thing in the entire world that could affect that trajectory -- whether Clinton or Trump become president -- he said he would vote Green. Truly idiotic. If Chris Hedges is part of our "spine", then we're pretty well screwed.
Every damn thing you say the left did not accomplish, was accomplished by the Congressional Democrats because of pressure from us.
That's a joke. One of the delusions that far leftists tell themselves. They act like they are the only people with progressive views, and mainstream Dems are inherently evil and untrustworthy and only do progressive things because of "pressure" from Susan Sarandon types. Wrong. Obama enacted progressive policies them because of his own progressive beliefs. Same goes for Hillary and congressional Dems. Sorry, the far left doesn't get to, on one hand, continually help Republicans get elected, and on the other hand, claim credit for the accomplishments of the Democratic Party that they despise.
Not sure what youre recommending-that the Democratic Party keep doing what it did in 2016 and see how that pans out?
No, I'm recommending they do what they did in 2008. Find a charismatic candidate and run on a platform that can win nationally. I find it fairly ironic that the far left keeps trying to use Trump's victory as a sign that the party needs to dive to the left, because the 2016 platform and campaign were the most progressive that the Dems have ever run. More so than 2008 and certainly more so than 1992. If anything, the lesson from 2016 versus those victory years is: don't bother trying to placate the far left, it won't get us votes.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
427 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Yes, no one likes people who lecture, constantly complain, and are constantly dissatisfied.
Warren DeMontague
Apr 2017
#1
It's an issue. People have been trying to blow it off or treat it like a joke for too fucking long.
Warren DeMontague
Apr 2017
#35
Why are you wasting time obsessing over what the people at counterpunch think?
Warren DeMontague
Apr 2017
#178
Probably the same reason you obsess over weed laws that you can't do anything to change.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#180
I have. The East Coast is not for me, although I know plenty of people who thrive on it.
Warren DeMontague
Apr 2017
#296
That's because there isn't a real war on those issues. but there is on abortion rights
JI7
Apr 2017
#23
You need to be more specific with these elaborate straw creatures you are constructing
Warren DeMontague
Apr 2017
#27
"big weed" is a bs term kevin sabet came up with to rebrand failed prohibition arguments.
Warren DeMontague
Apr 2017
#322
Sure, as long as you are not including folks like Keith Ellison in your description of the Far Left
Tom Rinaldo
Apr 2017
#6
during obama's yrs the party did little locally, regionally, or state legislatures and got clobbered
msongs
Apr 2017
#7
I think if people agree with the GOP platform at all, there's a problem.
Warren DeMontague
Apr 2017
#42
I, too, am strongly of the opinion that Bernie Sanders caused HRC to be a better candidate.
Warren DeMontague
Apr 2017
#368
Of course she had flaws. But she was more progressive than Obama, Kerry, Gore, or Bill.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#92
Hillary was not more progressive than Obama, her immediate predecessor as nominee
karynnj
Apr 2017
#261
Everything Nance wrote is factually correct. There are no alternative facts there. nt
stevenleser
Apr 2017
#109
these types have always been out there. it's more like a cool kids club than actual political
JI7
Apr 2017
#318
And meanwhile, the clueless far left will still accomplish nothing. Seriously, wake up.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#61
As long as you don't name one accomplishment of the far left, you prove my point.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#66
MA is a progressive state which was the first to legalize gay marriage. We voted for Hillary. n/t
seaglass
Apr 2017
#147
And it is easy to dupe them with fake news as the past election shows. All you have to do is
nikibatts
Apr 2017
#51
Losing centrists? You mean like the ones who turned around the massive losses
stevenleser
Apr 2017
#112
You could defeat the "wall of straw" by naming one thing the far left has accomplished.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#65
I vaguely remember last spring and summer how we were told here at DU and other
rpannier
Apr 2017
#67
No, but given the amout of energy some people put into the drama here
Warren DeMontague
Apr 2017
#69
I was talking the last three or four decades. My lifetime. And the answer is nothing.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#79
Nope. The middle of the road hindered those efforts. Pressure from the left brought it home.
Gore1FL
Apr 2017
#94
I think you've created a "far left" straw creature for your own purposes, here.
Warren DeMontague
Apr 2017
#160
I never said anything about filibuster-proof. Filibuster-proof has NOTHING to do with my point.
Gore1FL
Apr 2017
#375
Show me hard facts, not just simplistic math, but actual proof that Nader voters
Exilednight
Apr 2017
#239
Math isn't "simplistic" just because you don't like what it implies. It's math.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#240
No, it's not a mathematical proof. Such things don't exist outside of mathematics.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#249
The political spectrum has existed for a long time. The far left is not a new phenomena.
