Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Latest Breaking News
In reply to the discussion: Denmark's Burqa Ban Has Gone Into Effect [View all]McCamy Taylor
(19,240 posts)342. "All women should be free to dress as they please" But what if I want to wear a Burqa?
I hate fashion police.

Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
361 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Like men, they can wear hats, turbans and scarves. Like men, they can't cover their faces,
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#3
Unlike men, they can't wear certain garments dictated by religious law or custom.
Orsino
Aug 2018
#19
Unlike most who opine about this, I actually know women who are forced to wear a burka. I
Squinch
Aug 2018
#359
Good for Denmark. Push back on these repressives and their attempts to normalize it.
7962
Aug 2018
#9
I agree. These religions that make women 2nd class citizens make me vomit.
WhoWoodaKnew
Aug 2018
#115
Saw exactly that in Sydney several years ago. A woman in a burka pushing a stroller with a
Floyd R. Turbo
Aug 2018
#21
My objection is neither about religion, nor racism. The state should not outlaw styles of dress.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#16
It prevents people from being ID'd in public. I think the state has a valid interest.
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#17
That arg falsely links Islam w crime. when ski masks are illegal, ur argument may make some sense.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#20
It is illegal to walk around in public wearing a ski mask in Denmark, per this law.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#22
No, it is not silly at all. People only wear ski masks when skiing or when it's freezing. nt.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#30
It's silly (or perhaps just uncivil) to demand people keep visible faces. Paranoia is not policy. Nt
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#31
It is not silly nor paranoid to require people show their faces when in public. nt
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#34
Many things are a security risk. This calculation is being made in part bc the affected population
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#58
The affected population could be ANYONE. In the NW, we had a couple women walking around
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#78
It could be - but in this case it is those who wear the burqa who are affected.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#80
The word "everyone" u use so casually in your post betrays the lack of depth of thinking.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#68
You must be joking. Did you read this piece? A POC misidentified as a criminal is in peril.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#71
It's not too surprising when a machine set on 80% is wrong 20%+ of the time.
EX500rider
Aug 2018
#105
Male legislators should not be mandating what women can & can't wear. Taliban & Danes do that.
Bernardo de La Paz
Aug 2018
#325
Face coverings aren't clothes. They're masks. This law applies to both sexes.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#346
Law also prevents LGBTQ from hiding faces when going into LGBTQ events. THAT'S oppressive too. . nt
Bernardo de La Paz
Aug 2018
#326
The existence of surveillance tech does not mean the people an obligation to submit to surveillance.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#53
Many things are a security risk, priorities of rights curtailed are based in cultural perceptions.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#59
sunglasses? Wide rimmed hats? Surgical masks? Eye patches? Where does it end?
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#76
None of those things completely obscure the face except for the eyes, like a ski mask
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#85
White woman fashion A-OKAY but muslim woman can't make their own choices?
Bernardo de La Paz
Aug 2018
#334
Until the woman herself rejects the burqa, your assumption of her opinions is sexist. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#92
Not at all, that's a tragic reality around the world. Limiting their choices isnt how to redress it
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#329
I'm not saying we should ban their clothing. Just ALL face masks, whether it's a man or a woman
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#330
Of course not. But is sexist for male legislators to oppress women's choices.
Bernardo de La Paz
Aug 2018
#338
You are assuming wrong. There is an extremely low incidence of voter fraud, even in states
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#107
People can be ID'ed if needed. Otherwise go whole hog and embed a radio transmitter chip in arm. .nt
Bernardo de La Paz
Aug 2018
#323
How? Rip a burqa off a woman who's hit me and refuses to show herself? Or a man under a ski mask?
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#327
Of course you didn't take a photo of the driver. You could SEE s/he matched the driver's license.
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#348
Yeah, it does matter. If someone has hit me, it matters who that person was. n/t
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#350
Snore. Let the police handle stolen licenses. Don't try it yourself. Gosh. . . . nt
Bernardo de La Paz
Aug 2018
#354
I have to laugh at all the MEN defending women's "right" to wear those oppressive garments,
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#355
Hopefully the oppressed are willing to continue to pay for the delay with their lives and freedom.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#72
If "a cultural subgroup's practice" is cruel and inhumain it should be ruled against
Merlot
Aug 2018
#84
Like totally unfair...Xenophobic , Reminds me of the rabid antiabortion freaks in americu..
