Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Latest Breaking News
In reply to the discussion: High Court Rejects Appeal Over Ban on Guns at Post Offices [View all]friendly_iconoclast
(15,333 posts)54. Feh. We figured out posters like you *long* before you ever joined DU:
http://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1172&pid=189201
Nah, a "MGAFYGAE" and "Uncle Ruckus", and possibly a "F*dd"
From a still-useful thread. The whole thing is worth a read, as it discusses some very familiar
ploys
How to recognize the tactics used by anti gun activists in their plan to ban guns
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=118x361725#367600
The entire thread can be found at:
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=118x361725#361725
The disinterested reader will quickly notice that there is little new under the
gun control sun...
From a still-useful thread. The whole thing is worth a read, as it discusses some very familiar
ploys
How to recognize the tactics used by anti gun activists in their plan to ban guns
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=118x361725#367600
X_Digger
Response to Original message
60. How about..
Not sure if this one counts as a separate one, but the..
MGAFYGAE -- "MY guns are fine, YOUR guns are evil."
Black powder guns, revolvers, traditionally stocked shotguns, deer rifles, even 1911's- "But I {or Dad, or Granddad, or Uncle Duke} had / have one of those, so they're perfectly fine. The rest of your guns? Ban 'em."
friendly_iconoclast
Response to Reply #60
61. That's a good one. A variant is the "Uncle Ruckus"
Claiming to be a gun owner and/or very familiar with guns, and yet continually putting down other gun owners
jeepnstein
66. They're called "Fudds".
While I personally have nothing against Elmer Fudd and his War on Rabbits, his human counterparts are obnoxious at times.
They'll wax poetic about how this or that firearm is beyond reproach or ban because it has some sporting use. They constantly want to make the 2nd Amendment about hunting. Most of them will own a pistol or two but it's usually some kind of marginally useful thing that they've buggered to death after reading too many gun magazines.
When I was a brand-new Deputy Sheriff I had to buy a new duty weapon. My choice was, and still is, a Colt Officer's .45 ACP. Before I picked it up from my dealer I had them do a thorough inspection and adjustment. Their gun smith was a Colt armorer and he made the trigger absolute Series 80 perfection. So I stroll in to pick it up and there's a couple of Fudds standing around drinking cofee, wearing flannel shirts and hunting coats. One of them started on me about how I needed this or that special modification or doodad before the thing would really ever amount to anything. The owner of the shop jumped in and stated clearly that what I was buying wasn't a toy like they were accustomed to seeing, that it was a serious tool for serious business and his gun smith had it ready for me to be willing to bet my life on it. They didn't have a clue what he was talking about.
We get Fudds on this board every once in a while spouting off all sorts of downright dangerous information and cite their experience as a hunter as their authority. Every once in a while a politician will get a hold of a Fudd and have him go around talking like some sort of expert.
Response to Original message
60. How about..
Not sure if this one counts as a separate one, but the..
MGAFYGAE -- "MY guns are fine, YOUR guns are evil."
Black powder guns, revolvers, traditionally stocked shotguns, deer rifles, even 1911's- "But I {or Dad, or Granddad, or Uncle Duke} had / have one of those, so they're perfectly fine. The rest of your guns? Ban 'em."
friendly_iconoclast
Response to Reply #60
61. That's a good one. A variant is the "Uncle Ruckus"
Claiming to be a gun owner and/or very familiar with guns, and yet continually putting down other gun owners
jeepnstein
66. They're called "Fudds".
While I personally have nothing against Elmer Fudd and his War on Rabbits, his human counterparts are obnoxious at times.
They'll wax poetic about how this or that firearm is beyond reproach or ban because it has some sporting use. They constantly want to make the 2nd Amendment about hunting. Most of them will own a pistol or two but it's usually some kind of marginally useful thing that they've buggered to death after reading too many gun magazines.
