Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

MichMan

(17,150 posts)
36. The OP isn't about states/counties/ cities. It is about Federal mandates for public transportation.
Fri Apr 22, 2022, 06:45 AM
Apr 2022

As you stated, the CDC by itself has no power to set mandates, however the administration bases federal policy on those CDC recommendations. When asked, the administration defers to the CDC as being the experts.

Even after nearly all states withdrew mask mandates, the CDC kept them in place for public transportation until May 3, and the administration agreed with that recommendation. My statement regarding keeping it in place after May 3 was strictly referring to the public transportation rules. Rules on which the administration believes they have the authority to set, or they wouldn't be appealing the recent court decision. The Federal government clearly does not have the authority to set nationwide mask mandates, which is why they deferred to the states from day one.

The fact that many people are questioning the decisions made by state and local elected politicians as being based on political considerations vs health concerns shows the lack of trust and cynicism of the public towards their elected representatives. The rapidly shifting mandates since the beginning of the pandemic have only exacerbated those levels of cynicism.


Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Good LetMyPeopleVote Apr 2022 #1
Oh the confusion. THE CONFUSION! underpants Apr 2022 #2
Should be Executive Branch with input from CDC and others. Hoyt Apr 2022 #3
will there be any ruling before May 3rd? pstokely Apr 2022 #6
According to the Washington Post article that is linked: gldstwmn Apr 2022 #15
Hard to say at this point FBaggins Apr 2022 #19
Kicking for visibility SheltieLover Apr 2022 #4
The mandate should remain for public transportation. sheshe2 Apr 2022 #5
Republicans are not a democratic party, they are the insurrection party YoshidaYui Apr 2022 #7
Once they win, it needs to be extended until the end of the year. MichMan Apr 2022 #8
That sounds like a great way to lose a ton of seats in November. Ace Rothstein Apr 2022 #17
56% of Americans favor a mask mandate on planes, trains and public transportation while 24% opposed MichMan Apr 2022 #18
We'll find out pretty quickly whether that poll has any validity FBaggins Apr 2022 #20
Real life says otherwise. Ace Rothstein Apr 2022 #26
That is exactly why the mandate needs to be extended for several months then. MichMan Apr 2022 #27
Why isn't that an argument for mask mandates in general? FBaggins Apr 2022 #29
Ask the CDC. They are the ones setting the policy MichMan Apr 2022 #32
No they aren't FBaggins Apr 2022 #35
The OP isn't about states/counties/ cities. It is about Federal mandates for public transportation. MichMan Apr 2022 #36
The thread then turned to political implications FBaggins Apr 2022 #37
Elected officials will need to explain their decisions to their own constituents MichMan Apr 2022 #38
Tues/Weds Travel Observations unweird Apr 2022 #28
How many on the flight were masked? FBaggins Apr 2022 #30
Smaller sample unweird Apr 2022 #33
Glad to see this stupid ruling being appealed ificandream Apr 2022 #9
I'm sure... Snackshack Apr 2022 #10
DOJ was was the one who proposed to do it BumRushDaShow Apr 2022 #13
That still doesn't mean that they'll fight it very agressively FBaggins Apr 2022 #22
We will have to wait to see what they do? BumRushDaShow Apr 2022 #23
Sure - but the speculation in #10 is still valid until we do FBaggins Apr 2022 #24
Note that a significant chunk of DU has insulted DOJ for things unrelated to this BumRushDaShow Apr 2022 #25
It no longer matters to me.. SouthernDem4ever Apr 2022 #11
I think it should be mandatory that people aren't so fucking stupid. twodogsbarking Apr 2022 #12
This is why Plato said of democracy: "Wait, you gonna let stupid people vote?" tclambert Apr 2022 #34
Good. Owl Apr 2022 #14
Their side can kill themselves while our side keeps masking IronLionZion Apr 2022 #16
I wish they could remove Judge Mizelle from the bench Mr. Sparkle Apr 2022 #21
Good rockfordfile Apr 2022 #31
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»CDC asks Justice Departme...»Reply #36