Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

WilmywoodNCparalegal

(2,654 posts)
95. The one sure-fire way to prevent illegal immigration
Tue Aug 18, 2015, 11:27 AM
Aug 2015

is to prosecute civilly and criminally employers who knowingly hire people who lack authorization to work in the U.S.

Firstly, we must simplify Form I-9 or eliminate it altogether and replace it with mandatory E-Verify. However, employers must become better trained on Form I-9 and E-Verify. These functions are usually relegated to low-level HR employees or even third parties who do not have sufficient training or understanding. Instead, Form I-9 and E-Verify should be rightfully elevated to a compliance or legal role and anyone involved in Form I-9 and/or E-Verify should be properly trained. There are hundreds of ways an individual is authorized to work in the U.S. and hundreds of types of documentation. There are also plenty of techniques to use to distinguish between fraudulent and real documentation.

Secondly, Form I-9 audits and E-Verify monitoring must occur regularly and consistently (particularly with Form I-9 audits by ICE). When violations are found, employers need to face the music and not a simple slap on the wrist. Instead of a thousand bucks here and there, there need to be substantial monetary and other penalties on the employer, including forfeiture of assets and even jail time if necessary.

If these regulations were enforced, employers would not find it beneficial to hire people they know not to be authorized to work. As a result, there would be no advantage for someone to come to the U.S. without inspection (illegally) as there would be no work available.

[Disclaimer: I work in immigration law and I make my living in business immigration, Form I-9 and E-Verify. I am well recognized in the field.]