When I was a brand-new Deputy Sheriff I had to buy a new duty weapon. My choice was, and still is, a Colt Officer's .45 ACP. Before I picked it up from my dealer I had them do a thorough inspection and adjustment. Their gun smith was a Colt armorer and he made the trigger absolute Series 80 perfection. So I stroll in to pick it up and there's a couple of Fudds standing around drinking cofee, wearing flannel shirts and hunting coats. One of them started on me about how I needed this or that special modification or doodad before the thing would really ever amount to anything. The owner of the shop jumped in and stated clearly that what I was buying wasn't a toy like they were accustomed to seeing, that it was a serious tool for serious business and his gun smith had it ready for me to be willing to bet my life on it. They didn't have a clue what he was talking about.
We get Fudds on this board every once in a while spouting off all sorts of downright dangerous information and cite their experience as a hunter as their authority. Every once in a while a politician will get a hold of a Fudd and have him go around talking like some sort of expert.
The entire thread can be found at:
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=118x361725#361725
The disinterested reader will quickly notice that there is little new under the
gun control sun...
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
94 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Plus the scale and lethality of the weapons have changed, and you can't keep willfully ignoring that
villager
Mar 2016
#22
Ah, the "Technology has rendered the Second Amendment obsolete" argument is made
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#27
The First Amendment has moved along with technology...why not the Second?
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#51
The Supreme Court just *unanimously* issued the following rejection of your thesis:
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#57
"(T)he current four that are not fascist assholes" AGREED with the other four
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#78
I hope you find all that moralizing and self-righteousness a soothing balm for your soul
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#91
Rightwing judges presume a lot -- as did the Supreme Court when Scalia was the 5th NRA vote.
villager
Mar 2016
#38
Do you really believe it's not going to wind up in court anyway after your NRA compadres
villager
Mar 2016
#47
A progressive liberal also believes that the Constitution is not immutable
William Seger
Mar 2016
#16
Exactly. That side will never commit to an unambiguous answer while *pretending* to be reasonable...
villager
Mar 2016
#24
How about an unambiguous answer from *you*- what's a "large capacity magazine"?
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#26
'Forced justification' and 'Phelpsing', eh? Noted and figured out *long* ago:
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#56
No deal, Elmer- it's not up to you, as much as that might chap your ass
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#66
Do you prefer the Logitech Illuminated or an IBM Model M clone for your gun-control needs?
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#79
I don't own a gun, and haven't for years. Got any more erroneous assumptions for us?
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#87
"(P)ass the laws you want"? "(G)et busy"? As if! That sort doesn't do real-world politics
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#69
An unearned and undeserved sense of superiority has long been associated with gun control advocates
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#80
And what are *you* doing in the real world to bring that about? My guess: Nothing,...
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#67
Or anything substantial. BTW, you just used *another* fallacy seen prior to your DU stint:
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#77
It's none of your business. You are attempting the "forced justification" technique:
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#55
Not up to you, and you'll most likely never do anything in real life to make your dream reality
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#65
"That is why the whiny petulance of modern gun control advocates no longer.......
pablo_marmol
Mar 2016
#88
Back when they had political pull it carried a little. Not now, of course.
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#90
Agreed. Given the fact that the tide is failing to turn they're just getting filthy. NT
pablo_marmol
Mar 2016
#94
Feh. We figured out posters like you *long* before you ever joined DU:
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#54
Gonna stick with the Phelpsing and Fuddism? Fine- heckling from nonparticipating bystanders...
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#68
Don't mealy-mouth it. Have the courage of your convictions and spit it out.
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#76
I love the smell of undeserved and unearned self-righteousness in the morning
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#86
No different from heckling by a middle schooler- let them get it out of their system
friendly_iconoclast
Mar 2016
#93
I don't know why the scared-of-their-own-shadows gun freaks are upset about this.
Aristus
Mar 2016
#5
could be that the cons on the Court want to wait until they get another majority
TheDormouse
Mar 2016
#28
I don't see the relevance of the parking lot part. So the gun owner parks across the street.
Brother_Love
Mar 2016
#30