Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Latest Breaking News
In reply to the discussion: Denmark's Burqa Ban Has Gone Into Effect [View all]SunSeeker
(57,435 posts)30. No, it is not silly at all. People only wear ski masks when skiing or when it's freezing. nt.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
361 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Like men, they can wear hats, turbans and scarves. Like men, they can't cover their faces,
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#3
Unlike men, they can't wear certain garments dictated by religious law or custom.
Orsino
Aug 2018
#19
Unlike most who opine about this, I actually know women who are forced to wear a burka. I
Squinch
Aug 2018
#359
Good for Denmark. Push back on these repressives and their attempts to normalize it.
7962
Aug 2018
#9
I agree. These religions that make women 2nd class citizens make me vomit.
WhoWoodaKnew
Aug 2018
#115
Saw exactly that in Sydney several years ago. A woman in a burka pushing a stroller with a
Floyd R. Turbo
Aug 2018
#21
My objection is neither about religion, nor racism. The state should not outlaw styles of dress.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#16
It prevents people from being ID'd in public. I think the state has a valid interest.
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#17
That arg falsely links Islam w crime. when ski masks are illegal, ur argument may make some sense.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#20
It is illegal to walk around in public wearing a ski mask in Denmark, per this law.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#22
No, it is not silly at all. People only wear ski masks when skiing or when it's freezing. nt.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#30
It's silly (or perhaps just uncivil) to demand people keep visible faces. Paranoia is not policy. Nt
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#31
It is not silly nor paranoid to require people show their faces when in public. nt
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#34
Many things are a security risk. This calculation is being made in part bc the affected population
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#58
The affected population could be ANYONE. In the NW, we had a couple women walking around
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#78
It could be - but in this case it is those who wear the burqa who are affected.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#80
The word "everyone" u use so casually in your post betrays the lack of depth of thinking.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#68
You must be joking. Did you read this piece? A POC misidentified as a criminal is in peril.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#71
It's not too surprising when a machine set on 80% is wrong 20%+ of the time.
EX500rider
Aug 2018
#105
Male legislators should not be mandating what women can & can't wear. Taliban & Danes do that.
Bernardo de La Paz
Aug 2018
#325
Face coverings aren't clothes. They're masks. This law applies to both sexes.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#346
Law also prevents LGBTQ from hiding faces when going into LGBTQ events. THAT'S oppressive too. . nt
Bernardo de La Paz
Aug 2018
#326
The existence of surveillance tech does not mean the people an obligation to submit to surveillance.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#53
Many things are a security risk, priorities of rights curtailed are based in cultural perceptions.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#59
sunglasses? Wide rimmed hats? Surgical masks? Eye patches? Where does it end?
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#76
None of those things completely obscure the face except for the eyes, like a ski mask
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#85
White woman fashion A-OKAY but muslim woman can't make their own choices?
Bernardo de La Paz
Aug 2018
#334
Until the woman herself rejects the burqa, your assumption of her opinions is sexist. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#92
Not at all, that's a tragic reality around the world. Limiting their choices isnt how to redress it
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#329
I'm not saying we should ban their clothing. Just ALL face masks, whether it's a man or a woman
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#330
Of course not. But is sexist for male legislators to oppress women's choices.
Bernardo de La Paz
Aug 2018
#338
You are assuming wrong. There is an extremely low incidence of voter fraud, even in states
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#107
People can be ID'ed if needed. Otherwise go whole hog and embed a radio transmitter chip in arm. .nt
Bernardo de La Paz
Aug 2018
#323
How? Rip a burqa off a woman who's hit me and refuses to show herself? Or a man under a ski mask?
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#327
Of course you didn't take a photo of the driver. You could SEE s/he matched the driver's license.
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#348
Yeah, it does matter. If someone has hit me, it matters who that person was. n/t
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#350
Snore. Let the police handle stolen licenses. Don't try it yourself. Gosh. . . . nt
Bernardo de La Paz
Aug 2018
#354
I have to laugh at all the MEN defending women's "right" to wear those oppressive garments,
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#355
Hopefully the oppressed are willing to continue to pay for the delay with their lives and freedom.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#72
If "a cultural subgroup's practice" is cruel and inhumain it should be ruled against
Merlot
Aug 2018
#84
Like totally unfair...Xenophobic , Reminds me of the rabid antiabortion freaks in americu..
