Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

geek tragedy

(68,868 posts)
36. Besides his writings?
Mon Aug 1, 2016, 01:03 PM
Aug 2016
http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/media/2015/10/i-wanted-believe-jeremy-corbyn-i-cant-believe-seumas-milne

Take Ukraine. Ukrainians overthrew President Viktor Yanukovich last year, after snipers killed dozens of protesters. When they broke into his palace, they found treasures upon treasures – icons, carved ivory, Picasso ceramics, ancient books – piled up in the garage. He’d had nowhere to put them.

It was pure people power: the street reclaiming democracy from a thuggish kleptocrat. There was plenty for the leftist Milne to cheer here, right? Wrong. And then Ukraine’s larger neighbour took advantage of the revolutionary government’s weakness to annex its southern province. That’s something for Milne to disapprove of, right? Wrong again.

“The crisis in Ukraine is a product of the disastrous Versailles-style break-up of the Soviet Union in the early 1990s,” he told his readers on March 5. “The US and its allies have since relentlessly expanded NATO up to Russia's borders… it is hardly surprising that Russia has acted to stop the more strategically sensitive and neuralgic Ukraine falling decisively into the western camp.”

“Putin’s absorption of Crimea and support for the rebellion in eastern Ukraine is clearly defensive,” he wrote, a couple of months later.


...

For Milne, geopolitics is more important than people. Whatever crisis strikes the world, the West’s to blame. Why did a group of psychopaths attack a magazine and a supermarket in Paris? “Without the war waged by western powers, including France, to bring to heel and reoccupy the Arab and Muslim world, last week’s attacks clearly couldn’t have taken place”.

Why did Anders Breivik slaughter 77 people? “What is most striking is how closely he mirrors the ideas and fixations of transatlantic conservatives.”

Why did two maniacs in London decapitate an off-duty soldier? “They are the predicted consequence of an avalanche of violence unleashed by the US, Britain and others.”

Milne’s geopolitics spared us having to read how the children of Beslan or the theatregoers of Moscow only had themselves to blame, but office workers in New York had no such luck. “Recognition of why people might have been driven to carry out such atrocities, sacrificing their own lives in the process - or why the United States is hated with such bitterness, not only in Arab and Muslim countries, but across the developing world - seems almost entirely absent.”


He's also an apologist for ... Slobo Milosevic, because Milne has one principle: North America and Europe are always the villains.

http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/aug/02/warcrimes.serbia

So, in his view, Slobo Milosevic is a poor, victimized man of the people.

He's as anti-USA/NATO as ISIS.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

US launches strikes on IS in Libya [View all] MowCowWhoHow III Aug 2016 OP
U.S. jets pound ISIL in Libya MowCowWhoHow III Aug 2016 #1
Because why not, right? anoNY42 Aug 2016 #2
the government requested the bombing, and it's freaking ISIS. geek tragedy Aug 2016 #3
My point anoNY42 Aug 2016 #6
we're not bombing terrorism, we're bombing an armed militia that occupies territory geek tragedy Aug 2016 #7
And my point still stands. anoNY42 Aug 2016 #11
the human race has been doing it for thousands of years. geek tragedy Aug 2016 #12
I was under the impression anoNY42 Aug 2016 #13
it's a very slow process. geek tragedy Aug 2016 #14
In that case anoNY42 Aug 2016 #22
North Korea and Russia have nukes. geek tragedy Aug 2016 #24
So the test is anoNY42 Aug 2016 #26
To make it a military vs a law enforcement concern, I would say that's a very good rule of thumb. geek tragedy Aug 2016 #28
Ok anoNY42 Aug 2016 #32
a lot of other people are doing the fighting on the ground. geek tragedy Aug 2016 #33
"But the ouster of Col. Muammar el-Qaddafi left Libya a failed state and a terrorist haven." uawchild Aug 2016 #8
the alternative to Qaddafi's overthrow wasn't peace and prosperity, it was a Syria-like scenario nt geek tragedy Aug 2016 #9
The Guardian has a different view... "There's nothing moral about Nato's intervention in Libya" uawchild Aug 2016 #15
Seamus Milne is an anti-American Stalinist who gloated about the 9.11 attacks. geek tragedy Aug 2016 #16
"The Big Lie About the Libyan War" uawchild Aug 2016 #17
the US was taking sides in a civil war, not terribly difficult to infer that they wanted the other geek tragedy Aug 2016 #21
WRONG we were NOT taking sides uawchild Aug 2016 #30
STALINIST? Woah baby, its McCarthyism time! Seamus Milne is an accomplished journalist lol uawchild Aug 2016 #20
ummm geek tragedy Aug 2016 #23
lol and I paraphrase your proof: "His colleague had drinks with Che" lol uawchild Aug 2016 #29
asdf geek tragedy Aug 2016 #31
STANDPOINT MAGAZINE? Good lord, that's a right-wing RAG uawchild Aug 2016 #34
More about STANDPOINT magazine's rightwing bilge uawchild Aug 2016 #35
Besides his writings? geek tragedy Aug 2016 #36
Where's the STALINISM? uawchild Aug 2016 #38
He's a lifelong, proud Communist who rooted for the USSR. geek tragedy Aug 2016 #39
lol out of right wing sites to smear Milne with? uawchild Aug 2016 #41
I copied and pasted from his Wikipedia site. geek tragedy Aug 2016 #42
"has never stopped hating Western governments and blames them for every trouble in the world" uawchild Aug 2016 #44
STANDPOINT about Hillary: She has a sense of entitlement which she does not always disguise uawchild Aug 2016 #37
It's ever-morphing "government" is a "failed state". David Zephyr Aug 2016 #45
Perhaps you need more informaiton about the Libyan government requesting that help. glennward Aug 2016 #4
Oh anoNY42 Aug 2016 #5
So we just sit back and watch? yeoman6987 Aug 2016 #18
Really? anoNY42 Aug 2016 #19
"We have to fight them over there so we don't have to... actslikeacarrot Aug 2016 #25
But this time it will be different, anoNY42 Aug 2016 #27
Wow. Keep those blinders on. yeoman6987 Aug 2016 #40
I'm not the one advocating for an approach that has grown old and weary. anoNY42 Aug 2016 #43
U.S. commander in Africa says Libya is a failed state uawchild Aug 2016 #10
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»US launches strikes on IS...»Reply #36