Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

DanTex

(20,709 posts)
84. I don't know how to measure appeal, but Jimmy Dore and TYT aren't just nothing.
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 08:03 PM
Aug 2017

Now, granted, most people on TYT aren't nearly as nutty as Dore is, but still, people like him do have a following. If DU is any measure of anything, he got posted here fairly often before the "purge", as did other equally if not more nutty people like HA Goodman and "Sane Progressive." So, at least in one online political circle that you and I both frequent, they are (or were) somewhat influential.

Especially in light of the fact that a lot of people get their news from Facebook or youtube now, I don't think the Jimmy Dores of the world can just be dismissed as fringe. I mean, Alex Jones is certainly fringe, but he has a huge following. Also, remember that at the convention last summer, a significant minority of the delegates were actually booing a lot of the speakers. That was in the real world, not the fringe world. Where did they get their ideas? Where did Bernie-or-Bust come from? It came from "fringe" social and alternative media sites, where people like Dore and HA Goodman and the rest are influential.

You're right that Sarandon and West wouldn't say all the things that Dore has said. But they'd say different, arguably equally stupid things. Sarandon's whole Trump will make things will "really explode" comment is for the record books. West's "n****rized" comment about Obama wasn't so great either. And all three of them endorsed Jill Stein, which in my book comes pretty close to endorsing Trump.

As far as Joy Reid, of course, you're right, she has much more reach and exposure than Jimmy Dore. And, yes, obviously she has been critical of Bernie and his movement. That in itself is not problematic, though. There's a difference between "incorrect" and problematic, and I'm not even ready to concede that she's incorrect.

I don't know what comments of hers you are referring to specifically, but I do recall her pointing out that it is curious that the left has come down so hard on Booker and Harris. But again that's pretty far from saying, in your words, that it "must be for the color of their skin". And there are a lot of dimensions to that. For example, one angle is that the Bernie movement is often suspicious of "identity politics", and that suspicion can bleed over into a belief that minority or women candidates are "tokens", potentially using their gender or race to appease progressives while pursuing conservative economic policies. In fact, we saw plenty of that during the primary when people would argue that all Hillary had going for her was her gender. Also, remember Bernie himself made that poorly worded comment about how the country had "overcome racism" and that people shouldn't be basing their votes on their color.

Another angle is that African Americans, and AA women in particular, are the most loyal Democratic voters, and not only did Bernie do very poorly in that demographic, but a lot of the rhetoric coming from his supporters about the future of the party talks about the "white working class." And so on. So it's not nearly as simple as "Bernie supporters are racist".