Gore1FL
Apr 2017
#225
Nothing remotely "left" at all about people who would vote or not vote
Eliot Rosewater
Apr 2017
#228
LOL yeah... American abolitionists and American Revolutionaries are middle of the road types...
Gore1FL
Apr 2017
#254
Ah yes, history will always remember Franklin, Jefferson, and Madison as "middle of the road."
Gore1FL
Apr 2017
#334
I am saying they were far left for their era, which is how one should gauge it.
Gore1FL
Apr 2017
#365
LOL! We aren't talking about seating arrangements in the French National assembly in 1789.
Gore1FL
Apr 2017
#384
I am taking this in the context of what is being discussed in this thread. I ask a third time:
Gore1FL
Apr 2017
#386
You aren't making arguments, you are avoiding answering two pretty simple questions.
Gore1FL
Apr 2017
#391
Europe wasn't in the United States in the 1850s. It still isn't. I never mentioned Lincoln.
Gore1FL
Apr 2017
#393
There are many people here more interested in pointing fingers than fixing problems.
Gore1FL
Apr 2017
#80
Bullshit. Some of us know the 3rd party progressive nonsense is going to REPEAT
Eliot Rosewater
Apr 2017
#348
Good for Ralph on the seatbelts. But the damage he did in 2000 was hundreds of times worse.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#115
Oh come on! You can hit that horse harder than that. Put a little shoulder into it.
ornotna
Apr 2017
#104
The far left more consistently votes for the Democrats, so I don't get it.
Buckeye_Democrat
Apr 2017
#113
Bullshit! I sure don't talk to many people were delighted at the loss of the 2016 election.
Akamai
Apr 2017
#119
Stein and Sarandon are two sad people who are proud of their efforts to elect trump
Gothmog
Apr 2017
#401
The far left in the country doesn't have the same money at its disposal. The far left, those of it
JCanete
Apr 2017
#149
If we were smart we would lean left rather than right. Trying to be GOP lite is why we lose.
Vinca
Apr 2017
#150
The people to blame for the "both parties are the same" narrative are the idiots pushing it.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#186
There's no denying that they threw the 2000 election to W. That's an obvious fact.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#230
I view them as more of a symptom that a lot of people are dissatisfied with Dems
bekkilyn
Apr 2017
#234
Well I think they should be. Because I think that they could be a force for good instead of a force
DanTex
Apr 2017
#248
As if Trump is not enough of a reason? An outright racist? Really? And W before him?
DanTex
Apr 2017
#269
I see no point in a op like this one. Why rehash the past? Time to move forward.
Demsrule86
Apr 2017
#183
Couldn't disagree more. The Democrats have ONLY been successful when embracing liberalism.
Zen Democrat
Apr 2017
#184
Bill Clinton was popular, a great public speaker, and yet what did he accomplish for Dems?
Zen Democrat
May 2017
#427
I agree this has been a problem since McGovern....so I'm going back to the 70s.
Sancho
Apr 2017
#188
if you mean fall in line behind whatever gop lite the party is offering? nope
dembotoz
Apr 2017
#201
The point is that before telling the Dems what to do, the left should look in the mirror.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#209
Well, the Dems held the White House for eight years and enacted many historic reforms.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#356
Maybe instead of saying "far left" the OP should have just specified "Green" or "Nader/Stein"
bekkilyn
Apr 2017
#218
They keep doing it because it is easier to point fingers than to solve the underlying problems. nt
Gore1FL
Apr 2017
#227
It's not fair to imply that people on the left are gleeful that Trump is in.
Ken Burch
Apr 2017
#241
And we don't have many "far left" types on THIS board, so why are you calling them out here?
Ken Burch
Apr 2017
#245
We don't have many Republicans on this board, but people call out the GOP here all the time.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#256
Actually, no, it wasn't. Obama had more charisma, but in terms of issues, 2016 was more progressive
DanTex
Apr 2017
#260
Of course the "far left" ignored it. The Greens had their own platform to run on. (nt)
PotatoChip
Apr 2017
#265
Yeah, I agree, she could have done many things better, including more resources in those states.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#272
Chris Hedges is a perfect example of the stupidity and impotence of the far left.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#335
Yes. That's what makes it so egregious that the far left helped bring this about.
DanTex
Apr 2017
#410
I don't think you've provided any evidence of that, outside of pointing to a handful of individuals
bigtree
Apr 2017
#413
then address those individuals and their individual agendas, statements, actions
bigtree
Apr 2017
#415
Jettison them, move a little to the right and pick up the win in the center.
Foamfollower
Apr 2017
#423