Maxheader
Aug 2018
#25
the fact they do not tell the difference between a niqab and burja is ignorance
DonCoquixote
Aug 2018
#28
+1. Americans know that racism as foundation of policy is bad. Refusing to cop to it is worse. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#33
You seem personally invested in negating disagreeing opinions on this. But you can't.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#43
You are not the people of Denmark. That's not your place. You are one individual. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#45
You are one person, and your job is not to naysay everyone else here with opinion claimed as facts.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#49
Your posts declare the intent and effect of the policy as having nothing to do with race. Opinion.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#96
A law need not acknowledge it is racist in order to be racist. I'm surprised you tried this argument
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#113
Potentially, many things. Perhaps you should stop talking and start thinking. (nt)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#119
You can't answer because it's not. Nor are bans on female genital mutilation.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#127
Your error? "misogynistic, backwards, debilitating cultural practices" is opinion, not fact (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#128
You really think burqas and FGM are not misogynistic, backwards, debilitating cultural practices?
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#129
I try not to make absolutist value judgments about other cultural practices than mine. It's racist.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#130
Defending FGM on DU!! - who would have thought this day would come? n/t
Fix The Stupid
Aug 2018
#134
How is it racist? Are we not allowed to stop backwards practices that debilitate women?
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#136
Foot binding! It's a beautiful, cultural tradition! How dare we criticize it!
Coventina
Aug 2018
#138
You're thoroughly incorrect. And you are also entitled to your opinion, as am I. Cheers!
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#149
LOL, the bad logic in your post is what is laughable. Are all women wearing burqa forced? NO. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#154
So you are in favor of forced assimilation? But see no problem conflating FGM and the burqa?
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#157
Nope. If it was a cultural issue, then all Muslim men would continue to wear the thawb.
Coventina
Aug 2018
#159
Yup. But your use of the word "all" in that comment is pure stupidity and racist absolutism.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#162
No, it's holding another culture to your personal (not even your culture's) standards. Xenophobia.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#165
No, emigration doesn't work that way, unless it is to a totalitarian state. Freedom of expression
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#169
No, there is no such thing as being able to express yourself however you want.
Coventina
Aug 2018
#172
Wearing a burqa is a form of expression. It is, and should be, tolerated in many societies.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#174
It's super cute that you think you can demand an entire society of people abandon their practices
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#179
"Entire society of people"? No, just that Muslim women enjoy the same rights as their men.
Coventina
Aug 2018
#181
Feminists listen to women and ask them their values. White saviors speak for them without listening
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#183
It sure seems to matter to you, as you have been attacking my opinions as if they threaten you.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#190
Real feminism requires real work. The burqa is not shorthand for male oppression, and outlawing it
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#194
Okay, it's been fun but you aren't being honest so I'm done feeding you. See post 200.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#203
LOL! Your shift is probably coming to an end by now. Have a great day! (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#214
The idea of you spending a precious vacation day arguing racist trash is what's really funny.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#220
"I try not to make absolutist value judgments about other cultural practices than mine. It's racist"
EX500rider
Aug 2018
#224
Dishonestly omitting "absolute" when quoting me and equating human sacrifice to burqa...
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#232
Your post is Dishonest. U omitted the word absolutist from my quote, and that's dishonest. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#237
No, paraphrasing me u said NO judgment can be made, a dishonest contradiction of my point. (Nt)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#240
Well I for sure can be absolutest in my condemnation of certain cultural practices..
EX500rider
Aug 2018
#241
No, but the assertion that a nijab would be banned is an incorrect statement of fact.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#48
I didn't say a nijab would be. And laws are based on many factors... this one clearly reflects race.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#50
That's your opinion, and I never made no such assertion that such coverings would be banned.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#99
No, you typed "+1" which means you agree with everything in the post. A fact.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#103
I can agree with the post without agreeing with your interpretation of the post. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#112
Do you understand this law does not ban hair coverings as pictured in that post you agree with? nt
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#118
Do you understand how to let others have opinions with which you disagree? Like, wearing burqas? nt
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#131
I'm not defl3cting. Why are you attacking those with whom you disagree? Difference of opinion
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#150
Sexism super bad. If women do not voluntarily abandon the hijab, assuming they want to is sexist. nt
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#91
Wrong. Both of them fully obscure the face, except for the eyes. The only difference
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#87
And people of color r vastly misrecognized by this tech (predominantly written/trained by non POCs)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#60
My support for this "burqa ban" does not equal support for facial recognition surveillance
Devil Child
Aug 2018
#74
The irony is that the people on DU outraged about this ban as somehow oppressive
GulfCoast66
Aug 2018
#114
Ferengi are similar oppressive. woman are nude,not allowed in public or to own businesses.