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

There is no "alt-left." That's a word invented to create a false equivalency The Velveteen Ocelot Aug 2017 #1
Neither you nor I nor Ken spread alt-right conspiracy theories but some self-avowed 'leftists' do emulatorloo Aug 2017 #13
I'm just objecting to the term "alt-left." The Velveteen Ocelot Aug 2017 #16
Yeah the term is hinky. Trump framing and he is a liar. Best to drop it at DU. emulatorloo Aug 2017 #39
Alt-left is a an alt-right creation to make their extremes seem normal, a counter balance to... brush Aug 2017 #24
Exactly! It's the right-wing 'what-about-ism' they use to justify their hate... WoonTars Aug 2017 #27
I wasn't actually endorsing the use of the term "alt-left". Ken Burch Aug 2017 #32
Of course you aren't. Again thanks for the thread emulatorloo Aug 2017 #35
Yes DU should reject the term. emulatorloo Aug 2017 #36
THERE'S NOT ALT LEFT !!! Come on guys lets get with the propaganda uponit7771 Aug 2017 #2
Exactly. Alt Left would be Communism or the promotion of state control of all business and industry. jalan48 Aug 2017 #3
No, nothing "alt" about that rogerashton Aug 2017 #59
Can we just all agree - there is NO, NO alt-left.....I am all for Unity - asiliveandbreathe Aug 2017 #4
I've amended the thread title-never actually endorsed the idea that there's a true "alt-left" Ken Burch Aug 2017 #7
"alt-left" is just bs eleny Aug 2017 #5
Ditch "alt left," ditch "neoliberals," ditch "bros" as terms. David__77 Aug 2017 #6
Well-put. Ken Burch Aug 2017 #9
Nonsense Expecting Rain Aug 2017 #18
Ok...and you're maybe talking about 1,000 people in the whole country. Ken Burch Aug 2017 #30
Unfortunately, I think your numbers are way off. Expecting Rain Aug 2017 #43
hmmmm Warren DeMontague Aug 2017 #56
I don't believe that. Nt G_j Aug 2017 #71
And take some of the best tools out of the toolbox? Warren DeMontague Aug 2017 #55
There is no alt left ornotna Aug 2017 #8
I've amended the thread title. Ken Burch Aug 2017 #10
If only people would stop building straw men kcr Aug 2017 #14
The amended one is fine ornotna Aug 2017 #15
horrible to criticize those who threw John Lewis and Planned Parenthood under the bus. LanternWaste Aug 2017 #23
Which one is Michael Tracey, who implored Dem voters to stay home? Blue_Tires Aug 2017 #11
Oh you mean the martyr who was beaten by evil Democrat Maxine Waters? emulatorloo Aug 2017 #28
yeah, he's a trolly little fuck Blue_Tires Aug 2017 #61
Saying something doesn't exist, when it clarly does, doesn't make it so. Expecting Rain Aug 2017 #12
funny G_j Aug 2017 #72
Yes. Funny how some people get so defensive. betsuni Aug 2017 #75
Nobody equates the two. Nobody ever did. DanTex Aug 2017 #17
Spot on! Expecting Rain Aug 2017 #20
'Nobody equates the two. Nobody ever did." melman Aug 2017 #21
Sadly, You think every mention of BoB's is about you. You aren't a buster, you are a progressive emulatorloo Aug 2017 #25
The term does get used to try and silence or drive people away Ken Burch Aug 2017 #38
I guess I have been fortunate, I have never seen a DU'er call a fellow DU'er that. emulatorloo Aug 2017 #45
It was an artificially-created division, and some people still don't want to let it end. Ken Burch Aug 2017 #48
Right melman Aug 2017 #49
Anyone who equates the two is a dumb binary thinker. If it is a "position" at DU it is certainly emulatorloo Aug 2017 #57
"booted out for their views." Are you kidding? How many times have we been told here that JCanete Aug 2017 #22
If it violates TOS alert. Otherwise push back on the tiny minority who says that. emulatorloo Aug 2017 #26
You can always find several threads on that theme here. Ken Burch Aug 2017 #47
I keep trying to remind folks we are surrounded by fellow left liberals and progressives emulatorloo Aug 2017 #51
And it means a lot that you do that. Ken Burch Aug 2017 #62
Oh I am definitely not all sunshine and cotton candy, lol emulatorloo Aug 2017 #64
No, I'm not kidding. That's exactly what Nina Turner and single payer litmus test is. DanTex Aug 2017 #44
nobody should assume corruption, or evil, and where I see that I say so, though we hardly ever JCanete Aug 2017 #58
Of course financial connections should not be off the table. DanTex Aug 2017 #70
She called him a free-loafer, as if the party itself doesn't have a lot of democrats who invited him JCanete Aug 2017 #74
Which is a specific reference to his joining the party out of convenience, then leaving it, DanTex Aug 2017 #78
I didn't say they were the same, I said what Joy is doing is problematic, and she has far greater JCanete Aug 2017 #81
I don't think its problematic. At worst, she's mistaken. DanTex Aug 2017 #82
I get what your saying, but you are finding somebody who doesn't have massive appeal JCanete Aug 2017 #83
I don't know how to measure appeal, but Jimmy Dore and TYT aren't just nothing. DanTex Aug 2017 #84
It came to Bernie running because nobody identified as a Dem Ken Burch Aug 2017 #67
I don't doubt your sincere desire to help. At all. DanTex Aug 2017 #73
Actually, her campaign rescinded the concession on TPP. Ken Burch Aug 2017 #76
She was officially against TPP in the general election. DanTex Aug 2017 #80
There were many things she could not control(and I have no personal issue with her) Ken Burch Aug 2017 #85
But do voters actually have short memories? Do voters actually care about policies? DanTex Aug 2017 #86
baloney. Warren DeMontague Aug 2017 #31
Yep. A lot of us remember. Things got out of hand, didn't they? kcr Aug 2017 #40
Sure, although I'm pretty sure I didn't throw around stupid invective or do group-based name calling Warren DeMontague Aug 2017 #50
Yes, it is completely reasonable to say both sides have some blame kcr Aug 2017 #60
Everyone had bullshit thrown at them during the primaries. DanTex Aug 2017 #52
if that makes your life more fulfilling, enjoy. Warren DeMontague Aug 2017 #54
Thank you! Why is Trump's manipulative bullshit suddenly framing people's thoughts? bettyellen Aug 2017 #37
Yes, People who counter-protested are patriots emulatorloo Aug 2017 #66
All Dems denounce those Nazis. Trump is ridiculous to try and claim otherwise. bettyellen Aug 2017 #69
+1, OP WORTHY !!! uponit7771 Aug 2017 #65
+1 betsuni Aug 2017 #77
+1 Maven Aug 2017 #79
Bravo Ken emulatorloo Aug 2017 #19
The problem is the gaslighting kcr Aug 2017 #29
"alt-left" is a misnomer. Even saying Bernie supporters are ''far-left'' is incorrect. YOHABLO Aug 2017 #33
Wasn't FDR an internationalist who bucked the tide of nativist-isolationism... Expecting Rain Aug 2017 #53
The term alt left is a bogus term invented by Sean Hannity to include all non-trump supporters Gothmog Aug 2017 #34
Every argument against the OP in this thread HopeAgain Aug 2017 #41
And it's a good sign that there aren't that many arguments against the actual premise of my OP Ken Burch Aug 2017 #63
We shouldn't even be using alt-left mvd Aug 2017 #42
There is no alt left. Trump made that up. applegrove Aug 2017 #46
The fact is, Trump was using the term in a completely different context. And that matters. kcr Aug 2017 #68
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»There's folks who are CAL...»Reply #84