Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

sheshe2

(95,551 posts)
Sun May 14, 2017, 02:52 PM May 2017

Trump Has Just Solved a Conundrum Historians have Struggled with for a Century [View all]

As a historian, it is difficult if not impossible to teach American history, without at least one student each semester asking in wide-eyed incredulity, the same damning question. "How could slavery have existed and flourished in the Antebellum South, given that it was so inimical to the democratic values upon which American society was built?"

snip//

But please don't get me wrong. I'm not suggesting that Trump's bungling, his treasonous ties to Russia or brutal immigration policy might in any way add up to the unspeakable evils of slavery. But what I am suggesting is this. The people who make the biggest moral claims are invariably the ones who accept the most jaw-dropping moral compromises. It was the well-mannered, genteel Southern aristocracy, who examined naked slaves on the auction block like beef heifers, sold slave children from their mothers when money was tight, or worked the field hands until they dropped dead in the cotton fields. Their Confederate Christianity accepted the status quo, as did their confederate moral sense of right and wrong. Their confederate schools taught them to disparage reason in favor of pseudo-scientific theories about racial hierarchies, where the universe placed them at the top and their slaves at the bottom. These people lived in a confederate world so jerry-built on fakery and filled with lies that they truly believed the slaves loved their station in life, and would take the Confederate's side when the Civil War erupted.

Trump's presidency is an abomination of a different sort. But like the confederacy of old, it too is built on fakery and flim-flam. The man is a corrupt businessman, who has bankrupted every business he started. It appears that he became entangled in money laundering for the Russian mob when American banks would no longer lend to him. International intelligence reports claim that he has been compromised by Russian President Vladimir Putin. And yet the Republicans in Congress as well as his supporters have refused ever since Trump entered the presidential campaign to demand that he release his income tax returns. The daughter and son-in-law are selling their wares from the White House porch. This is the behavior of a crime family. The "First Lady" refuses to move in, knowing that her husband, who is on tape as a "pussy grabber" will probably be serving penitentiary time before she even has a chance to hang the gold-threaded curtains in the bathroom. Speaker of the House Paul Ryan and Senate Speaker Mitch McConnell know that Trump is a pathological liar as do the other members of the GOP. They realize that he is precipitating a constitutional crisis by attempting to obstruct the FBI's investigation of Trump's collusion with the Kremlin. But they tiptoe around everything, the dishonesty, disrespecting the rule of law, compromising the government of the United States for the sake of the Russians.

My point here, is that Trump's supporters, the Republican controlled Senate and House of Representatives didn't just pop out of nowhere. They've merely been in the background, waiting for an opportunity to be heard. This is neo-confederate America. Anti-immigrant nativism, plays a role and police state racism. But the larger picture is one of authoritarianism, a yearning for fascism, a strong man dictatorship. That is the true legacy. It is a fake worldview, whose means of validating what is true are whatever lies are most comforting. Politically it could hardly be compared with slavery. But in all the ways that human beings are able to distinguish what is decent and good from what is dishonest and corrupt it is the same epistemological system, that is “way of knowing” that the Confederacy used to justify slavery. America’s mistake in fighting so valiantly to end slavery was in refusing to take the next step after winning the Civil War. That would have been dismantling the Confederacy’s deeply-ingrained but fake truth system.

Read More:http://www.dailykos.com/stories/2017/5/14/1662171/-Trump-Has-Just-Solved-a-Conundrum-Historians-have-Struggled-with-for-a-Century

30 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Excellent read malaise May 2017 #1
It's a very good essay. Lies not stomped will fester. . . nt Bernardo de La Paz May 2017 #2
It's a fundamental mistake to assume that American society was built on "democratic values" Spider Jerusalem May 2017 #3
The Founding Fathers feared democracy because they feared that "the mob" would take their PROPERTY. YoungDemCA May 2017 #4
That was one of the motivations for the Revolution, in fact Spider Jerusalem May 2017 #6
I remember the reaction of the kids at Colonial Williamsburg, as more and more people karynnj May 2017 #24
. . . and what about: marybourg May 2017 #5
Easy. When the wealthy siphon off more and more to fulfill their lust to own as much cstanleytech May 2017 #28
Trump is cautionary tale of all great falls into the dark. gordianot May 2017 #7
Their revisionist history is still strong in the South regarding slavery and the Civil War. GBizzle May 2017 #8
Welcome to DU. n/t rzemanfl May 2017 #9
Plain and simple...they were traitors, and what we're dealing with now are traitors. brush May 2017 #11
Welcome to DU. Aristus May 2017 #14
Welcome and thanks blueseas May 2017 #20
Maybe I had a sheltered unbringing.. Mercurian May 2017 #22
Cognitive Dissonance Juliusseizure May 2017 #27
Many of these poor white ancestors fought Duppers May 2017 #30
Human nature doesn't seem to change. dawg May 2017 #10
Samuel Johnson asked much the same question thucythucy May 2017 #12
I finished a paper on Antebellum Southern Paternalism last year. I won't paste it--identity reasons. TheBlackAdder May 2017 #13
Thank you for sharing...a good read. sheshe2 May 2017 #15
Would LOVE to read more of this, I had a sKrong notion that the church had a hand in beliefs that uponit7771 May 2017 #29
a very good read . Thank you luvMIdog May 2017 #16
Yup, the traitorous Confederates are still with us. SunSeeker May 2017 #17
They never stop, do they? sheshe2 May 2017 #18
I don't think so either. SunSeeker May 2017 #19
You are right, they don't want in. sheshe2 May 2017 #21
Atrocities are easier to commit if you demonize people first IronLionZion May 2017 #23
Fakery and flim-flam at every level. Orsino May 2017 #25
Great article. louis-t May 2017 #26
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Trump Has Just Solved a C...