Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

mr_lebowski

(33,643 posts)
9. It's on top of normal unemployment benefits, and it's also generally not taxed
Wed Aug 5, 2020, 01:44 PM
Aug 2020

until you pay taxes in April, plus ttbomk there's not other taxes like SS/Medicare.

If you normally make $10/hour, that's $400/week. After taxes, more like $300.

Your regular UI benefit is probably around $200 in that case. Thus, with the $600 bonus, it's now $800/week.

Eyeballing the math here ... by becoming unemployed and staying home, you've received a raise from $10 for working ... to $26.66/hr for not working. Granted you'll lose some of that in taxes owned next year, but I bet most people are thinking 'I'll worry about that come April'.

A great many people are indeed going to calculate that it doesn't makes sense for them to go back to work, given how much they would lose by doing so.

To be clear, I'm not saying *I CARE* that many people are going to make that decision. I don't. I'm fine with it. I don't think ANYONE should only be making $10/hour. I favor pumping money into the bottom of the economy like this, when there is a good reason for it (and this is a good reason for it).

But a significant number of people are going to stay home and collect their big raise. It's human nature.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Alabama will elect his stupid racist ass anyhow The Velveteen Ocelot Aug 2020 #1
Tuberville sounds about as bright as a potato NickB79 Aug 2020 #2
Tom-ato Potato. TheCowsCameHome Aug 2020 #3
Make these senators get by on $600 a week. See how easy it is. rickyhall Aug 2020 #4
It's on top of normal unemployment benefits, and it's also generally not taxed mr_lebowski Aug 2020 #9
What unemployment benefits? Most of those ran out. Have they been extended? Bengus81 Aug 2020 #13
But if they don't have jobs they don't have health insurance either. The Velveteen Ocelot Aug 2020 #17
To be clear, I agree w/everything you just said ... mr_lebowski Aug 2020 #26
lots of jobs don't offer insurance because they're part-time. Nt raccoon Aug 2020 #36
You lose all UI benefits, including the $600, if you are called back to work Tiger8 Aug 2020 #22
Right ... so the people called back to work are not the population he'd be addressing in this case. mr_lebowski Aug 2020 #27
I think you're forgetting something... GB_RN Aug 2020 #23
Yeah, and I kinda think that part is bullshit too ... making people go back to non-essential work mr_lebowski Aug 2020 #28
The employee loses unemployment IF the employer reports them MichMan Aug 2020 #32
The Average MONTHLY Cost of Living in the US..... louzke9 Aug 2020 #30
I do think it could be reasonably argued that it should be sliding scale, like the benefit itself mr_lebowski Aug 2020 #5
We SHOULD be incentivizing staying home Withywindle Aug 2020 #37
The unemployed should get the same amount as Cam Newton got to transfer to Auburn Coleman Aug 2020 #6
A fuckin' men! Traildogbob Aug 2020 #31
He should get along just fine with Moscow Mitch then. n/t totodeinhere Aug 2020 #7
I think a lot of people miss why it was set that high. People on unemployment have to spend the LiberalArkie Aug 2020 #8
"What in the heck is a 33% drop in GDP called?" Jedi Guy Aug 2020 #11
Exactly GreenPartyVoter Aug 2020 #12
And...unlike Trumps tax cut give away for the rich these benefits WILL sunset Bengus81 Aug 2020 #14
And who says that the voters actually vote them in any more? LiberalArkie Aug 2020 #15
Why not set it at $1000 per week then? MichMan Aug 2020 #33
If you want to see the economy grow - Give us seniors an extra $1000 a week from the fed. LiberalArkie Aug 2020 #34
Of course you would Tommy TRUMPERville. amb123 Aug 2020 #10
I wrote a long, reasoned response but tossed it. F**k you Tubby Trumperville, and the tractor you BamaRefugee Aug 2020 #16
It's probably going to have to be changed to be whatever the person earned per week prior to losing cstanleytech Aug 2020 #18
So basically making total chaos for the system durablend Aug 2020 #19
That is what we have computers for. cstanleytech Aug 2020 #20
lol my sweet summer child obamanut2012 Aug 2020 #39
I bet the unemployed idiots will still vote for him. ananda Aug 2020 #21
If the benefit goes away, the economy tanks even more MissMillie Aug 2020 #24
This tests his theory: have wages risen? Cicada Aug 2020 #25
OK. If Tommy Tuba wins in AL, we'll pay him $200/week. lagomorph777 Aug 2020 #29
Too high for the common folk-- not the 100's of thousands of dollars an employed football coach gets andym Aug 2020 #35
Tuberville: People should just eat cake sakabatou Aug 2020 #38
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»GOP Senate nominee: $600 ...»Reply #9