Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Honeycombe8

(37,648 posts)
21. Great! I know he's not a lech or a harasser, after watching him for years.
Tue Nov 21, 2017, 10:50 AM
Nov 2017

Comedians do over reach sometimes, reaching for the "gag." It's a personal thing with me that I give comedians a wide berth. The way a successful comedian works, and his mind works, is they go for the gag, push the envelope, and say and do things on the spur of the moment...which sometimes falls flat or is more offensive than they intended. Much of comedy is intended to be offensive about something. If they are too careful, they lose that edge that makes for a successful comedian or political satirist. Think of George Carlin, Richard Pryor, Bill Mahrer, Stephen Colbert, Jon Stewart. It doesn't mean they aren't unnecessarily offensive or don't cross the line and it's wrong. But I give them room to make that mistake because of the nature of what they do. For someone else in another line of work, it would definitely be wrong, and I would blame them.

I think things should be judged, also, for the era those things occurred in. This routine is pretty offensive and I doubt would fly these days.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I'm glad they sent this. It would be interesting to see the names though. smirkymonkey Nov 2017 #1
Here's the names octoberlib Nov 2017 #4
Jane Curtin signed it. That says a lot to me. yardwork Nov 2017 #5
Jane Curtain kicks ass Orrex Nov 2017 #22
Didn't she have a lot of trouble with how male centric SNL was in her day? dflprincess Nov 2017 #40
Yes, and she wasn't into the drugs and partying. yardwork Nov 2017 #41
Thanks for that insight NewJeffCT Nov 2017 #50
Thanks! Good to see Jane Curtin and Laraine Newman on there. smirkymonkey Nov 2017 #8
Quite the distinguished list. Hugin Nov 2017 #9
EXCELLENT! brush Nov 2017 #18
Take that you 'not a bible between you' liar. Demsrule86 Nov 2017 #2
Good to see. lindysalsagal Nov 2017 #3
K&R... spanone Nov 2017 #6
Compared to several hours and lots more women coming out about Charlie Rose mucifer Nov 2017 #7
I did an OP about it. It was like something out of the Onion octoberlib Nov 2017 #10
Yeah, thank you ladies....... a kennedy Nov 2017 #11
So why Timmygoat Nov 2017 #12
Some did not sign, a bit troubling Cicada Nov 2017 #13
Tina Fey and Al Franken did not work together. Different time periods. octoberlib Nov 2017 #14
Thank you for that explanation Cicada Nov 2017 #15
Tina Fey didn't start work at SNL until 1997 (behind the scenes). Franken was at SNL mnhtnbb Nov 2017 #16
K&R mcar Nov 2017 #17
If his accusers are to be believed, Farmer-Rick Nov 2017 #19
Good point n/t spooky3 Nov 2017 #23
If his accusers are to be believed Nevernose Nov 2017 #33
he apoligized for how the women felt questionseverything Nov 2017 #44
Good point Farmer-Rick Nov 2017 #49
Let's see if CNN makes this headline news, like they did for the unverified accusers Dopers_Greed Nov 2017 #20
Great! I know he's not a lech or a harasser, after watching him for years. Honeycombe8 Nov 2017 #21
Great example (George Carlin) robbob Nov 2017 #29
Your comment also brought to mind Michael Richards robbob Nov 2017 #36
Most uncomfortable "routine" I've ever witnessed! wolfie001 Nov 2017 #47
Great letter from the SNL women performers Gothmog Nov 2017 #24
Randi Rhodes worked with Al on Air America for yrs & she says Al was always a gentleman womanofthehills Nov 2017 #25
Thank you ladies at SNL who worked with Al Franken. democratisphere Nov 2017 #26
Trump will no doubt ask wryter2000 Nov 2017 #27
This will piss off a few people here BannonsLiver Nov 2017 #28
I don't care. I still think it's a political hit job. octoberlib Nov 2017 #32
Damn right it's a hit job. eissa Nov 2017 #34
Its both a political hit job and harassment. apnu Nov 2017 #35
Tweeden's RW crap! wolfie001 Nov 2017 #48
Standing with them and Al!! zentrum Nov 2017 #30
I beginning to think he didn't even need to apologize for that stupid photo. Hassin Bin Sober Nov 2017 #31
I would like to hear from some of the troops LisaM Nov 2017 #42
I think he was right for apologizing over the content of the joke... renegade000 Nov 2017 #43
Character witnesses moondust Nov 2017 #37
The right is out to get every Democrat who may run in 2020. Dawson Leery Nov 2017 #38
Trumps support of a child molester makes me nostalgic for the days when he just supported Nazis. L. Coyote Nov 2017 #39
K&R nt ProudProgressiveNow Nov 2017 #45
It's interesting seeing which DUers like to throw Democrats under the bus IronLionZion Nov 2017 #46
What strikes me as a positive is the power distribution of the women who signed it... CincyDem Nov 2017 #51
This is a great letter Gothmog Nov 2017 #52
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»JUST IN: Women staff of "...»Reply #21