Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Latest Breaking News
In reply to the discussion: In Hiroshima, Kerry will not apologize for atomic bombs dropped on Japan [View all]oneshooter
(8,614 posts)95. In early 1944 the Department of the Army ordered
one million Purple Heart awards. This was in preparation for the invasion of Japan.
We are still awarding these medals from that order today.
This is how many casualties were expected from the in nvasion.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
315 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
In Hiroshima, Kerry will not apologize for atomic bombs dropped on Japan [View all]
jpak
Apr 2016
OP
Nothing done in or to Iraq comes even close to what the Japanese did in WWII.
EX500rider
Apr 2016
#224
Thus the US agreed NOT to remove the Emperor and post war kept on the old ruling elite
happyslug
Apr 2016
#289
That Soviets didn't care about human life, after the Soviets invaded Finland, and then Poland,
braddy
Apr 2016
#154
Actually the post war study on the bombing said the bombing HELPED the Nazis.
happyslug
Apr 2016
#198
I'm not talking about actions. I'm talking about your dream bombings from 2016z
morningfog
Apr 2016
#240
Dont feel bad about saying something, I support your comment, but I wont make
Jackie Wilson Said
Apr 2016
#151
Hmm thats probably why they say war is hell, every side did things in that war that they shouldnt
cstanleytech
Apr 2016
#52
Depending on who is doing the counting, the Fire Bomb raid on Tokyo caused the greatest loss of life
happyslug
Apr 2016
#205
It's hard for those of Japanese decent to come to terms with the terrible way Japan waged war
TeamPooka
Apr 2016
#58
I was trying to describe the silly duck and cover routines I learned as a kid.
Kablooie
Apr 2016
#272
My wife is Chinese. Rape of Nanking, Unit 731 in Harbin and human experimentation
Feeling the Bern
Apr 2016
#121
300,000 men, women and children in Nanjing. 20,000 women raped in Nanjing
Feeling the Bern
Apr 2016
#260
They started the damn war. No one cared in 1931-1938 when they were butchering Chinese
Feeling the Bern
Apr 2016
#301
"Trying to surrender"? How difficult was it to send a telegram to FDR and Churchill
Nye Bevan
Apr 2016
#6
A lot of it was to save the POWs who were dying by the 10s of 1000s, and in fact were
braddy
Apr 2016
#155
He has been an advocate for reducing/eliminating nuclear weapons his whole career
karynnj
Apr 2016
#99
You do place a great reliance on test scores et al, don't you? Bet you "keep score" too.
Hekate
Apr 2016
#254
Exactly...When they received the warnings on Hiroshima, they knew they were losing
whathehell
Apr 2016
#282
Trying to surrender? lol They took two atomic bomb hits and wanted to keep fighting
TeamPooka
Apr 2016
#59
As I mentioned earlier, the Atomic bombing had NO affect on the decision to surrender
happyslug
Apr 2016
#292
There's nothing like knowing zero about the Axis, especially the Japanese war crimes in Asia.
Hekate
Apr 2016
#159
The 'Empire of Japan' would no doubt agree with you -- Read the Rape of Nanking.
whathehell
Apr 2016
#281
An easy dodge. To some, being a superpower means never saying anything but "Sorry"
whathehell
Apr 2016
#285
there is also the question of why a few days after the first nuclear bomb, they dropped another...
EX500rider
Apr 2016
#148
True, but were three days enough or is it possible that a week or two might have led to surrender
karynnj
Apr 2016
#150
30 yrs ago I met a friend of a friend of and both were WW II vets and one had been a ...
Botany
Apr 2016
#11
How convenient that the one scenario where it's OK to use nukes is the time we used them.
arcane1
Apr 2016
#40
Ike an the others didn't have an issue with incinerating civilians via firebombing
Kaleva
Apr 2016
#118
I've known a lot of WWII vets in my time, even my father who fought the Japanese
braddy
Apr 2016
#178
What would the US do if someone threw up a naval blockade of our oil imports in 1969?
kristopher
Apr 2016
#48
"It is estimated that out of every 6 deaths in the bombings, 5 were civilians and 1 was military."
rug
Apr 2016
#20
International law during World War II did not specifically forbid aerial bombardment of cities.