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Uh you might want to clear that with Big Agra and the meat processors underpants Aug 2015 #1
And the hospitality and home care and landscaping industries. dieter Aug 2015 #13
American citizens would do these jobs if paid well. candelista Aug 2015 #16
If and no underpants Aug 2015 #62
No they wouldn't. I know because I owned a house keeping agency. trillion Aug 2015 #69
Yes we would Marrah_G Aug 2015 #88
Where were you when I needed employees? I had very few whites ever apply and none stuck around even trillion Aug 2015 #100
I live in new england Marrah_G Aug 2015 #101
I paid $15 per hour and it was 2006 then. Thats why the $15 groups are demanding now seems too low trillion Aug 2015 #102
15 should be the bare minimum Marrah_G Aug 2015 #104
No you actually don't know. I know for a fact from an employer perspective. trillion Aug 2015 #103
The likelihood of Trump eviscerating our workforce was my first reaction too. About 0. But Hortensis Aug 2015 #111
Not true angrychair Aug 2015 #72
Even if they DIDN'T pay well, people would apply jmowreader Aug 2015 #84
"pandering to the xenophobic base" PSPS Aug 2015 #28
+1000 trillion Aug 2015 #70
Yes. Hortensis Aug 2015 #112
Great points underpants Aug 2015 #61
Not so good. candelista Aug 2015 #108
and the construction and road crews wordpix Aug 2015 #96
Plenty of Americans would do these jobs if they paid well. candelista Aug 2015 #109
Candelista, the contractor who built our house was the best and most honorable in the area. He Hortensis Aug 2015 #114
ATTENTION LATINOS! REPUBLICAN FRONTRUNNER Trump Would Deport All Undocumented Immigrants onehandle Aug 2015 #2
republicans will deport 5-11 million? people, many who have been here for decades, entire life. Sunlei Aug 2015 #3
Absolutely impossible task - even if there was the national will to do it aint_no_life_nowhere Aug 2015 #31
What's he plan to do, send the Gestapo in and go house to house asking for papers please. RKP5637 Aug 2015 #51
republicans will keep it like it is today. Millions of people scared they can be picked-up & deporte Sunlei Aug 2015 #80
Millions of people who pay taxes but get no political voice. Anyone here remember KingCharlemagne Aug 2015 #92
Agriculture and Meat-Packing assassins will go after Trump before that happens. valerief Aug 2015 #60
Maybe this is his... 3catwoman3 Aug 2015 #79
He's full of it. He couldn't if he really wanted to ...... marmar Aug 2015 #4
Exactly! He's a showman barker and a negotiator. He knows what to say to get the votes RKP5637 Aug 2015 #53
I'm sure this is their true goal but at a price.... FarPoint Aug 2015 #5
I'm on the side of those who do the work, i.e., the Latinos, if it comes down KingCharlemagne Aug 2015 #93
Oh trumpy.... V0ltairesGh0st Aug 2015 #6
Love that AAACK! LiberalElite Aug 2015 #10
I don't suppose he'd let a little thing like a Constitution stand in his way..... lastlib Aug 2015 #7
Not unconstitutional. They can have a choice: candelista Aug 2015 #17
Maybe you can start a Trump group on DU. JoePhilly Aug 2015 #27
That little piece of innuendo does not answer my point. candelista Aug 2015 #30
I did not say it was unconstitutional. JoePhilly Aug 2015 #32
Yes. Igel Aug 2015 #34
You also need to learn to read ... JoePhilly Aug 2015 #36
I understand your point. David__77 Aug 2015 #45
Trumpo wants to deport children--who were BORN here. lastlib Aug 2015 #58
Aren't they entitled to due process? Bradical79 Aug 2015 #74
It is of course de facto forcible deportation of a citizen alcibiades_mystery Aug 2015 #86
Are you for real? a la izquierda Aug 2015 #113
Who knew he was a pie-in-the-sky idiot to boot? pipoman Aug 2015 #8
Why "pie in the sky"? candelista Aug 2015 #18
Have you pondered the logistics of finding and deporting millions of people? Comrade Grumpy Aug 2015 #24
Besides tracking them down and making sure we got the right guys aint_no_life_nowhere Aug 2015 #38
So your objection is that it is "impractical"? candelista Aug 2015 #75
Yes my fear too. Latin communities with plenty of legal Americans know Trump would Person 2713 Aug 2015 #77
Is there a Spanish equivalent... 3catwoman3 Aug 2015 #81
It's impossible treestar Aug 2015 #39
Trump is pandering to the racist/xenophobic idiots in the GOP base Gothmog Aug 2015 #9
He is also speaking to large numbers of Latino Americans.... candelista Aug 2015 #20
So they want to be deported?? JoePhilly Aug 2015 #37
I am speaking of naturalized American citizens from Latin America. candelista Aug 2015 #41
Who pretend to be illegal ... which could get one deported ... no? JoePhilly Aug 2015 #48
oh baloney treestar Aug 2015 #40
Why do you want to expand the labor supply when American wages are already so low? candelista Aug 2015 #43
undocumented aliens wages are lower yet treestar Aug 2015 #50
That is why they have a dampening effect on wages of US citizens. candelista Aug 2015 #83
Apparently ... JoePhilly Aug 2015 #49
Ridiculous. candelista Aug 2015 #110
They would love to try...as Domestic Terrorists, they don't care about SoapBox Aug 2015 #11
You post is so full of hatred and invective, I recoil from replying to it. candelista Aug 2015 #22
They are really swarming on local levels I noticed all th way down to school boards . Person 2713 Aug 2015 #78
He'll have to start... Sophiegirl Aug 2015 #12
I'd deport the Donald if I could figure out which planet he came from Jack Rabbit Aug 2015 #14
Let him start with all the Undocumented workers R Merm Aug 2015 #15
Where will he get the money? cosmicone Aug 2015 #19
"I will come up with the money. There is plenty of money out there." AngryOldDem Aug 2015 #35
Sometimes I wonder if Trump is a Clinton plant cosmicone Aug 2015 #52
Trump's deportation proposal is fiscally impossible PJMcK Aug 2015 #107
If the GOP really wanted reduce illegal immigration TexasBushwhacker Aug 2015 #21
The Democrats could do this too. candelista Aug 2015 #23
Mass deportation of hard-working people is not a Democratic value. Comrade Grumpy Aug 2015 #25
The Democrats support a pathway to citizenship TexasBushwhacker Aug 2015 #26
Why do you want to expand the labor supply when American wages are already so low? candelista Aug 2015 #29
I want the minimum wage to be raised to at least $11/hr TexasBushwhacker Aug 2015 #42
If you raise the minimum wage without controlling immigration.... candelista Aug 2015 #44
I fully support controlling immigration TexasBushwhacker Aug 2015 #54
some states require E-Verify Mosby Aug 2015 #89
I'm in Texas. No e-verify required TexasBushwhacker Aug 2015 #97
I don't know about farming Mosby Aug 2015 #117
Not a landscaping business of any size TexasBushwhacker Aug 2015 #118
Deposits, cashed checks, wire transfers and withdrawals $10K are reported, in my experience. freshwest Aug 2015 #116
Any idea how many undocumented immigrants Trump employs at his hotels/casinos/golf courses, etc.? AngryOldDem Aug 2015 #33
I know that he applied to import workers on H1b visas TexasBushwhacker Aug 2015 #46
How can you H1B a housekeeper? jmowreader Aug 2015 #85
They say they can't get enough of them TexasBushwhacker Aug 2015 #87
H-1Bs are not for housekeepers WilmywoodNCparalegal Aug 2015 #94
You're right. My bad. TexasBushwhacker Aug 2015 #98
When do we get to see HIS BIRTH CERTIFICATE ??? n/t vkkv Aug 2015 #47
Donald Trump released his birth certificate PJMcK Aug 2015 #106
No he wouldn't. He is just saying he would. All the world is a stage. nt Live and Learn Aug 2015 #55
I suppose he could send the raving fool the great lion hunter Dr. Walter J. Palmer RKP5637 Aug 2015 #56
I didn't realize Trump was also a magician. Vinca Aug 2015 #57
Such speaking talents has the loquacious Mr. Trump. 3catwoman3 Aug 2015 #82
Trump isn't for that Hydra Aug 2015 #59
Spot on underpants Aug 2015 #63
Also eliminate the J1 program, right? greymattermom Aug 2015 #64
Of course he would deport them. He needs them to work in his Mexican factories making his clothing 4lbs Aug 2015 #65
No need to respond to this bluestateguy Aug 2015 #66
I guess Donald is paying the air fare out.... Historic NY Aug 2015 #67
Can we start with all businesses bearing the Trump name? The Second Stone Aug 2015 #68
I want to thank trump for sending the last would-be-republican Latino voters over to the Dems. trillion Aug 2015 #71
Wow! Here comes the police state with IDs, roadblocks, people dragged out of bed at night! freshwest Aug 2015 #73
Does this mean he would also deport all of the illegal Canadians and Irish? Champion Jack Aug 2015 #76
You know, I'm different than a lot of people here regarding illegal immigrants WhoWoodaKnew Aug 2015 #90
The one sure-fire way to prevent illegal immigration WilmywoodNCparalegal Aug 2015 #95
Well, when you're family is starving, waiting in line probably isn't an option. a la izquierda Aug 2015 #115
The city of Los Angeles will grind to a halt, as it is currently 51% KingCharlemagne Aug 2015 #91
I suppose we could deport 12,000,000 people if we used cattle cars. Spitfire of ATJ Aug 2015 #99
Why bother with cattle cars. Why not COLGATE4 Aug 2015 #105
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Trump Would Deport All Un...»Reply #95