Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Wonderful overlooked fact about Obamacare--it will curtail mandatory alternative medicine coverage! [View all]BlueToTheBone
(3,747 posts)71. Are you a surgical instrument salesman?
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
312 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Wonderful overlooked fact about Obamacare--it will curtail mandatory alternative medicine coverage! [View all]
Godhumor
Jul 2012
OP
Source for your argument: " acupuncture fails the scietific process 100% of the time."
emsimon33
Jul 2012
#264
chiropractic fixed my sciatica problem, when the ER didn't even get a fucking xray.
pansypoo53219
Jul 2012
#63
It depends on cause and how bad it is. My partner had a big curve and chiro & massage helped a lot.
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#127
Good, show me my ignorance. Where is the scientific work showing acupuncture works
Godhumor
Jul 2012
#34
Proof has been posted #90 I was giving you a chance to catch up with the front of the class.
underseasurveyor
Jul 2012
#113
He already replied there but didn't address the proof. Did a red herring thing instead. You are so
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#117
Willful ignorance and prejudice combine into an ugly mess. I like reading and learning also.
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#128
clinical studies have shown time and time again, where the needle goes makes no difference
Godhumor
Jul 2012
#172
Medically necessary? vs PATIENT necessary. It may be "medically" necessary to haul an 88
patrice
Jul 2012
#55
Have seen several family elders off into the beyond. Even under what is supposed to be the best
patrice
Jul 2012
#64
And the conclusions are clear on drugs like Zoloft, Prozac, Xanax, etc.?
underseasurveyor
Jul 2012
#108
Um, I thought anecdotal stories were worthless. I'm very close to someone who has benefited
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#112
silly you -- anecdotal evidence is only permissible when advocating big pharma.
nashville_brook
Jul 2012
#207
Oh silly me indeed. I forgot. Slap me with a wet noodle and call me done.
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#208
And let me just say right now, misuse of prescription drugs is a terrible thing
Godhumor
Jul 2012
#160
And misuse of prescription drugs is off the charts at an all time high (no pun intended)
underseasurveyor
Jul 2012
#170
Yes, the conclusions are clear. Only the severely depressed do better on them than placebo
stevenleser
Jul 2012
#169
That is because improperly prescribed, SSRI's/SNRI's can push a person into hypomania.
stevenleser
Jul 2012
#176
Perfect example. Germ theory was outrageous quackery and no reputable scientist
Egalitarian Thug
Jul 2012
#295
You mean all those double blind tests we've been finding out are rigged to give new meds
Lionessa
Jul 2012
#138
Yes, but we also need more naturalistic research, to try to understand qualitatively significant fac
patrice
Jul 2012
#149
Absolutely. There's no way to share it if it isn't. There must be some kind of connecting commonalit
patrice
Jul 2012
#152
What's a shame is that you haven't bothered to find out about the research that IS being done.
pnwmom
Jul 2012
#231
And do you know what they call alternative medicine that's been proven to work,
Egalitarian Thug
Jul 2012
#106
No, I haven't. Since massage therapy now has studies proving effectiveness for some
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#145
I can't even get an apology posted right today. ^ look up there ^. n/t
Egalitarian Thug
Jul 2012
#187
I've been offline a while. We are agreeing and no problems, was being too curt nt
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#193
No, subsidized CAM is being reduced or wiped out, which is a boost to all of us
Godhumor
Jul 2012
#4
I love quackwatch but have found untrue non-sources "facts" there which lead me to
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#288
Your ignorance is showing. Medical doctors in Washington often recommend naturopaths.
pnwmom
Jul 2012
#23
Which is the C in CAM, and is not even remotely medically necessary or even useful
Godhumor
Jul 2012
#27
And, I'm glad the country will be trusting scietific rigor instead of pseudoscience
Godhumor
Jul 2012
#43
They can. Bastyr University has been actively engaged in research for years, in partnership
pnwmom
Jul 2012
#51
Right, you speak for the entire medical world -- except for the N.I.H., the University of Washington
pnwmom
Jul 2012
#70
"Some benefit was shown." In the world of cancer studies, that kind of result is considered
pnwmom
Jul 2012
#300
Are M.D. allergists also "woo woo"? Those allergy shots with the tiny amounts of allergens
pnwmom
Jul 2012
#303
Folic acid during pregnancy has greatly reduced spina bifida, but it wasn't conventional
pnwmom
Jul 2012
#46
No, you are. The people I've been arguing with are those who lump naturopathy and acupuncture
pnwmom
Jul 2012
#65
I'm supporting the work of Bastyr Naturopathic University and its trained practitioners,
pnwmom
Jul 2012
#253
I never said it was "unaware of folic acid." They didn't recommend the standard use of
pnwmom
Jul 2012
#255
Some do, true. But many do not. Like MD's that over prescribe. There are some unscrupulous doctors
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#285
Check the context, please. The person I was responding to had just used the term "woo-woos."
