Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NNadir

(37,966 posts)
19. I don't "guess." If the Chinese lived the way Americans do, the atmosphere would...
Wed Oct 26, 2022, 11:04 PM
Oct 2022

...complete its collapse much faster than it is right now, and the collapse is accelerating, not decelerating.

"Per capita" is not adjusted to include only the poor or only the rich. It's an average, based on the entire population.

I read all the whining by Americans in their consumer society about Indian and Chinese emissions as completely oblivious and contemptuous.

An American living like the average Indian would consider himself, herself or themselves impoverished.

I have been to India and what I saw is out of the purview of smug Americans who think they're going to save the world by staring at pictures of wind turbines, solar cells and electric cars, while the amount of coal and gas Americans burn, dumping the waste into the planetary atmosphere, on average, per person, disgusts the rest of the world, and with good reason.

Chinese and Indians may not agree that they should live in dire poverty, overall, so oblivious Americans can declare themselves "green."

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

The worst climate offenders are .. at140 Oct 2022 #1
Of course, on a per capita basis, it's not even close which country is the worst on the planet. NNadir Oct 2022 #7
It isn't the poor people of those two nations producing the greenhouse gases Kaleva Oct 2022 #10
No. It is people climbing out of poverty the same way Americans did, burning fossil fuels. NNadir Oct 2022 #13
I'm saying you need to compare apples to apples Kaleva Oct 2022 #16
I don't "guess." If the Chinese lived the way Americans do, the atmosphere would... NNadir Oct 2022 #19
Well, we didnt KNOW 100yrs ago what we know now. Either you want change or not. oldsoftie Oct 2022 #27
We are still burning coal. We want to pretend that by looking... NNadir Oct 2022 #33
But are we building 100s of new coal plants? No. oldsoftie Oct 2022 #42
Look, we burn coal and have been doing so on a massive scale for over... NNadir Oct 2022 #46
Well you can blame the "greens" for the dearth of nuclear here. oldsoftie Oct 2022 #49
My son is a Ph.D student in nuclear engineering. NNadir Oct 2022 #52
All true. But how to get everyone to UNDERSTAND this?? oldsoftie Oct 2022 #54
I've been in favor of nuclear energy ever since 1987, when I started to understand... NNadir Oct 2022 #57
I've certainly gotten a lot of pushback here for backing nuclear power as well. oldsoftie Oct 2022 #58
I've heard so many "major breakthroughs" over my lifetime, I have a very jaundiced view of them... NNadir Oct 2022 #59
Thank you! oldsoftie Oct 2022 #60
Middle class in India is bigger than middle class in USA at140 Oct 2022 #21
If I have time, I may look for numbers. Kaleva Oct 2022 #32
Do not use median income as your criteria at140 Oct 2022 #38
That's because a large segment of the population is poor Kaleva Oct 2022 #40
Correct. Standard of living is much higher in India at140 Oct 2022 #41
My stepdaughter went to India a few years ago Kaleva Oct 2022 #48
Your daughters observation is correct at140 Oct 2022 #50
So let the "poor" of other countries "catch up" & continue polluting? oldsoftie Oct 2022 #26
Hope this will set off alarms everywhere LT Barclay Oct 2022 #2
I doubt it. Kaleva Oct 2022 #6
So do I, but the reality we are approaching is quite disturbing. LT Barclay Oct 2022 #18
Almost everyday I'm doing something towards my goal of adapting to what is expected to come. Kaleva Oct 2022 #24
Prepping/ prepper? OtterDave Oct 2022 #31
Preparing to adapt to what respected experts predict is coming Kaleva Oct 2022 #34
I love gardening as well OtterDave Oct 2022 #36
Yes. So I don't consider it work. More of an enjoyable hobby! Kaleva Oct 2022 #37
I've been concerned about food supply disruption and I want my family to start gardening, even if it LT Barclay Oct 2022 #53
I've been thinking about what you wrote and will offer my advice tomorrow Kaleva Oct 2022 #55
Well thank you! LT Barclay Oct 2022 #56
Some thoughts Kaleva Oct 2022 #61
Good thoughts. My idea of the garden is more of a buffer against extreme price increases. LT Barclay Oct 2022 #62
I'll reiterate: NullTuples Oct 2022 #3
That's an average. Some regions will become much hotter Kaleva Oct 2022 #5
China is now the largest producer of greenhouse gases. Twice as much as the US Kaleva Oct 2022 #4
I commented on the myopia associated with this blame in post #7. NNadir Oct 2022 #8
And I replied to your post stating why I think you are wrong Kaleva Oct 2022 #11
Not really. Americans are not more worthy human beings than Indians or Chinese. NNadir Oct 2022 #14
In 2035, we will have zero emissions jimfields33 Oct 2022 #9
Yes but that won't make a difference if the rest of the world doesn't follow suit Kaleva Oct 2022 #12
Most of this type of soothsaying is delusional, this more so than most. NNadir Oct 2022 #15
Don't know. Use of electric will lower the cost of fuel, right wingers will buy even bigger trucks LT Barclay Oct 2022 #17
No, maybe in some but not all states, only new electric cars will be sold, Dysfunctional Oct 2022 #20
And we'll never have the required infrastructure for total electric anyway. oldsoftie Oct 2022 #43
"All vehicles electric" is ANOTHER pipe dream. oldsoftie Oct 2022 #28
A total fantasy. former9thward Oct 2022 #51
We are soooooooo fucked Javaman Oct 2022 #22
We're Doomed. Heather MC Oct 2022 #23
And that's before accounting for global inflation's reduction of the value of those pledges... nt Starfury Oct 2022 #25
Don't forget the amounts of pollution added to the atmosphere by Putins war oldsoftie Oct 2022 #29
While the US could do more melm00se Oct 2022 #30
Won't help if other nations don't follow suit Kaleva Oct 2022 #35
China and India are rapidly developing nuclear energy. Elessar Zappa Oct 2022 #47
They are also building coal fired power plants Kaleva Oct 2022 #64
Very disturbing. I think its going to take a massive disaster to finally get everyone's attention. honest.abe Oct 2022 #39
I marched in DC about Renewable Energies back in the 80's after Reagan... electric_blue68 Oct 2022 #44
The world does this together or fails. Torchlight Oct 2022 #45
Big fail coming. roamer65 Oct 2022 #63
If you are truly serious about understanding climate change ... jgo Oct 2022 #65
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Greenhouse gases reach a ...»Reply #19