Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

karynnj

(60,897 posts)
29. Never before had a candidate had the State Department IG and the Intelligence Community IG
Mon Jul 10, 2017, 03:27 PM
Jul 2017

appointed by an administration of the nominee's own party recommended and investigation and investigated themselves. Hillary's numbers on honest and trustworthy sank as she dealt poorly with the issue of her emails before the FBI started to investigate. Much of the damage was done by June 2015. (In March 2015, we learned that she used a private server and left the State Department without the emails they needed to produce for Congress and FOIA. The State Department "negotiated" with HRC to get them returned in late 2014.)

Bill Clinton, privately meeting with the AG as that investigation was nearing its end made things worse - as it compromised Lynch. It directly led to Lynch saying she would accept the FBI's recommendation - leading to Comey announcing the findings rather than simply reporting them to the AG to announce. That led to Comey being called before Congress and promising to report if anything changed.

I think Comey erred in sending that letter to Congress, where it was promptly and predictably leaked. At minimum, he should have prioritized getting computer experts to quickly extract any new emails and (given how few there ended up being) checking them out. All without a word to Congress. Had there been any bombshell, he would still have been able to get it out before the election - eliminating any reason to favor the path he took.

Clinton knew that there was nothing wrong in the emails. There were requests for them in her last year as Secretary of State. All she had to do was to leave the work email with the State Department when she left. As it was, the House and Senate BOTH asked about the email requests every time Kerry or an under secretary came to Congress. This was an untenable situation - and it blew up in her face. The most galling thing was that there was not anything she had to cover up! Both Congressional oversight and FOIA - even by people we do not like - are important to an open, transparent government.

It is absolutely terrible that a well qualified, intelligent public servant lost this election because of the series of her email decisions that led to this. That it allowed an unqualified sociopath to win makes this even worse. While it is fair to blame Comey's letter, none of this would have happened had Hillary Clinton not made a terrible choice on her emails. Also blame Bill Clinton's inexplicable action or even the leaders of the Democratic party for not quickly understanding how badly this was hurting her.



Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I think Hillary and President Obama are both playing it smart by remaining mostly silent. Vinca Jul 2017 #1
Yup zipplewrath Jul 2017 #6
Agreed ! Jimbo101 Jul 2017 #19
Almost everyone, including too many Democrats, would tell her to shut up and go away-- tblue37 Jul 2017 #2
Horrifyingly, yes. Squinch Jul 2017 #7
Yep NastyRiffraff Jul 2017 #13
Yep Me. Jul 2017 #27
She would look like a whining sore loser, MichMary Jul 2017 #3
This WillowTree Jul 2017 #34
Unfortunately, it would only strengthen the resolve of those on the right. LonePirate Jul 2017 #4
I too wish she would but it would just be called sour grapes... I do wish.. samnsara Jul 2017 #5
Nothing of any value would happen. MineralMan Jul 2017 #8
I admit I concur with all of your opinions, it's just sad. If this had happened to repub candidate, monmouth4 Jul 2017 #9
True, but rest assured that it would not happen to a Republican candidate. Caliman73 Jul 2017 #17
She would be marginalized and lose credibility Lee-Lee Jul 2017 #10
The cheat is inherent in our antiquated Constitutional Electoral College System. yallerdawg Jul 2017 #11
She would be shredded..... dawnie51 Jul 2017 #12
People would tell to go take care of her grand babies ismnotwasm Jul 2017 #14
Public Opinion would turn on her quickly Caliman73 Jul 2017 #15
Trump would try to jail her Johnny2X2X Jul 2017 #16
She would come off as an undignified sore loser loyalsister Jul 2017 #18
of course not . . . DrDan Jul 2017 #20
"Laugh and the world marybourg Jul 2017 #21
It is not fair to say that Hillary's silence is not helpful karynnj Jul 2017 #22
Never before has the FBI intervened like this to destroy a candidate. StevieM Jul 2017 #28
Never before had a candidate had the State Department IG and the Intelligence Community IG karynnj Jul 2017 #29
They didn't say that they had evidence that HRC may have committed crimes. StevieM Jul 2017 #30
They included the top law enforcement people in the US Government karynnj Jul 2017 #32
The right would jump for joy Generic Other Jul 2017 #23
The focus would shift 100% to Clinton if she did that Orrex Jul 2017 #24
There *IS* something in the Constitution to address this...WE THE PEOPLE. LaydeeBug Jul 2017 #25
I agree DUgosh Jul 2017 #33
The right would band tighter together. We need to let the current bunch to hang themselves. nolabear Jul 2017 #26
We are moving closer to primary season with a very unpopular President. NCTraveler Jul 2017 #31
I'd make a killing off of kindling wood... SaschaHM Jul 2017 #35
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»What would happen if Hill...»Reply #29