EX500rider
Apr 2016
#211
Live with the victims and their families as long as I and you fail to feel sympathy
Feeling the Bern
Apr 2016
#275
Still not a word about the Japanese human experimentation in Unit 731, the Three All's policy
Feeling the Bern
Apr 2016
#278
The bomb and Kerry's refusal to apologize provokes the Japanese War Crimes
Feeling the Bern
Apr 2016
#283
I would walk down Main Street accosting random Chinese residents about the Nanking Massacre.
rug
Apr 2016
#284
The fact that you think their was a "naval blockade" of Japan before the war....
EX500rider
Apr 2016
#114
Quote from you "What would the US do if someone threw up a naval blockade of our oil imports in 1969
EX500rider
Apr 2016
#147
You really think the US had a economic embargo against the Japanese in place..
EX500rider
Apr 2016
#210
whether you think incinerating civilians "worked" or not. It is in violation of the law.
EX500rider
Apr 2016
#213
My prior comment only concerned the technical legalities of the use of the atomic bombs.
branford
Apr 2016
#271
Why apologize for ending a war of aggression that committed many documented atrocities?
GummyBearz
Apr 2016
#24
a bomb is a bomb is a bomb unless you are positioning yourself as some sort of victim instead of
msongs
Apr 2016
#35
The pro left, the west can never do any right crowd has taken over this thread.
Dawson Leery
Apr 2016
#39
Nazis already had surrendered to the Soviet Supreme command 4 months earlier :p
MillennialDem
Apr 2016
#125
If those cities were leveled by conventional bombings, would that require an apology?
PersonNumber503602
Apr 2016
#67
Go to the Rape of Nanking Memorial and walk out thinking anyone owes Japan an apology for anything
Feeling the Bern
Apr 2016
#123
No one seems to ever give a shit what the Japanese did in Korea, China, Taiwan
Feeling the Bern
Apr 2016
#122
The problem is that many on DU blame America for everything wrong in the world
Democat
Apr 2016
#129
She was born and raised in Danyang, about 80 miles east of Nanjing. Full blooded Han Chinese
Feeling the Bern
Apr 2016
#196
I think the song is good propaganda. Doesn't mean I like it? And I argue with him about it all the
Feeling the Bern
Apr 2016
#268
Dude, you said it was your favorite song. On a thread about the 2 nukes dropped on Japan.
Bonobo
Apr 2016
#270
You're absolutely right. In fact, atomic bomb was barely a factor in their surrender.
Nyan
Apr 2016
#252
The Japanese high command actually attempted to overthrown Hirohito and confiscate the surrender
Feeling the Bern
Apr 2016
#258
That has been a traditional approach to this. And it has been pretty much debunked by
Nyan
Apr 2016
#262
When they apologize for murdering 28 million Chinese citizens and all the war crimes they
Feeling the Bern
Apr 2016
#259
They have apologized over and over. And they did not murder 28 million citizens.
Bonobo
Apr 2016
#264
You do realize I worked at the Rape of Nanking museum for almost three years.
Feeling the Bern
Apr 2016
#267
Rather than relitigating yesterday's argument, why not read what Secretary actually did and said
karynnj
Apr 2016
#149
My dad was in Borneo when the peace time sneak attack on Pearl harbor was made.
braddy
Apr 2016
#153
Has Japan ASKED for an apology? No? then I don't see the need. We all know it was a horrible
vkkv
Apr 2016
#160
That isn't an answer to my question, when did the American military conduct a genocide
braddy
Apr 2016
#182
It's too broad for me, if fighting and war is now genocide, then it was just about all genocide.
braddy
Apr 2016
#235
I think largely in terms as a soldier and a lifelong student of military history, starting to
braddy
Apr 2016
#257
I'm a military history buff and an American Army veteran, and it is a legitimate question.
braddy
Apr 2016
#184
I read that and many others, I also grew up reading of Hitler and genocide against the Jews, it
braddy
Apr 2016
#186
I think of genocide as trying to physically erase a people to death, such as Hitler practicing
braddy
Apr 2016
#188
If we call a battle genocide or a small war genocide, then what do we call Hitler's actual
braddy
Apr 2016
#190
Hitler was only third to the mass murderers of the 20th century, but again, mass murder
braddy
Apr 2016
#192
Nothing to apologize for. We rebuilt the country & made them a 1st world country.
GOLGO 13
Apr 2016
#207
Very ugly story tailored to titilate those who are nearly drowning in general hatred.
Judi Lynn
Apr 2016
#223