pnwmom
Jul 2012
#227
Empiricism, the scientific method: These are my gods. Their magic is STRONG. nt
Poll_Blind
Jul 2012
#7
I'm sure there are studies about the efficacy of Chinese herbal medicines in Japan
Art_from_Ark
Jul 2012
#262
Actually, flossing is better at preventing periodontitis. Besides which, he said "treat".
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#286
And eating right and using good toothpaste, and good genes, and lots of other things too.
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#310
I am glad massage therapists are doing scientific studies so massage therapy may be continued.
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#33
But it would move from CAM to accepted medicinal practice when proven effective
Godhumor
Jul 2012
#37
I'd like to see a link to a reputable source with that definition vs your definition. Thank you.
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#57
Thanks for the link but it says nothing about CAM being "crap" or unprovable or validating your defn
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#80
You generalize too much. My massages are not "relaxing and feel great". Yes, I'm a Western med & CAM
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#94
Another fail. Here is what AMTA does say, and links to research now, 2012, not 1997 "AMTA booklet".
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#103
"Realxing, relief of aches, and feel good" sounds like a lot of prescriptions you seem ok with
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#110
I have not talked about any prescribed drugs other that normal umbrella prescription coverage
Godhumor
Jul 2012
#121
why are prescriptions that are "Realxing, relief of aches, and feel good" ok with you?
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#125
Your proof maintains massage as therapy for HIV/AIDS victims, autism spectrum, etc.
Godhumor
Jul 2012
#148
NOTHING was said about "permanently healing scar tissue" in ETL's comment.
underseasurveyor
Jul 2012
#178
IF you had any understanding of the subject you'd know better than to ask that.
underseasurveyor
Jul 2012
#184
You deny something works, then shown proof you still disagree and want to leave. Hahaha
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#215
Range of motion improves after massage in children with burns: A pilot study
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#203
You answered my last question. "Can you do any of that or will you now try and deflect...?" Deflect.
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#200
Deflect again. AMA have no scientific standing either since it, like AMTA is a professional organiza
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#211
Lung cancer "Complementary therapies have an increasingly important role in the control of symptoms
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#205
So you think pain medicine is crap also since it only helps with aches. Gotcha. thanks for clarifyin
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#206
As I understand: it will identify what is more valid and what is less valid & under what variables.
patrice
Jul 2012
#36
Exactly, so CAM disappears, but those that are proven effective become actual medical work
Godhumor
Jul 2012
#39
These are HUGE questions especially amongst the elderly. The answers MUST come from research that is
patrice
Jul 2012
#61
Neither. How does acupuncture work without refering to a non-tangible energy flow?
Godhumor
Jul 2012
#118
Both. Educate yourself. Scientific terms? Ok. Try here for starts... Oh dang, "mystical" is missing.
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#123
That 1 word is all you take away?Try neurotransmitters, neurohormones, nerves, hypothalamic-pituitar
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#195
How does that work if the needles don't cause pain and never overcome the receptor thresholds
MattBaggins
Jul 2012
#249
All sensory receptors are not pain receptors. If they are in you, I feel sorry because you must be
uppityperson
Jul 2012
#284
Even if what you say is true, you still do not address the balance of my post.
scubadude
Jul 2012
#257
Replies re “alternative medicine” challenge acupuncture and chiropractic practices but IMO more harm
jody
Jul 2012
#97
THANK YOU! I've been feeling as if I've wandered into the wrong site lately.
progressivebydesign
Jul 2012
#122
I can take the differences; it's the meanness of it all that is overwhelming. I wonder if there
patrice
Jul 2012
#137
I taught Psychology, as Science, for high school. Human behavior and mental processes
patrice
Jul 2012
#162
All of us need to free ourselves and then try to collaborate on how to proceed. And I do mean "need"
patrice
Jul 2012
#156
You're absolutely right, but this has nothing to do with liberal or conservative.
Egalitarian Thug
Jul 2012
#268
I am going home and stepping out for a bit. Will be on to check replies late tonight
Godhumor
Jul 2012
#158
We should allow a little bit of coverage in this area simply to admit we don't know everything.
limpyhobbler
Jul 2012
#259