Maxheader
Aug 2018
#25
the fact they do not tell the difference between a niqab and burja is ignorance
DonCoquixote
Aug 2018
#28
+1. Americans know that racism as foundation of policy is bad. Refusing to cop to it is worse. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#33
You seem personally invested in negating disagreeing opinions on this. But you can't.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#43
You are not the people of Denmark. That's not your place. You are one individual. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#45
You are one person, and your job is not to naysay everyone else here with opinion claimed as facts.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#49
Your posts declare the intent and effect of the policy as having nothing to do with race. Opinion.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#96
A law need not acknowledge it is racist in order to be racist. I'm surprised you tried this argument
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#113
Potentially, many things. Perhaps you should stop talking and start thinking. (nt)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#119
You can't answer because it's not. Nor are bans on female genital mutilation.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#127
Your error? "misogynistic, backwards, debilitating cultural practices" is opinion, not fact (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#128
You really think burqas and FGM are not misogynistic, backwards, debilitating cultural practices?
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#129
I try not to make absolutist value judgments about other cultural practices than mine. It's racist.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#130
Defending FGM on DU!! - who would have thought this day would come? n/t
Fix The Stupid
Aug 2018
#134
How is it racist? Are we not allowed to stop backwards practices that debilitate women?
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#136
Foot binding! It's a beautiful, cultural tradition! How dare we criticize it!
Coventina
Aug 2018
#138
You're thoroughly incorrect. And you are also entitled to your opinion, as am I. Cheers!
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#149
LOL, the bad logic in your post is what is laughable. Are all women wearing burqa forced? NO. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#154
So you are in favor of forced assimilation? But see no problem conflating FGM and the burqa?
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#157
Nope. If it was a cultural issue, then all Muslim men would continue to wear the thawb.
Coventina
Aug 2018
#159
Yup. But your use of the word "all" in that comment is pure stupidity and racist absolutism.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#162
No, it's holding another culture to your personal (not even your culture's) standards. Xenophobia.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#165
No, emigration doesn't work that way, unless it is to a totalitarian state. Freedom of expression
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#169
No, there is no such thing as being able to express yourself however you want.
Coventina
Aug 2018
#172
Wearing a burqa is a form of expression. It is, and should be, tolerated in many societies.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#174
It's super cute that you think you can demand an entire society of people abandon their practices
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#179
"Entire society of people"? No, just that Muslim women enjoy the same rights as their men.
Coventina
Aug 2018
#181
Feminists listen to women and ask them their values. White saviors speak for them without listening
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#183
It sure seems to matter to you, as you have been attacking my opinions as if they threaten you.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#190
Real feminism requires real work. The burqa is not shorthand for male oppression, and outlawing it
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#194
Okay, it's been fun but you aren't being honest so I'm done feeding you. See post 200.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#203
LOL! Your shift is probably coming to an end by now. Have a great day! (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#214
The idea of you spending a precious vacation day arguing racist trash is what's really funny.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#220
"I try not to make absolutist value judgments about other cultural practices than mine. It's racist"
EX500rider
Aug 2018
#224
Dishonestly omitting "absolute" when quoting me and equating human sacrifice to burqa...
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#232
Your post is Dishonest. U omitted the word absolutist from my quote, and that's dishonest. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#237
No, paraphrasing me u said NO judgment can be made, a dishonest contradiction of my point. (Nt)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#240
Well I for sure can be absolutest in my condemnation of certain cultural practices..
EX500rider
Aug 2018
#241
No, but the assertion that a nijab would be banned is an incorrect statement of fact.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#48
I didn't say a nijab would be. And laws are based on many factors... this one clearly reflects race.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#50
That's your opinion, and I never made no such assertion that such coverings would be banned.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#99
No, you typed "+1" which means you agree with everything in the post. A fact.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#103
I can agree with the post without agreeing with your interpretation of the post. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#112
Do you understand this law does not ban hair coverings as pictured in that post you agree with? nt
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#118
Do you understand how to let others have opinions with which you disagree? Like, wearing burqas? nt
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#131
I'm not defl3cting. Why are you attacking those with whom you disagree? Difference of opinion
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#150
Sexism super bad. If women do not voluntarily abandon the hijab, assuming they want to is sexist. nt
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#91
Wrong. Both of them fully obscure the face, except for the eyes. The only difference
pnwmom
Aug 2018
#87
And people of color r vastly misrecognized by this tech (predominantly written/trained by non POCs)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#60
My support for this "burqa ban" does not equal support for facial recognition surveillance
Devil Child
Aug 2018
#74
The irony is that the people on DU outraged about this ban as somehow oppressive
GulfCoast66
Aug 2018
#114
Ferengi are similar oppressive. woman are nude,not allowed in public or to own businesses.
