Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NullTuples

(6,017 posts)
49. The controversy goes back to when Michelangelo was still alive.
Mon Mar 27, 2023, 02:44 PM
Mar 2023

M. himself argued that David should be given "decoration" when the statue was placed. He carved them accurately according to the style, but also realized they were going to be visible to the public. It *may* have been a political concession.

Shortly before he died, Bishops went around and covered all of the penises he'd carved onto his statues. Or hacked them off completely. There were a lot of them, by the way.

"In 1563, the year before Michelangelo died, the Council of Trent banned "lasciviousness" in religious imagery, and a dedicated campaign of figging began. Mostly this was just a question of covering up, but, in the 1800s, Pope Pius IX went further, and had the genitalia hacked off completely. I remember a historian saying, some years ago, that the Vatican, great collectors that they are, have crates of severed penises somewhere in their vaults."

From:

"Why the ancient Greeks didn’t make a big deal of penis size
A Cork gallery has removed the fig leaves from its statues, showing that small is beautiful"

And since people seem to be discussing this aspect as well:
"...in ancient Greece, which is the inspiration and source for a great deal of Renaissance art, a large penis wasn’t something to shout about. Instead, a smaller size was associated with good citizenry and intellectual pursuits."

https://www.irishtimes.com/culture/why-the-ancient-greeks-didn-t-make-a-big-deal-of-penis-size-1.3953929

And from here:
https://www.artsy.net/article/artsy-editorial-ancient-greek-sculptures-small-penises





Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

If I was that principal I'd be on the first flight to Italy I could. dem4decades Mar 2023 #1
If the statue of David were porn, his dick would be erect ... Earth-shine Mar 2023 #2
You just read my mind tornado34jh Mar 2023 #4
It was the Puritans who settled here first. ProudMNDemocrat Mar 2023 #20
It goes back further than that. tornado34jh Mar 2023 #23
Well, that's the story they want you to believe jmowreader Mar 2023 #54
Aaye 3auld6phart Mar 2023 #52
So trump can't do porn? BOSSHOG Mar 2023 #19
They look like trans angels to me. Beastly Boy Mar 2023 #27
I mean, angels were neither male nor female. NullTuples Mar 2023 #48
Michelangelo's defense is that he only painted someone's idea of God. Marcuse Mar 2023 #32
What I remember is that he didn't want to paint the chapel. Earth-shine Mar 2023 #34
Honestly, this is getting ridiculous tornado34jh Mar 2023 #3
Interestingly Europe went through what Florida is going through hundreds of years ago Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Mar 2023 #6
Seems just like you would see in the Dark Ages tornado34jh Mar 2023 #18
Guess not. Maybe no ART classes. or MUSIC. elleng Mar 2023 #10
Only their "Southern" music and art are allowed tornado34jh Mar 2023 #21
i am getting fed up with this nonsense. hope seawater floods florida soon. AllaN01Bear Mar 2023 #5
Just keep tabs on Thwaites Glacier. Mr. Evil Mar 2023 #8
Thanks. very good article riversedge Mar 2023 #40
i wonder what is on their devices? hmmmmm. AllaN01Bear Mar 2023 #16
6th grade? Hate to break it to the parents, but paleotn Mar 2023 #7
This Is Exactly RobinA Mar 2023 #37
'Confusing art with pornography was "ridiculous," Nardella said.' elleng Mar 2023 #9
We truly have the stupidest people on the planet in this country iemanja Mar 2023 #11
I don't mind them being stupid. rsdsharp Mar 2023 #12
Stupid, ignorant, evil, immoral, dangerous. Irish_Dem Mar 2023 #13
Is the donald porn? truthisfreedom Mar 2023 #14
Advice to Italians: Don't waste your time with Floridians. Sneederbunk Mar 2023 #15
No, that's a defeatist attitude, and it will exacerbate the existing harm. elleng Mar 2023 #22
DeSantis is of Italian ancestry. Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Mar 2023 #31
This orangecrush Mar 2023 #45
And please don't let your children know that some man stuck something in their mother! erronis Mar 2023 #17
Taliban enigmania Mar 2023 #24
Art Squad UnderThisLaw Mar 2023 #25
Perhaps DUH_Santis and the insecure pukes.. raising2moredems Mar 2023 #26
David "porn" means that the USA has truly reached the tipping point of no return f_townsend Mar 2023 #28
Better Close All Of The Major Art Museums In America OhioTim Mar 2023 #29
I guess the GQP wouldn't approve of my light switch plate BigmanPigman Mar 2023 #30
Remember when Ashcroft covered that statue's breasts?! Behind the Aegis Mar 2023 #33
Yep, I remember. n/t area51 Mar 2023 #41
How embarrassing Bayard Mar 2023 #35
When a third of a country thinks [using the term loosely] like this, why wouldn't they? Wonder Why Mar 2023 #51
Is this porn? keithbvadu2 Mar 2023 #36
oh YUK--I want to UNse that!! riversedge Mar 2023 #43
Keep thumping that bible The Jungle 1 Mar 2023 #38
Repugs in the USA have once AGAIN made us a Laughingstock!! riversedge Mar 2023 #39
"incident was another episode in escalating U.S. culture wars and questioned how the statue could be riversedge Mar 2023 #42
Fixed. CrispyQ Mar 2023 #44
It was likely 1 parent at that "Classical" school that complained. maxsolomon Mar 2023 #46
Good grief moose65 Mar 2023 #47
The controversy goes back to when Michelangelo was still alive. NullTuples Mar 2023 #49
If Florida is labeling things like this as porn then will they be eviciting and or arresting Trump? cstanleytech Mar 2023 #50
I remember when a copy of Picasso's "Guernica" on the wall of the United Nations was curtained CTyankee Mar 2023 #53
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Is the David porn? Come s...»Reply #49