Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Latest Breaking News
In reply to the discussion: US troops deliver food, supplies to devastated Puerto Rico during round-the-clock operations [View all]AtheistCrusader
(33,982 posts)23. IT IS AN OIL TANKER.
OH MY GOD.
"it is still better than having no hospital at all"
THE KEARSARGE IS A HOSPITAL, WITH HEAVY LIFT AND AMPHIBIOUS ASSAULT AND AIR ASSAULT CAPABILITIES, WITH THE BEST DOCTORS IN THE FLEET.
It is designed FOR this mission, minus killing people and breaking things. It was there before the storm, during the storm, and after the storm, doing what it does best. Doing a mission the Comfort is not suited to.
When I say it is 'not fun' to play doctor on the Comfort while it's at sea, that was actually sarcasm. It materially hampers the ability to do so. FEMA/Navy, etc have been running full tilt boogie for more than a month on disaster relief, across the gulf. Diverting materials and personnel to the Comfort is a mistake in this situation. Those materials could have been moved faster. Those people could have been used sooner. Transported more easily.
It is a politically motivated mistake to utilize that ship in this situation. AT BEST, it should be sent somewhere ELSE with a deep blue water harbor that isn't wrecked, freeing up SOME OTHER asset that could be better used in Puerto Rico.
If you were demanding to know why the Iwo Jima wasn't in Purto Rico, I'd be harder pressed to offer a good reason, and would probably agree with you, aside from the fact that IT is being re-fueled and re-provisioned after hurricane relief in Florida.
If you had a choice between putting supplies and people on the Iwo Jima, or the Comfort and you chose the Comfort in this situation, you'd be making a horrible mistake.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
78 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
US troops deliver food, supplies to devastated Puerto Rico during round-the-clock operations [View all]
nitpicker
Sep 2017
OP
Why the fuck has the USNS Comfort hospital ship been sitting in Norfolk all this time?
SunSeeker
Sep 2017
#4
Because it's inferior to the USS Kearsarge and can't dock in Puerto Rico right now.
AtheistCrusader
Sep 2017
#11
The USNS Comfort has a 33 foot draft. San Juan port has a channel depth of 34.7 feet.
AtheistCrusader
Sep 2017
#14
I see you have no link. It CAN anchor offshore, with smaller boats bringing patients to it.
SunSeeker
Sep 2017
#15
None of that disputes that it can anchor offshore, with smaller boats bringing patients to it.
SunSeeker
Sep 2017
#21
It is a hospital ship. Trump should have sent it and every other one we had available.
SunSeeker
Sep 2017
#29
What part of 3.5 million Americans with no food, power or hospitals do you not understand?
SunSeeker
Sep 2017
#35
It is 'moving big things around' if the big thing isn't able to aid them.
AtheistCrusader
Sep 2017
#37
But 5000 national guard in place before the hurricane hit is a "mealy mouthed response".
AtheistCrusader
Sep 2017
#43
Not at all. First of all, the president doesn't activate the national guard in this manner.
AtheistCrusader
Sep 2017
#52
WRONG. The President does not need to be "king" to activate US troops in emergencies.
SunSeeker
Sep 2017
#56
You continued attempt to re-cast pointing out reality as 'defending trump' is noxious and part
AtheistCrusader
Sep 2017
#58
You were not "pointing out reality." You wrongly suggested he couldn't call out more NG.
SunSeeker
Sep 2017
#61
It is you who wants to add words that were not there, 9 paragraphs of them. nt
SunSeeker
Oct 2017
#65
You did. My original post is still there in context for everyone to see.
AtheistCrusader
Oct 2017
#68
Frankly, all the Wasp class ships are genius designs. I think they are fantastic.
AtheistCrusader
Sep 2017
#59
It's used in many places where it can't dock. It stands offshore with transport to it.
SharonAnn
Sep 2017
#49
And there is a history of how many many people it can handle when docked versus at anchor.
AtheistCrusader
Sep 2017
#53
It left VA a few days ago. Article posted on du. I do not know when it will arrive in PR.
riversedge
Oct 2017
#76
Yes, I know. But no one can explain why it took so long for it to leave for PR.
SunSeeker
Oct 2017
#77
Pathetic, the repeated use of the word 'sortie' in this context ... who WROTE this?
mr_lebowski
Sep 2017
#5
I was not talking to you, so you were not "responding" to me, you were butting in.
SunSeeker
Sep 2017
#36