Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BainsBane

(57,751 posts)
17. The war was about slavery
Mon May 1, 2017, 11:41 PM
May 2017

that is not the same as Lincoln's goal upon entering the war. Historical causes are rarely the same as specific war aims. While there is debate among historians about the cause of the war, the argument that is was caused by slavery is widespread, if not dominant.

If you see the Civil War documentary by Ken Burns, Historian Barbara Fields notes that the war was caused by the inauguration of the republic with slavery existing within its borders. Most cite its impetus later with, for example, the acquisition of territories from the Mexican War or Bleeding Kansas.

To understand what caused the War, one has to think about what led the South to secede. For them, it was the election of Abraham Lincoln, a proponent of Free Soil--stopping the spread of slavery into the new territories. Slaveholders saw that as indistinguishable from abolitionism. They believed that without territories to export their slaves to, they would face widespread insurrection like that which struck Haiti in 1791. They saw Lincoln as an existential threat to their way of life, which hinged on slavery.

Slavery was indeed the cause of the war.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Haw, haw, haw, Colin gratuitous May 2017 #1
Post removed Post removed May 2017 #2
In the beginning it could have preserved slavery, but in the end angstlessk May 2017 #3
It was about slavery! L. Coyote May 2017 #4
Not according to the CIC. former9thward May 2017 #5
Lincoln, you will note, is not the topic. Confederate forces fired on Ft. Sumter, starting the Civil WinkyDink May 2017 #9
According to the Confederate states, slavery was definitely their reason for leaving Union wishstar May 2017 #33
Yet according to each rebelling state's Articles of Secession, it in fact, was. LanternWaste May 2017 #49
It WAS about slavery -- that's why the South fought for leaving the union, regardless of what pnwmom May 2017 #6
Lincoln Said It Wasn't About Slavery Leith May 2017 #7
Both paragraphs were 100% about slavery. yodermon May 2017 #8
It is true that Lincoln called up volunteers to try to preserve the Union. Staph May 2017 #10
... One-eighth of the whole population were colored slaves, not distributed generally over the Union struggle4progress May 2017 #13
As a southerner hurple May 2017 #16
The war was about slavery BainsBane May 2017 #17
RWTP.... FULL STOP uponit7771 May 2017 #19
Hanging on to their slaves was the paramount intent of every rebel oasis May 2017 #20
"No course in U.S. History necessary." former9thward May 2017 #25
Only confederate sympathizes claim that slavery was not the geek tragedy May 2017 #38
Compare his earlier statements with his later statements Nevernose May 2017 #21
It seems you think that if there were no slavery there still would have been the war. :eyes: Bernardo de La Paz May 2017 #22
If the Southern states had agreed to stay there would have been no Civil War. former9thward May 2017 #26
You want to sweep slavery under the rug. Only you don't see they left BECAUSE of the slavery issue. Bernardo de La Paz May 2017 #29
It was central and important to the Southern states. former9thward May 2017 #31
Of course it was! Thank you. It split the nation! Duh! . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz May 2017 #32
Lincoln is NOT saying the war was NOT about slavery. You misinterpret. Bernardo de La Paz May 2017 #24
When the war started did Lincoln say it was about slavery? former9thward May 2017 #27
The distal cause (slavery) was the root cause. The proximal cause (secession) doesn't erase the dist Bernardo de La Paz May 2017 #30
The slave states started the civil war. Because of slavery. geek tragedy May 2017 #37
Hahahahahahaha! Not about slavery? Good one. brush May 2017 #34
The south seceded because of slavery. Period. geek tragedy May 2017 #35
So why did he free the slaves during the war? Kingofalldems May 2017 #40
Lincoln worked a bit of genius with his Emancipation Proclamation... VOX May 2017 #48
i wish the admin would do something about long time trolls JI7 May 2017 #11
Ditto. N/t spooky3 May 2017 #23
Who are you calling a troll? former9thward May 2017 #28
People who deny slavery was the root cause of the civil war geek tragedy May 2017 #36
DU has fucking jumped the shark BumRushDaShow May 2017 #41
Some patterns of behaviors with certain geek tragedy May 2017 #44
Yup. nt BumRushDaShow May 2017 #47
Thank you. Kingofalldems May 2017 #42
Without secession Lincoln would have exboyfil May 2017 #12
Thanks, exboyfil! pnwmom May 2017 #18
Zinged Colin right up to his colon. oasis May 2017 #14
Colin Carr.. typical rw no nothing asshole.. Cha May 2017 #15
Chelsea's got promise, can think on her feet, doesn't toady and thus, so diff from her friend Ivanka brush May 2017 #39
Yes! I was thinking about Chelsea earlier.. Cha May 2017 #43
Probably so. I wonder sometimes if Ivanka is embarrassed for her old man? brush May 2017 #45
If she is she hides it in her sociopathic support for his Cha May 2017 #46
BREAKING: Trump thinks Google is a form of pussy-grabbing Martin Eden May 2017 #50
Yeah for Chelsea Clinton Gothmog May 2017 #51
Am going to say this a little differently Lithos May 2017 #52
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Chelsea Clinton answers D...»Reply #17