Sunlei
Aug 2018
#126
Sorry, that category has been done to death by those of you declaring this a one sided issue.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#155
Some Muslim women adopt western dress in the West, and not all women who wear burqa are forced.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#160
If they want to wear the burqa, they should go to a country where that is the norm.
Coventina
Aug 2018
#161
That is a fundamentally racist statement. That isn't your decision to make. It's theirs.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#163
A culture is neither rejected, nor adopted, wholesale. That is a foolish notion.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#167
Then why are you interfering with those individuals' right to choose their own mode of dress?
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#171
Your spam posts here do exactly that. A burqa does not erase identity if a woman chooses it.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#175
That is the entire purpose of a burqa? Says you... a non-Arab, non-Muslim? Did you study Islam?
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#180
Yes, as a matter of fact I have studied Islam. I have Muslim students who tell me
Coventina
Aug 2018
#182
Any educated educator would never freely use the absolutist language you do.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#184
Not projection. You used absolutist lterms inappropriate to the realities of cultural interaction.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#189
Cultural interaction is what I teach. I am well aware of what is oppressive and what is not.
Coventina
Aug 2018
#191
Nor is demanding all immigrants to a society assimilate in full, as u did above.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#193
Don't be dishonest. U said "If they want to live in the west, then they should adopt western dress"
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#196
All women should be free to dress as they please and to wear clothing that expresses their identity
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#200
The it's you on one side of this argument, and me and Amnesty International on the other.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#208
I value the opinions of the world's human rights authorities over anecdotes deployed to racist ends
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#213
If being anti-burqa is YOUR definition of racist, then there are a LOT of "racists" here on DU.
Coventina
Aug 2018
#215
Says you. And since you are not a woman who wears one, it's not your call to make for them.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#221
And, as I've said before, I had nothing to do with this decision, I merely applaud it.
Coventina
Aug 2018
#223
Sunseeker, meet Coventina. You seem to disagree with each other about the legality of the burqa.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#234
Me too. But I wouldn't presume to ban it outright, I would let Muslim women decide for themselves.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#246
Letting women decide for themselves is misogyny? You can't be serious with this trash. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#249
You are not the one to decide if another person has an identity or not based on their clothing.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#256
You are not the one to decide if a person's identity is obliterated by their choice of covering.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#260
A non Muslim can assuredly tell Muslim women the purpose of the burqa? Nonsense. nt
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#280
Thank god you arrived to tell everyone what we were and weren't already talking about! nt
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#339
Danish culture does not allow the valuing of women as second class. FULL STOP
RelativelyJones
Aug 2018
#230
Then Amnesty Int'l needs to get a clue about the public erasure of women's identities
RelativelyJones
Aug 2018
#236
Awesome! Let us know how your effort to educate the worlds foremost human rights org goes.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#238
Even Amnesty Intl gets some things wrong, assuming this person speaks for them.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#243
LOL. No way you could be wrong. It must be Amnesty International that is in error. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#244
I find hilarious your inability to let a differing opinion stand without trying to negate it.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#250
Not in the least. Your opinions are not facts. Let others have their opinions. (nt)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#282
If you think my statements of fact are opinions, why are you so bothered by them?
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#285
Islamophobia is not going to take hold on the Left as it has on the right...
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#258
If burqa bans are Islamophobic, why did Morrocco, which is 99% Muslim, ban them?
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#262
That's a great article, that shows Muslims deciding their own policy, for themselves.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#264
Why is that relevant, unless you believe only Muslims should issue burqa bans? nt
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#273
No, I said Morocco is not Denmark. Slow down and take a breath... you're slipping. (nt)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#278
So why are you fine with the Morocco burqa ban, but not the Denmark burqa ban? nt
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#295
Because Morocco's decision was made by people with cultural familiarity w the burqa.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#296
Anyone who had that familiarity wouldn't make the ignorant claims u have made. Still waiting. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#299
If that's a lie, why are you fine with the Morocco burqa ban, but not Denmark's?
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#302
It's gratifying that you must resort to lies to continue your filibuster. Thanks for the laffs!
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#303
Not being a referendum, the Danish Parliament are the Danes of which I spoke.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#313
I did not ignore anything. You're fine with the Morocco burqa ban, but not the Danish one.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#317
Again, you suggest that unless the legislator is Muslim, they shouldn't vote to ban burquas.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#319
The good news is 340 posts and only 8 recs shows in how little regard DUers hold racist policies.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#340
"All women should be free to dress as they please" But what if I want to wear a Burqa?
McCamy Taylor
Aug 2018
#342