General Discussion

ancianita

(43,312 posts)

12. Noam Chomsky is wrong. Silence allows all the genocides he's ever covered. I've read him,

Thu Aug 31, 2017, 01:06 PM

Aug 2017

and his method was to "out" fascist genocides carried out by states against their people.

He has failed to apply what he learned about resistance in those countries. Even an unbroken clock can run fast or slow. He's off on this one.

OK! I'm totally down for the "no face, no place" idea, but the actual phrase doesn't communicate its meaning. I'll just spread the idea that no one who is morally right need cover their faces. You do know, however, that they can be photographed, too, and seriously hurt by white supremacist hate groups. Violence will be the method of fascists after their numbers have grown. Which is what the antifa are trying to prevent.

I'm still waiting for you to answer whether defensive, due force violence is the same as offensive violence.

What's your answer?

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

34 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

What the Media Got Wrong About Last Weekends Protests in Berkeley [View all] ancianita Aug 2017 OP

Obviously, they are trying to target large urban areas... Wounded Bear Aug 2017 #1

Amen to that. ancianita Aug 2017 #2

"in cities where they know they are not welcome" FLPanhandle Aug 2017 #3

They are not welcome in Berkeley, arguably the most liberal community in the USA. Expecting Rain Aug 2017 #5

Then why did the progressive (Bernie Sanders-endorsed) Mayor of Berkeley... Expecting Rain Aug 2017 #4

What forms do rejections of fascism take, then? What has worked to stop its growth so far? ancianita Aug 2017 #6

"No face, no place" means that those who want to demonstrate on "our side" should not wear masks... Expecting Rain Aug 2017 #9

Of course it's not difficult to understand. You can drop the shade casting. Of course I'd support it ancianita Aug 2017 #10

Noam Chompsy disagrees. the "gift" is his phraseology and he's spot-on. Expecting Rain Aug 2017 #11

Noam Chomsky is wrong. Silence allows all the genocides he's ever covered. I've read him, ancianita Aug 2017 #12

Chompsy is wrong, the Mayor of Berkeley is wrong, I'm wrong, everyone is wrong... Expecting Rain Aug 2017 #14

Clever by half. You don't represent everyone. Some leaders are mistaken.Chomsky is no authority on ancianita Aug 2017 #18

Explain, exactly, how people of good will have prevented the growth of 900+ fascist groups so far. ancianita Aug 2017 #13

+1000 leftynyc Aug 2017 #24

I support their cause leftynyc Aug 2017 #7

If I defend my kids from being intimidated, bullied, even hit, is my cause just? Is my due force ancianita Aug 2017 #8

Self defense, legally and morally, is about proportionally Lee-Lee Aug 2017 #16

That is a thoughtful and knowledgable response. MindPilot Aug 2017 #19

You can apply different standards but the law is the same Lee-Lee Aug 2017 #22

How many Nazis would you say are in the GOP right now? Not Ruth Aug 2017 #26

Thanks for your thoughts. It's judgment. Standing on the street in the face of hate, you can see ancianita Aug 2017 #20

What part of I'll never condone leftynyc Aug 2017 #23

Fair enough, free country. Who decides "immediate danger"? Me in my home? Or you, outside my ancianita Aug 2017 #25

Good citizens just need to stay home and tweet "resist" leftstreet Aug 2017 #15

Thanks for reading! ancianita Aug 2017 #21

Don't you know the American Left must be Ghandi crossed with MLK? maxsolomon Aug 2017 #17

Indeed. It's ugly. It's going to get uglier. We need to keep a chronology of these current clashes ancianita Aug 2017 #28

Be sure to count smashed windows and overturned newspaper boxes as "violence" maxsolomon Aug 2017 #31

LOL yeah that's what counts. Property. ancianita Aug 2017 #32

If people are walking down the streets of my city with swastikas, MarvinGardens Aug 2017 #27

I agree. Amplification by media are almost always the false equivalency source for these claims. ancianita Aug 2017 #29

It's damned sad that antifa have to check themselves with "taking a knife to a gunfight" attitude. ancianita Aug 2017 #30

Thank you, again and again, for the work you are doing on DU Coventina Aug 2017 #33

Thank you back! I'll quote my favorite TV writer, and free speech absolutist, Jenji Kohan, ancianita Sep 2017 #34