General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Arguments stupid people use [View all]anneboleyn
(5,626 posts)disqualified from this "proof." Honestly these people have never even thought through this argument, and they never have a response for it as AT BEST it's an argument for deism, meaning some god may exist. There is nothing in it that justifies the existence of their god vs. gods such as Shiva and Krishna, the Buddha, Odin, Zeus, the Great Spirit, etc etc.
I have seen many debates between atheists and Christians (usually evangelicals who read "proof" from the Christian bible during the debates) who will make ridiculous arguments about how a moth turning green (whatever -- take your pick) is PROOF that god exists. They are frequently allowed to get away with the fundamentally stupid and incorrect notion that such "proof" proves that the Christian god of the Christian bible exists, and created everything they see, instead of having it pointed out to them that even if one agrees that some moth turning x color proves god there's no reason it proves their god.