Latest Breaking News

VanillaRhapsody

(21,115 posts)

27. are you saying it is vestigial and not there for a reason?

Tue Apr 14, 2015, 07:25 PM

Apr 2015

I suggest you youtube for a video of an actual circumcision procedure. I saw one once on a baby in a documentary and I was horrified. My grandmother volunteered for years at the hospital taking care of newborns. I asked her about it and she said oh yeah.....those babies come back screaming inconsolably so much that they would give them bottles of sugar water just to calm them back down....my own father as an adult was circumcised right before he married my mother....I was told it was a horrible experience and my grandmother told me that was why he looked so bad in his wedding pictures! In light of that....I cannot imagine doing this to a 4 yr old....without some absolute medical reason to do so...

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

60 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Civil rights case filed to stop Florida boy's circumcision [View all] Nine Apr 2015 OP

#GiveMeBackMySkin Chicago1980 Apr 2015 #1

Protect From What? HassleCat Apr 2015 #2

Genital mutilation. closeupready Apr 2015 #9

You may want to find more about genital mutilation question everything Apr 2015 #18

You're lucky congress isn't making laws Politicalboi Apr 2015 #24

You have egg on your face Lipss Apr 2015 #14

And the father did nothing about it for over two years. Nine Apr 2015 #38

If the child wasn't a newborn at the time of decision, it might have been better to wait TexasMommaWithAHat Apr 2015 #58

How do you know what came first? Earthly Creature Apr 2015 #60

The World Health organization sponsored multiple large-scale studies that showed circumcision can pnwmom Apr 2015 #39

Those doctors from the 1800s were certainly foresighted. Nine Apr 2015 #43

If the parents are not in agreement, then they should wait until the boy is older Marrah_G Apr 2015 #3

"The procedure becomes more complicated and riskier in older babies, children, and men" Lipss Apr 2015 #6

If you mean, 'mutilating infants is easier than mutilating grown men', closeupready Apr 2015 #10

The child is 4 years old, so I think we're already there azurnoir Apr 2015 #12

The doctor was concerned about children in puberty Lipss Apr 2015 #20

wrong a later story on this azurnoir Apr 2015 #22

Mustn't the person performing it attain permission from both parents? tomm2thumbs Apr 2015 #4

That's why the judge ordered her to sign the consent forms. Nine Apr 2015 #8

I think the idea that doing it when the kid is 3 or 4 is the same as when an infant is ridiculous tomm2thumbs Apr 2015 #11

Maybe ask the kid -- since it affects him afterall -- dimwit judge tomm2thumbs Apr 2015 #13

Don't you mean "dimwit judges" (plural) ? Lipss Apr 2015 #21

There was permission from both parents Lipss Apr 2015 #15

I think the father waiting so long is now the issue tomm2thumbs Apr 2015 #17

The mother didn't share your concern about the age issue Lipss Apr 2015 #19

And now she has changed her mind. Nine Apr 2015 #40

Imagine the future discussion this kid will have with his dad: LeftinOH Apr 2015 #5

Tip of the penis? Lipss Apr 2015 #7

When he is being potty trained and his Dad IS circumcized HockeyMom Apr 2015 #36

worst argument ever for circumcision Nine Apr 2015 #49

& r all fathers obsessed with other men's penis appearance? closeupready Apr 2015 #51

All men are obsessed with other males penises HockeyMom Apr 2015 #52

To a Martian, it certainly could seem that way. closeupready Apr 2015 #53

proof that you can cut off 1/3 of anything and still be fine. ileus Apr 2015 #56

Not this shit again. n/t Comrade Grumpy Apr 2015 #16

Barbaric nonsense. jomin41 Apr 2015 #23

Then why do we still have appendixes? Hoppy Apr 2015 #25

And Wisdom Teeth, and men's nipples nt Lipss Apr 2015 #26

are you saying it is vestigial and not there for a reason? VanillaRhapsody Apr 2015 #27

Alls I'm saying is that evolution doesn't work that way. Hoppy Apr 2015 #29

Particularly when there is purpose for a body part to be there... VanillaRhapsody Apr 2015 #30

Why do women have breast REDUCTION surgery? HockeyMom Apr 2015 #28

do they do that to 4 yr olds? VanillaRhapsody Apr 2015 #31

Oh, but a lot of MINOR GIRLS with big boobs HockeyMom Apr 2015 #33

and your point is? Do those girls have it done without their consent? VanillaRhapsody Apr 2015 #34

Parental consent HockeyMom Apr 2015 #35

baloney....they are not doing those without those kids wanting that....ridic... VanillaRhapsody Apr 2015 #37

Agree! It's barbaric IMO too! n/t RKP5637 Apr 2015 #32

The kid is 4 years old. It�s too late now, so let him keep it. n/t Little Tich Apr 2015 #41

My opinion too Yupster Apr 2015 #44

my husband converted to Judaism when he was in his 20s. It was helpful CTyankee Apr 2015 #42

How was that helpful? Because once older, he'd refuse consent? closeupready Apr 2015 #45

well, I'm not sure but I think he'd kinda have to be circumcised to become a Jew... CTyankee Apr 2015 #46

Ok, thanks. closeupready Apr 2015 #47

Not always. Behind the Aegis Apr 2015 #50

He didn't say anything about that... CTyankee Apr 2015 #54

The foreskin is homologous with the clitoral hood. Sivafae Apr 2015 #48

It's gonna suck when the kids has one in his 20's... ileus Apr 2015 #55

Why "when"? Nine Apr 2015 #57

Everyone is invited to a celebratory dinner at The Olive Garden! Tom Ripley Apr 2015 #59