Sunlei
Aug 2018
#126
Sorry, that category has been done to death by those of you declaring this a one sided issue.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#155
Some Muslim women adopt western dress in the West, and not all women who wear burqa are forced.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#160
If they want to wear the burqa, they should go to a country where that is the norm.
Coventina
Aug 2018
#161
That is a fundamentally racist statement. That isn't your decision to make. It's theirs.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#163
A culture is neither rejected, nor adopted, wholesale. That is a foolish notion.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#167
Then why are you interfering with those individuals' right to choose their own mode of dress?
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#171
Your spam posts here do exactly that. A burqa does not erase identity if a woman chooses it.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#175
That is the entire purpose of a burqa? Says you... a non-Arab, non-Muslim? Did you study Islam?
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#180
Yes, as a matter of fact I have studied Islam. I have Muslim students who tell me
Coventina
Aug 2018
#182
Any educated educator would never freely use the absolutist language you do.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#184
Not projection. You used absolutist lterms inappropriate to the realities of cultural interaction.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#189
Cultural interaction is what I teach. I am well aware of what is oppressive and what is not.
Coventina
Aug 2018
#191
Nor is demanding all immigrants to a society assimilate in full, as u did above.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#193
Don't be dishonest. U said "If they want to live in the west, then they should adopt western dress"
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#196
All women should be free to dress as they please and to wear clothing that expresses their identity
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#200
The it's you on one side of this argument, and me and Amnesty International on the other.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#208
I value the opinions of the world's human rights authorities over anecdotes deployed to racist ends
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#213
If being anti-burqa is YOUR definition of racist, then there are a LOT of "racists" here on DU.
Coventina
Aug 2018
#215
Says you. And since you are not a woman who wears one, it's not your call to make for them.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#221
And, as I've said before, I had nothing to do with this decision, I merely applaud it.
Coventina
Aug 2018
#223
Sunseeker, meet Coventina. You seem to disagree with each other about the legality of the burqa.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#234
Me too. But I wouldn't presume to ban it outright, I would let Muslim women decide for themselves.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#246
Letting women decide for themselves is misogyny? You can't be serious with this trash. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#249
You are not the one to decide if another person has an identity or not based on their clothing.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#256
You are not the one to decide if a person's identity is obliterated by their choice of covering.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#260
A non Muslim can assuredly tell Muslim women the purpose of the burqa? Nonsense. nt
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#280
Thank god you arrived to tell everyone what we were and weren't already talking about! nt
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#339
Danish culture does not allow the valuing of women as second class. FULL STOP
RelativelyJones
Aug 2018
#230
Then Amnesty Int'l needs to get a clue about the public erasure of women's identities
RelativelyJones
Aug 2018
#236
Awesome! Let us know how your effort to educate the worlds foremost human rights org goes.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#238
Even Amnesty Intl gets some things wrong, assuming this person speaks for them.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#243
LOL. No way you could be wrong. It must be Amnesty International that is in error. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#244
I find hilarious your inability to let a differing opinion stand without trying to negate it.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#250
Not in the least. Your opinions are not facts. Let others have their opinions. (nt)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#282
If you think my statements of fact are opinions, why are you so bothered by them?
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#285
Islamophobia is not going to take hold on the Left as it has on the right...
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#258
If burqa bans are Islamophobic, why did Morrocco, which is 99% Muslim, ban them?
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#262
That's a great article, that shows Muslims deciding their own policy, for themselves.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#264
Why is that relevant, unless you believe only Muslims should issue burqa bans? nt
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#273
No, I said Morocco is not Denmark. Slow down and take a breath... you're slipping. (nt)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#278
So why are you fine with the Morocco burqa ban, but not the Denmark burqa ban? nt
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#295
Because Morocco's decision was made by people with cultural familiarity w the burqa.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#296
Anyone who had that familiarity wouldn't make the ignorant claims u have made. Still waiting. (n/t)
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#299
If that's a lie, why are you fine with the Morocco burqa ban, but not Denmark's?
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#302
It's gratifying that you must resort to lies to continue your filibuster. Thanks for the laffs!
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#303
Not being a referendum, the Danish Parliament are the Danes of which I spoke.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#313
I did not ignore anything. You're fine with the Morocco burqa ban, but not the Danish one.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#317
Again, you suggest that unless the legislator is Muslim, they shouldn't vote to ban burquas.
SunSeeker
Aug 2018
#319
The good news is 340 posts and only 8 recs shows in how little regard DUers hold racist policies.
FreepFryer
Aug 2018
#340
"All women should be free to dress as they please" But what if I want to wear a Burqa?
McCamy Taylor
Aug 2018
#342